Research Article
INEH-VNS Algorithm Solved Automatic Production System Scheduling Problem under Just-in-Time Environment
Table 9
Comparison standard deviation between the INEH-VNS algorithm, the G-VNS algorithm, and the SA algorithm when
and
.
| Tank | 15 | 20 | STSA | STG-VNS | STINEH-VNS | (%) | (%) | STSA | STG-VNS | STINEH-VNS | (%) | (%) |
| 2 | 190.55 | 91.40 | 153.56 | 19.41 | -68.01 | 341.35 | 163.34 | 45.46 | 86.68 | 72.17 | 4 | 1067.12 | 207.40 | 121.74 | 88.59 | 41.30 | 1037.31 | 264.67 | 255.50 | 75.37 | 3.46 | 6 | 1757.07 | 280.04 | 21.84 | 98.76 | 92.20 | 1687.32 | 569.50 | 8.34 | 99.51 | 98.53 | 8 | 2515.67 | 472.49 | 162.06 | 93.56 | 65.70 | 2422.99 | 636.79 | 144.54 | 94.03 | 77.30 | 10 | 1639.26 | 399.43 | 152.27 | 90.71 | 61.88 | 3144.65 | 743.05 | 203.85 | 93.52 | 72.57 | 12 | 2277.20 | 392.36 | 302.40 | 86.72 | 22.93 | 2789.35 | 628.26 | 145.73 | 94.78 | 76.80 | 14 | 2613.79 | 613.04 | 288.78 | 88.95 | 52.89 | 5319.97 | 1386.70 | 400.55 | 92.47 | 71.11 | 16 | 3802.75 | 622.98 | 240.98 | 93.66 | 61.32 | 4752.51 | 1023.85 | 19.95 | 99.58 | 98.05 | 18 | 3613.17 | 312.13 | 317.07 | 91.22 | -1.58 | 3108.78 | 994.65 | 415.17 | 86.65 | 58.26 | 20 | 4172.77 | 615.93 | 138.41 | 96.68 | 77.53 | 4102.68 | 2193.45 | 379.71 | 90.74 | 82.69 |
|
|
The symbol bold’ indicates the best improvement rate and the worst improvement rate.
|