- About this Journal
- Abstracting and Indexing
- Aims and Scope
- Annual Issues
- Article Processing Charges
- Articles in Press
- Author Guidelines
- Bibliographic Information
- Citations to this Journal
- Contact Information
- Editorial Board
- Editorial Workflow
- Free eTOC Alerts
- Publication Ethics
- Reviewers Acknowledgment
- Submit a Manuscript
- Subscription Information
- Table of Contents
Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society
Volume 2012 (2012), Article ID 273164, 16 pages
A Real-Time Lane Detection Algorithm Based on Intelligent CCD Parameters Regulation
1College of Electromechanical and Information Engineering, Dalian Nationalities University, Dalian, Liaoning 116600, China
2School of Automotive Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, Liaoning 116024, China
3Xinjiang Technical Institute of Physics and Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Urumqi 830011, China
Received 27 August 2012; Revised 23 November 2012; Accepted 27 November 2012
Academic Editor: Wuhong Wang
Copyright © 2012 Ping-shu Ge et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Lane departure warning system (LDWS) has been regarded as an efficient method to lessen the damages of road traffic accident resulting from driver fatigue or inattention. Lane detection is one of the key techniques for LDWS. To overcome the contradiction between complexity of algorithm and the real-time requirement for vehicle onboard system, this paper introduces a new lane detection method based on intelligent CCD parameters regulation. In order to improve the real-time capability of the system, a CCD parameters regulating method is proposed which enhances the contrast between lane line and road surfaces and reduces image noise, so it lays a good foundation for the following lane detection. Hough transform algorithm is improved by selection and classification of seed points. Finally the lane line is extracted through some restrictions. Experimental results verify the effectiveness of the proposed method, which improves not only real-time capability but also the accuracy of the system.
With the rapid development of expressway and the growth of motor vehicle quantities, the traffic accidents, especially mass traffic accidents, are increasing and become one of the most serious problems around the world [1–4]. For low-income and middle-income countries, this situation is much worse. A report from World Health Organization (WHO) points out that over 90% of the world’s fatalities on the roads occur in low-income and middle-income countries, which have only 48% of the world’s registered vehicles. It has been estimated that, unless immediate action is taken, road traffic deaths will rise to the fifth leading cause of death by the year 2030, resulting in an estimated 2.4 million fatalities per year . The global status report on road safety clearly shows that significantly more action is needed to make the world’s roads safer. At present, the increase trend of traffic accidents and causalities in China has been slowed down to some extent and shows a declining tendency, but the situation is far away from being optimistic .
To lessen the damages resulting from the road traffic accidents and save more lives, the reasons and factors should be analyzed and summarized. There are a number of factors which cause the traffic accidents, ranging from driver behavior to mechanical failure, environmental conditions, and roads design [7–9]. Many works have been done to investigate ways of developing a vehicle driving assistance system to improve its safety. Among those factors resulting in serious accidents, driver fatigue or inattention contribute a considerable portion [10, 11]. Driving is a complex process which involves eye-hand-foot coordination. In many cases, the driver falls asleep making the vehicle to leave its designated lane and possibly causing an accident. NHTSA estimated that running off the road caused about 28% of fatal vehicle accidents in the US in 2005. Moreover, drowsy, sleeping, or fatigued and inattentive drivers caused about 2.6% and 5.8% of the fatal crashes, respectively [12, 13]. Further research is needed to improve driver’s behavior and driving activities with the help of other advanced techniques.
In order to prevent this type of accident, researchers have proposed a variety of solutions and technologies to predict and detect unintended lane departure events to warn drivers about such events. Lane departure warning system (LDWS) has been proposed for this purpose, to warn the driver as soon as a vehicle begins to inadvertently drift out of its driving lane or to automatically take steps to ensure that the vehicle stays in correct lane . The currently available LDWSs on the markets are forward-looking vision-based systems and are mainly applied to prestige car, such as BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and so on. In order to reduce the traffic accidents, the LDWS needs to adapt all types of vehicle rather than some certain kinds of vehicles. Although many researchers have proposed several advanced algorithms to improve the system performance [15, 16], there still exist the following bottleneck problems: (1)Lane detection should adapt to various conditions. Lane detection is a main task of LDWS, and the accuracy of detection is foundation and prerequisite to realize its warning function. Several algorithms have been proposed and their differences are mainly consisting in image preprocessing, lane model, selected model fitting method, and tracking strategy [17, 18]. However, it is difficult to be performed with a high detection rate in complex situations involving shadows, varying illumination conditions, bad conditions of road paintings and kinds of lane marks such as solid lines, segment lines, double yellow lines, pavement or physical barriers. Therefore, how to make the detection algorithm accommodate the complex environment is an important issue. (2)The LDWS has to meet the requirements such as robust, low cost, compact, low dissipation, and real time. Some of these requirements need to be accomplished by algorithm, while the other can be achieved from the hardware device. In , an adaptive DSP-based LDWS was introduced with its operating frequency of 600 MHz and the lane marking detection speed of 35 f/s. The system function is compact but the price is slightly high. In addition, researchers use FPGA devices or other low-cost and low-power consumption architectures to develop the systems [20, 21]. However, the contradiction between complexity of algorithm and the memory of hardware is very outstanding.
To overcome the above difficulty, some strategies should be developed to make the system real time and robust, which can adapt to real road environments. This paper aims to develop a real-time lane detection algorithm based on intelligent regulated CCD parameters, which can effectively solve the conflicts between real time and robustness of the LDWS. The contents of this paper are organized as follows. Section 2 introduces an intelligent regulated CCD parameters algorithm. After analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of traditional Hough transform, an improved Hough transform algorithm is proposed in Section 3. Section 4 verifies the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm through road experiments, and some conclusions are given in Section 5.
2. CCD Parameters Regulation Based on Feature Regions
The LDWS system needs a great demand on the CCD image grabbing speed. To achieve this, CCD employs a kind of parameter control technique, that is to say, the gain, bright, and shutter of CCD can be programmed. Therefore, the CCD parameters can be regulated by programmed in real time, which is helpful to image segmentation, reducing noise as well as improving the reliability and instantaneity of lane detection algorithms. Moreover, it can heighten the contrast between road surfaces and lane marks.
The CCD model used in our LDWS is BaslerA602f and its parameters can be regulated through IEEE1394 video capture board connected to an imbedded computer . The purpose of CCD parameters regulation can be realized by defining some feature regions and calculating the eigenvalues of those regions.
2.1. Feature Regions Division and Eigenvalues Computation
As showed in Figure 1, the image to be processed is divided into six feature regions from region to . The size of image is 320 × 240 pixels.
Region is the upper center 1/4 region of the image. The gray mean value and variance of this region indicate the brightness of sky. While region is the bottom center 1/4 region of the image, whose gray mean value and variance indicate the darkness of the road surface. They can be calculated using where and are the width and height of image, respectively; is the gray value of pixel .
Usually, the lane mark is included in regions , , , and . To a certain extent, their gray mean values and variances can indicate the light and shade condition of images around the lane marks. The positions of the lane marks are not changeless as the vehicle moving. So the regions , , , and , which called the lane marks feature regions, will change their position and information when the vehicle is moving. The sizes of those regions can be divided in accordance with the detection and tracking status of the lane marks .
If the lane is during the detecting status, that is to say, we have no idea about the lane marks position and its gray information. The size and position of those feature regions are uncertain and can be determined on the basis of practical experimental data. As shown in Figure 1, they are defined as follows. The width is 160 pixels and is in the center of the image. Points and are symmetric with respect to -axis. The angle between and -axis is 45° and is parallel to . The left lane marks may line in the region of PMQN. Region of PMQN is divided into regions and by line of , which may contain the detail line mark information and the macroscopic view of the lane, respectively. In the coordinate system displayed in Figure 1, the coordinates for points , , and are (−80, 120), (0, 120), (80, 120) respectively. The function for can be expressed by . Then the eigenvalues of regions and are calculated as where and are pixel numbers in regions PHM and PIGH, respectively; is the pixel number in region .
The angle between ST and -axis is 135° and ST is parallel to NL. The gray mean values and variances of regions and can be calculated by the same means.
If the lane is during the tracking status, that is to say, we have gotten prior parameters of the lane to be detected. In this condition, the instantaneity of the system is improved by building some dynamic trapezoid feature regions. Due to the effect of projection, there are some differences in deflected distance between the bottom and the centre of the image. Therefore, we build the dynamic trapezoid feature areas taking advantage of 6 specialized feature points . As shown in Figure 2, point is taken as the previous lane vanishing point, with its coordinate is . Points and are the endpoint of the left lane and the right lane, respectively. Then offset point with 20 pixels to the left and right, respectively, we can get points and . Offset point with 30 pixels up and connect this point to , the crosspoint for this line with the image margin is . Offset point with 30 pixels down and connect this point to , the crosspoint for this line with the image margin is . At the same way, we will get points and . In the tracking condition, a moving vehicle will change the lane position, which leads to the changing of these 6 feature points. As a result, the feature regions determined by these points are dynamic.
2.2. CCD Parameters Regulation
Once the feature regions are determined and their eigenvalues are calculated, the CCD parameters can be regulated according to those values. The detailed CCD parameters regulation is as follows. (1)Computing the eigenvalues of those feature regions according to the lane detection and tracking status. (2)Previous experiments in different illumination conditions indicate that it is easy to make a decision between lane marks and road surfaces when the mean values of regions , , , and are in range of [60,100] and their variances in [11, 27]. So we will not change the CCD parameters and continuous capturing images when the gray level mean values gotten are in range [60, 100] and their variances in [11, 27]. If all of the mean values are below 60 or higher than 100, we will change the CCD gain, brightness, and shutter by a certain step size till their eigenvalues are in proper range. (3)Saving the current parameters and capture the next frame images.
Figure 3 shows the image and its segmentation results after the CCD parameters regulation in the condition of strong illumination. In these images showed below, the left one is the image based on CCD parameters regulation and the right one is the corresponding segmentation result.
Above images show that the contrast between lane marks and the road surfaces has been enhanced after the CCD parameters regulation. The segmentation of the image is pretty well and there is little background noise.
3. Lane Detection Using Improved Hough Transform
3.1. Analysis of Traditional Hough Transform
As the images collected on the highway are very complicated, there will be great error if we use linear fitting method to detect the lane. On the contrary, Hough transform is robust to small change of the image noise, and it is good at handling over the conditions that the object is partly occluded and covered . In the image space, the straight line can be described as and can be graphically plotted for each pair of image points . The main idea of Hough transform is to consider the characteristics of the straight line not as image points , , etc.) but instead, in terms of its parameters, that is, the slope parameter and the intercept parameter . For computational reasons, a different pair of parameters in polar coordinates, denoted by and , is used for the line in the Hough transform. is the length of a normal from the origin to this line and is the orientation of with respect to the -axis. The implementation procedure using traditional Hough transform to extract a straight line is as follows. (1)Quantize and , build a two-dimensional accumulate array in the parameter map of , as shown in Figure 4. The span for parameter () are separately [, ] and [,]. (2)Initialize the two-dimensional array , search the white edge in the image in sequence. To every white edge in the binarization image, let can be any value in the axis . Then calculate the value according to the equation . Accumulate the array on the basis of the value of and . (3)Figure out the maximum value in the transform domain and record it. (4)Clear the maximum value and their values of its neighborhood points. (5)Figure out all the maximum points successively and record them. (6)Seek for the recent lane line according to some certain constraints.
According to this procedure, the traditional Hough transform has some disadvantages as follows when detecting the road lane. (1)As every white point should be involved in the computing of space transform, the calculated amount increases, and it is time consuming. We can overcome this by adjusting the CCD parameters, as shown in the Figure 5. We compare the lane detection using the binarization images collected at the same place. The left images in Figure 5 show the situation without and with adjusting CCD parameters, respectively. Through comparing these two figures, we discover that after the use of CCD parameter adjusting algorithm, the points involving in the Hough transform decrease clearly, which verifies the effectiveness of CCD parameter adjusting algorithm. (2)Due to the quantizing of parameters and , the peak value near one straight line is always very large after finding the peak value; we should clear the neighborhood values and look for next line. But it is not easy to perfectly define the neighborhood range, if the neighborhood is too small, the line detected next time will be overlapped on the already existed line, if the neighborhood is too large, the nearby waiting to be detected points will be clear up, and next time, you will not find any point. It is more obvious when there exist several similar lines at the same time and they are close to each other, as shown in the middle and right column of Figure 5.
3.2. Improved Hough Transform for Lane Detection
Facing the disadvantages, many researchers have proposed some improved methods. Those methods can be summarized to two kinds [26, 27]. The one is to classify the points in the image before conducting Hough transform, such as using the gradient direction to reduce the number of votes. This kind can reduce the computation time and has the interesting effect of reducing the number of useless votes, thus enhancing the visibility of the spikes corresponding to real lines in the image. The key technique is to select proper point classifying method. The other is to improve the transform voting scheme, such as Kernel-based Hough transform . This approach can significantly improve the performance of the voting scheme and makes the transform more robust to the detection of spurious lines. But the computation time is huge, which is improper to the LDWS.
After analyzing the traditional Hough transform, this paper proposes a new lane identification method. Specifically, seed points of lane are selected firstly and then utilize Hough transform for seed points of every group. Figure 6 shows the pictures after threshold and noise filtering, represents three typical situations, the normal, existing similar interference and some deviation happens.
3.2.1. Selection and Classification of the Seed Points
As indicated in Figure 6, the lane has two main features for each scan line, because the lane has width and gray value of each side has mutation. These two features can be the criterion for selecting the lane seed points and any one possesses the features can be seen as the lane seed points. The seed points between two scanning lines can be put into one seed points group, if their pixel difference is less than a certain threshold value, otherwise they will be put into a new group. The specific steps are as follows.
Firstly, take a two-dimensional array SeedGroup represents the -coordinate of the seed points. Among which, is the amount of the seed points arrays, which is also the maximum lane line numbers. According to the CCD equipment view and the highway scenario, the maximum value of is set 4. represents the amount of the scan lines and also the seed points -coordinate. As the lane marks are always in the lower half of the picture, we set the value of to a half of image height, that is, . This array is initialized to be 0.
Secondly, scan the image from left to right and bottom to top. When the scanning encounters a white point , goes on with the scanning, and starts to count numbers, ends when encounters a point is not a white one. Then number of the white points is , take the middle value of it as the seed point
Therefore, the seed point’s coordinate is . Considering the case that the lane is discontinuous which may lead to seed points separated by several scanning lines, we classify them by taking the strategy as follows. According to the CCD perspective principle, when is much larger, the actual distance each pixel represents is much farther. so is divided into two parts: If , we should compare the SeedGroup values of all lane arrays before with . If it is less than a certain threshold value (when the CCD is mounted on the vehicle basically horizontal, through test the threshold is set to be 20), it classifies the seed point to this lane array. If it is larger than a certain threshold value, it indicates that a new lane is appearing. We can classify the seed point to the new lane array. Else if , we should compare the SeedGroup values of the first 30 lane arrays before with . Classify principle is same as above.
Suppose that the lane array which the seed points are classified to is . We should retain the data of lane array (SeedGroup , ). And then continue scan starts from the 0 pixel downward, until to finish the current scanning.
Finally, continue to scan up until to complete all seed points’ choice and classification. Figure 7 displays the nonzero seed points arrays SeedGroup for the image in Figure 6. Each array represents a lane. As can be seen, this method can accurately obtain the points of center lanes, and classify the points accurately.
3.2.2. Utilizing Hough Transform for the Seed Points of Each Group
Once the seed points have been selected and classified, and each lane can be determined utilizing Hough transform according those seed points of each group. Quantify the parameter space and build a two-dimensional accumulate array, then initialize the two-dimensional array at first and utilize Hough transform for the seed points of each group. We should let each point take all value on the axis and calculate the value of the . Compare the size of the array element to get maximum value. corresponding with maximum value is the parameter corresponded with the required straight line. So we just find out the parameter of each lane.
3.2.3. Current Lane Detection with Angle Constraints
Commonly, there may exist more than one lane in the image therefore, we need to define a certain constraint to extract the current lane accurately. Because of the CCD projection transformation, the lane disappeared in a point in the image. Figure 8 displays the angular relationship diagram for multilane in the image. As shown in this figure, the angle for the left lane is and for the right lane is . The farther away from the centerline of the image, the smaller is and the larger is . Therefore, we can extract the current lane in accordance with this method.
When exploiting the improved Hough transform acquiring the parameters of each straight lane, the minimum in the angle of and the maximum in can be determined. Then the current lane can be detected according to the parameter map . Figure 9 displays the current lane detection results.
4. Experiments and Analysis
To verify the proposed lane detection method, several experiments were conducted on images and sequences on real highway scenarios with the lane departure warning system. During the experiment, the driver drives the vehicle cross the lane intentionally to see the system performance. The driving environment is focused on highway with different light conditions. Some typical experiments results for lane detection are shown in Figure 10. The left images are the detection results using traditional Hough transform, while the right images display the results using the improved Hough transform. Those entire images are captured after applying the intelligent regulated CCD parameters.
As can be seen from Figure 10(a), both methods can realize the lane detection under normal environments. The difference lies in the processing time of each image. The average processing time for an image using the traditional Hough transform is about 45 ms. It decreases to 25 ms when using the improved Hough transform. Moreover, the proposed lane detection method can recognize the lane correctly under abnormal environments, such as strong brightness. Even there are interferences on road. While the traditional method fails in this case, as displayed in Figure 10(b). It is important for the LDWS to achieve correct detection of current lane, especially when the vehicle is in process of lane exchanging. The traditional method usually takes the adjacent boundary as the current lane, which may lead to missing alarm and result in serious accident. Fortunately, the improved Hough transform is able to detection the current lane accurately, even if they are dashed lane marks, as shown in Figure 10(c) that may contribute to the importing of angle restraints.
Table 1 compares the performance of our lane detection method with traditional method. Statistic analysis also indicates that after the CCD parameters regulating, the performances for both of the traditional and improved Hough transform are enhanced. While the proposed Hough transform presents the best performance. As to the weather conditions, cloudy day shows better than sunny day for the reason that the road surface is more dark, which is helpful to enlarge the contrast between the surface and the white lane marks.
In this paper, a robust lane detection method based on intelligent CCD parameters regulation by combining the improved Hough transform with certain angle restraints is presented. The main contributions of this paper are as follows. (1)The CCD parameters, such as the brightness, gain, and exposure time, are regulated based on the information in the specialized feature regions. Test results indicate that the adjusting of CCD parameters can enhance the contrast between the lane marks and road surfaces and reduce background noise, which is helpful to improve the real time of the algorithm. (2)An improved Hough transform algorithm is proposed after analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of traditional one, which optimizes the selection of seeds and introducing the angle constraints. (3)Several road experiments were conducted to validate the proposed method. Compared with the traditional Hough transform, results show that the improved method can detect the current lane with lower processing time and higher detection accuracy.In this case, the lane model is taken as straight line and ignoring the curve line model that really existing in real environments. In the future work, this case should be taking into account for the lane departure warning system. Moreover, the vehicle steering controlling is necessary according to the lane detection results.
This research was financed by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (61104165) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (DUT12JR08 and 20116217).
- R. Sánchez-Mangas, A. García-Ferrrer, A. de Juan, and A. M. Arroyo, “The probability of death in road traffic accidents. How important is a quick medical response?” Accident Analysis and Prevention, vol. 42, no. 4, pp. 1048–1056, 2010.
- W. Zhang, O. Tsimhoni, M. Sivak, and M. J. Flannagan, “Road safety in China: analysis of current challenges,” Journal of Safety Research, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 25–30, 2010.
- W. H. Wang, Vehicle’s Man-Machine Interaction Safety and Driver Assistance, China Communications Press, Beijing, 2012.
- W. H. Wang, H. W. Guo, H. W. Bubb, and K. Ikeuchi, “Numerical simulation and analysis procedure for model-based digital driving dependability in intelligent transport system,” KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, vol. 15, no. 5, pp. 891–898, 2011.
- World Health Organization, World Health Statistics 2008, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2008.
- J. H. Zhou, J. Qiu, X. C. Zhao et al., “Road crash in China from 2003 to 2005,” Chinese Journal of Traumatology, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 3–7, 2008.
- M. Karacasu and A. Er, “An analysis on distribution of traffic faults in accidents, based on driver's age and gender: Eskisehir case,” Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, vol. 20, pp. 776–785, 2011.
- M. G. Masuri, K. A. M. Isa, and M. P. M. Tahir, “Children, youth and road environment: road traffic accident,” Procedia—Social and Behavioral Sciences, vol. 38, pp. 213–218, 2012.
- A. Spoerri, M. Egger, and E. von Elm, “Mortality from road traffic accidents in Switzerland: longitudinal and spatial analyses,” Accident Analysis and Prevention, vol. 43, no. 1, pp. 40–48, 2011.
- A. Bener, M. G. A. Al Maadid, T. Özkan, D. A. E. Al-Bast, K. N. Diyab, and T. Lajunen, “The impact of four-wheel drive on risky driver behaviours and road traffic accidents,” Transportation Research F, vol. 11, no. 5, pp. 324–333, 2008.
- P. Angkititrakul, R. Terashima, and T. Wakita, “On the use of stochastic driver behavior model in lane departure warning,” IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, vol. 12, no. 1, pp. 174–183, 2011.
- N. Minoiu Enache, M. Netto, S. Mammar, and B. Lusetti, “Driver steering assistance for lane departure avoidance,” Control Engineering Practice, vol. 17, no. 6, pp. 642–651, 2009.
- E. A. Schmidt, M. Schrauf, M. Simon, A. Buchner, and W. E. Kincses, “The short-term effect of verbally assessing drivers' state on vigilance indices during monotonous daytime driving,” Transportation Research F, vol. 14, no. 3, pp. 251–260, 2011.
- J. C. McCall and M. M. Trivedi, “Video-based lane estimation and tracking for driver assistance: survey, system, and evaluation,” IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 20–37, 2006.
- Đ. Obradović, Z. Konjović, E. Pap, and I. J. Rudas, “Linear fuzzy space based road lane model and detection,” Knowledge-Based Systems. In press.
- Y. Wang, N. Dahnoun, and A. Achim, “A novel system for robust lane detection and tracking,” Signal Processing, vol. 92, no. 2, pp. 319–334, 2012.
- S. Nedevschi, R. Danescu, T. Marita et al., “A sensor for urban driving assistance systems based on dense stereovision,” in Proceedings of the IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium (IV'07), pp. 276–283, Istanbul, Turkey, June 2007.
- J. G. Wang, C. J. Lin, and S. M. Chen, “Applying fuzzy method to vision-based lane detection and departure warning system,” Expert Systems with Applications, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 113–126, 2010.
- B. F. Wu, C. J. Chen, Y. P. Hsu, and M. W. Chung, “A DSP-based lane departure warning system,” in Proceedings of the 8th WSEAS International Conference on Mathematical Methods and Computational Techniques in Electrical Engineering, Bucharest, Romania, 2006.
- E. Shang, J. Li, X. J. An, and H. H. He, “A real-time lane departure warning system based on FPGA,” in Proceedings of the 14th International IEEE Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems, pp. 1243–1248, Washington, DC, USA, 2011.
- P. Y. Hsiao, C. W. Yeh, S. S. Huang, and L. C. Fu, “A portable vision-based real-time lane departure warning system: day and night,” IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology, vol. 58, no. 4, pp. 2089–2094, 2009.
- L. S. Jin, R. B. Wang, T. H. Yu, L. Guo, and L. Yang, “Lane departure warning system based on monocular vision,” in Proceedings of the 14th World Congress on Intelligent Transportation Systems, Beijing, China, 2007.
- S. Suh and Y. Kang, “A robust lane recognition technique for vision-based navigation with a multiple clue-based filtration algorithm,” International Journal of Control, Automation and Systems, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 348–357, 2011.
- Z. W. Kim, “Robust lane detection and tracking in challenging scenarios,” IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 16–26, 2008.
- V. Shapiro, “Accuracy of the straight line Hough Transform: the non-voting approach,” Computer Vision and Image Understanding, vol. 103, no. 1, pp. 1–21, 2006.
- A. L. Fisher and P. T. Highnam, “Computing the Hough transform on a scan line array processor,” IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 262–265, 1989.
- M. C. K. Yang, J. S. Lee, C. C. Lien, and C. L. Huang, “Hough transform modified by line connectivity and line thickness,” IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, vol. 19, no. 8, pp. 905–910, 1997.
- L. A. F. Fernandes and M. M. Oliveira, “Real-time line detection through an improved Hough transform voting scheme,” Pattern Recognition, vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 299–314, 2008.