Research Article

A Macroevolutionary Perspective on Multiple Sexual Traits in the Phasianidae (Galliformes)

Table 2

Characters scored as monomorphic or dimorphic.

CharacterDescription

1Plumage-ColorDimorphic scored for obvious differences between the sexes in coloration (subtle differences, such as slightly brighter in males or more extensive spotting in one sex were scored as monomorphic)
2Plumage-Tail LengthDimorphic scored when tail (or tail coverts) was much longer or modified in males relative to female tail
3Plumage-Head OrnamentsDimorphic scored if ear tufts, crests, or capes either present in males or larger in males
4Plumage-OtherDimorphic scored if male plumage exhibits iridescence or modified feathers not covered in other categories
5Plumage-ElaborationDimorphic scored if the male plumage pattern or color is dramatic and very obvious relative to female plumage
6Fleshy TraitsDimorphic scored if one sex larger or obviously brighter than the other; since the goal was to explore sexual selection on these traits, the appearance of the trait when displayed was scored
7SpursDimorphic scored if males had more spurs than females, or in a few cases male spurs noticeably longer than female spurs
8Wing LengthDimorphic if at least a 5% difference between the sexes (following Höglund [20]). Used average wing length if given; if only a range was given, then the midpoint of the range was used for calculations)
9Body SizeDimorphic if species noted as having larger males or smaller females; scored as monomorphic if differences were noted as slight (weight was not used as many measures in the literature taken from captive individuals and/or dead specimens whose weight may not be representative)
10Any PlumageScored as one if dimorphic in any of the five plumage traits
11Any CompetitiveScored as one if dimorphic in either spurs, wing length, or body size
12High PlumageScored as one if the species exhibited dimorphism in at least three of the five plumage characters
13High CompetitiveScored as one if the species exhibited dimorphism in at least two of the three competitive characters
14TotalSum of all characters scored as dimorphic in a species
15Total SignalSum of the plumage and fleshy trait dimorphism, both of which are used in visual displays
16Total CompetitiveSum of spur, wing, and body size characters scored as dimorphic
17Total PlumageSum of the five plumage characters scored as dimorphic