Review Article

The Many Faces of Malaysian English

Table 1

The evolutionary cycle of new Englishes: parameters of the development phases.

PhaseHistory and politicsIdentity constructionSociolinguistics of contact/use/attitudesLinguistic developments/structural effects

(1) FoundationSTL: colonial expansion: trade, military outposts, missionary activities, emigration/settlement IDG: occupation, loss/sharing of territory, tradeSTL: part of original nation
IDG: indigenous
STL: cross-dialectal contact, limited exposure to local languages
IDG: minority bilingualism (acquisition of English)
STL: koineization; toponymic borrowing; incipient pidginization (in trade colonies)

(2) Exonormative stabilizationStable colonial status; English established as language of administration, law, (higher) education, …STL: outpost of original nation, “British-plus-local”
IDG: individually “local-plus-British”
STL: acceptance of original norm; expanding contact
IDG: spreading (elite) bilingualism
Lexical borrowing (esp. fauna and flora, cultural terms); “-isms”; pidginization/creolization (in trade/plantation colonies)

(3) NativizationWeakening ties; often political independence but remaining cultural associationSTL: permanent resident of British origin
IDG: permanent resident of indigenous origin
Widespread and regular contacts, accommodation
IDG: common bilingualism, toward language shift, L1 speakers of local English
STL: sociolinguistic cleavage between innovative speakers (adopting IDG forms) and conservative speakers (upholding external norm; “complaint tradition”)
Heavy lexical borrowing;
IDG: phonological innovations (“accent,” possibly due to transfer); structural nativization, spreading from IDG to STL: innovations at lexis-grammar interface (verb complementation, prepositional usage, constructions with certain words/word classes), lexical productivity (compounds, derivation, phrases, semantic shifts); code mixing (as identity carrier)

(4) Endonormative stabilizationPostindependence, self-dependence (possibly after “Event X”)(member of) new nation, territory-based, increasingly pan-ethnicAcceptance of local norm (as identity carrier), positive attitude to it; (residual conservatism); literary creativity in new varietyStabilization of new variety, emphasis on homogeneity, codification: dictionary writing, grammatical description

(5) DifferentiationStable young nation, internal sociopolitical differentiationGroup-specific (as part of overarching new national identityNetwork construction (increasingly dense group; internal interactions)Dialect birth: group-specific (ethnic, regional, social) varieties emerge (as L1 or L2)