Review Article

Vascular Tissue Engineering: Recent Advances in Small Diameter Blood Vessel Regeneration

Table 7

Studies of the scientific literature (2008–2013) on TEVG development without the use of scaffolds.

Fabrication methodCell typeIDMechanical propertiesBiological in vivo resultsReference

In vivo bioreactor approach: device implanted in the peritoneal cavity to attract cells around a tubular scaffold; scaffold = stretchable urethane + silicone with a coating of nonadhesive materialAutologous tissue6 mm outer diameterAxial tensile tests UTS = 0.2 [0.04, 0.45]b MPa, = 0.75 [0.37, 0.86]b; circumferential tensile tests UTS = 0.07 [0.02, 0.72]b MPa, = 0.69 [0.39, 1.09]b; similar to native ovine blood vessels: axial tensile tests UTS = 5.7 [3.39, 7.12]b MPa, = 0.9 [0.57, 1.25]b; circumferential tensile tests UTS = 4.43 [2.76, 5.54]b MPa, = 0.72 [0.65, 1.15]bModel: sheep; device implantation for 10 days: many porous spaces in neotissue; some contractile protein expression; no production of collagen bundles and elastin; carotid artery interposition: quick rupture; patches in carotid artery (2 weeks): 1 graft failed after 1 week; other graft remained patent; aneurysm formation in both cases [72]

Cell ring-based approach: seeding of cells into annular agarose wells + cell aggregation + formation of thick tissue rings (static culture); tissue rings could be fused to generate tubular constructs Rat aortic SMCs2, 4, and 6 mmCircumferential tensile tests ID 2 mm day 8: UTS = 169 ± 45 kPa, = 0.81 ± 0.28 MPa, ; day 14: UTS = 97 ± 30 kPa, = 0.50 ± 0.09 MPa, ; ID 4 mm day 8: UTS = 339 ± 131 kPa, = 1.21 ± 0.46 MPa, ; day 14: UTS = 201 ± 63 kPa, = 0.71 ± 0.20 MPa, ; ID 6 mm day 8: UTS = 503 ± 76 kPa, = 1.98 ± 0.4 MPa, ; day 14: UTS = 302 ± 42 kPa, = 1.08 ± 0.14 MPa, [73]

Cell sheet-based approach: production of a completely autologous TEVG (7 months) + air-dried devitalization + freezing + storing for 5 months at −80°C + seeding with autologous ECs (culture for 4 days)Autologous fibroblasts and ECs isolated from skin and vein biopsies 4.8 mmBP = 6407 ± 633 mmHg, SRS = 261 ± 20 gf, = 3.1 ± 0.7%Clinical trial (1 patient); reduction of the production time (~2 weeks versus ~6–9 months); implanted without complication; no evidence of leakage at anastomoses; at 8 weeks: no complication; graft patency; stable diameter; no adverse reactions[74]

Cell sheet-based approach (single step method): tunica media and adventitia produced by rolling a tissue sheet containing both cell types contiguously (SMCs grew beside fibroblasts in the same culture dish)SMCs isolated from human umbilical cord; TEVMA produced by SMCs and either DFs (TEVMA-DF) or SVFs (TEVMA-SVF)4.5 mmTEVMA-DF BP ~ 1000* mmHg; circumferential tensile tests: UTS ~ 2.1* MPa,  MPa, ~ 30*%; stress-relaxation tests:  N,  N; TEVMA-SVF BP ~ 250* mmHg; circumferential tensile tests: UTS ~ 0.8* MPa,  MPa, %; stress-relaxation tests:  N,  N[48]

Cell sheet-based approach (single step method): tunica media and adventitia produced by rolling a tissue sheet containing both cell types contiguously (SMCs grew beside fibroblasts in the same culture dish)SMCs and fibroblasts isolated from 3 distinct human umbilical cords; aTEVMA-arterial TEVMA; vTEVMA-venous TEVMA4.5 mmaTEVMA BPe ~ 250* mmHg; circumferential tensile tests: UTS ~ 3* MPa,  MPa, %; stress-relaxation tests:  N,  N; vTEVMA BPe ~ 100* mmHg; circumferential tensile tests: UTS ~ 1* MPa,  MPa, %; stress-relaxation tests:  N,  N[75]

Cell sheet-based approach + decellularization (dTEVM): sheet from fibroblasts (21 days) + decellularization by osmotic shock + seeding of SMCs + culture for 7 days + cellular sheet rolled on a mandrel + culture for 21 days Human arterial SMCs isolated from an umbilical cord; DFs obtained from a reductive breast surgery; dTEVM-DF obtained from DFs; dTEVM-SVF obtained from SVFs; TEVM standard cell-sheet grafts (no decellularization), produced by SMCs4.5 mmdTEVM-DF UTS ~ 3.1* MPa,  MPa, %; BPe ~ 2600* mmHg; dTEVM-SVF UTS ~ 2.2* MPa,  MPa, %; BPe ~ 1800* mmHg; TEVM UTS ~ 0.8* MPa,  MPa, %; BPe ~ 400* mmHg; UTS, , and calculated from circumferential tensile tests[76]

Microtissue self-assembly approach: microtissues produced higher amounts of ECM + bioreactor to assemble microtissues in a tubular shape + dynamic culture for 14 days (pulsatile flow and circumferential mechanical stimulation)Microtissues composed of myofibroblasts and ECs; HAFs and HUVECs used for microtissue generation3 mm[77]

Scaffold-free rapid prototyping bioprinting approach: cells aggregated into cylinders + bioprinting of cell cylinders using agarose rods as molding template + 2–4 days in the mold (fusion period) + maturation in a perfusion bioreactorHUVSMC and HSF aggregated into cylinders0.9 to 2.5 mm outer diameter[78]

TEVMA: tissue-engineered vascular media and adventitia; TEVM: tissue-engineered vascular media.
UTS: ultimate tensile strength; : strain at break; : elastic modulus; : initial modulus; : equilibrium modulus; BP: burst pressure; BPe: estimated burst pressure; *values were graphically read; bdata expressed as medians (min., max.), SRS: suture retention strength, C: compliance.
SVFs: human saphenous vein fibroblasts; DFs: human dermal fibroblasts; HAFs: primary human artery-derived fibroblasts; HUVECs: human umbilical vein endothelial cells; HUVSMCs: human umbilical vein smooth muscle cells; HSFs: human skin fibroblasts.