Research Article

Selection and Configuration of Sorption Isotherm Models in Soils Using Artificial Bees Guided by the Particle Swarm

Table 8

Performance of different solvers for the selection of appropriate algorithm based on best solution.

#PSOPCPSOABCMABC

1Two-site Langmuir (0.1273)Two-site Langmuir (0.1275)Two-site Langmuir (0.1278)Two-site Langmuir (0.1273)

2Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0955)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0940)Two-site Langmuir (0.0938)Freundlich-Langmuir/two-site Langmuir (0.0924)

3Freundlich
(0.0233)
Freundlich
(0.0233)
Freundlich
(0.0233)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0200)

4Freundlich
(0.0798)
Freundlich
(0.0798)
Freundlich
(0.0798)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0771)

5Two-site Langmuir (0.0277)Two-site Langmuir (0.0294)Freundlich-Langmuir
(0.0309)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0279)

6Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0742)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0742)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0742)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0742)

7Two-site Langmuir (0.0381)Two-site Langmuir (0.0421)Two-site Langmuir (0.0407)Two-site Langmuir (0.0390)

8Two-site Langmuir (0.0776)Two-site Langmuir (0.0783)Two-site Langmuir (0.0786)Two-site Langmuir (0.0772)

9Freundlich(0.1330)Freundlich (0.1330)Freundlich (0.1330)Freundlich (0.1330)

10Freundlich-Langmuir/Two-site Langmuir (0.1010)Freundlich-Langmuir/two-site Langmuir (0.1010)Freundlich-Langmuir/Two-site Langmuir (0.1010)Freundlich/Freundlich-Langmuir/two-site Langmuir(0.1010)

11Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0704)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0724)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0715)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0704)

12Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0309)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0310)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0312)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0309)

13Two-site Langmuir (0.0322)Two-site Langmuir (0.0318)Two-site Langmuir (0.0332)Two-site Langmuir (0.0316)

14Two-site Langmuir (0.0719)Two-site Langmuir (0.0721)Two-site Langmuir (0.0724)Two-site Langmuir (0.0719)

15Two-site Langmuir (0.0393)Freundlich-Langmuir/two-site Langmuir
(0.0396)
Freundlich-Langmuir
(0.0396)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0393)

16Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0651)Two-site Langmuir
(0.0695)
Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0660)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0651)

17Freundlich
(0.0676)
Freundlich
(0.0676)
Freundlich
(0.0677)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0596)

18Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0320)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0320)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0323)Freundlich-Langmuir (0.0320)

19Two-site Langmuir (0.0140)Freundlich-Langmuir
(0.0235)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0129)Two-site Langmuir (0.0111)

20Two-site Langmuir (0.0143)Two-site Langmuir (0.0152)Two-site Langmuir (0.0149)Two-site Langmuir (0.0143)

21Freundlich-Langmuir
(0.0110)
Two-site Langmuir (0.0100)Two-site Langmuir (0.0097)Two-site Langmuir (0.0030)