Searching, Navigating, and Recommending Movies through Emotions: A Scoping Review

Table 3

List of documents selected for the final analysis of the scoping review.

Author (Year)	Type of paper	Info source	Model	Terms used
Aurangzeb et al. [85]	Pc	Tran	Ct	Anger, disgust, happy, neutral, sad, surprise.
Babas et al. [86]	Pc	Tran	Nd	Not described.
Bader et al. [87]	Pc	Tran	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Benini et al. [82]	Es	User	Cs	Boredom, distress, excitement, happiness, relaxation, sadness, sleepiness, tension.
Canini et al. [88]	Es	User	Cs	Boredom, distress, excitement, happiness, relaxation, sadness, sleepiness, tension.
Cao & Kang [89]	Pc	User	Dm	Not described.
Chakraverty & Saraswat [90]	Cs	Tran	Ct	Anger, fear, joy, love, sadness, surprise.
Chambel et al. [91]	Es	User	Ct	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, surprise.
Chambel et al. [92]	Es	User	Ct	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, surprise.
Chan & Jones [93]	Pc	Mov	Ct/Dm	Anger, gloat, hate, joy, love, pity, resentment.
Chan & Jones [94]	Pc	Mov	Dm	Not described.
Chang et al. [95]	Pc	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Chu et al. [8]	Es	User	Dm	Not described.
Cohen-Kalaf et al. [96]	Es	Tran	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
De Pessemier et al. [97]	Pc	Tran	Ct	Angry, scared, contempt, disgusted, happy, sad, surprised.
Dilip et al. [98]	Pc	Tran	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Dushantha et al. [99]	Es	User	Ct	Happy, neutral, sad, satisfying.
Fernandez-Tobias et al. [100]	Es	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Gaag et al. [101]	Pc	Mov	Ct/Dm	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Gedikli & Jannach [102]	Pc	Tran	Nd	Not described.
Giannakopoulos et al. [103]	Cs	Mov	Nd	Angry, ambiguous, happy, neutral, sad.
Gil et al. [77]	Es	User	Ct	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, surprise.
Gu & Su [104]	Pc	Tran	Nd	Not described.
Ha et al. [105]	Es	Tran	Nd	Awesome, bored, calm, chilly, creepy, cruel, disgusted, drowsy, ecstatic, energetic, enjoyable, excited, fantastic, fearsome, funny, furious, gratified, great, happy, heartbroken, horrified, impressed, lonely, mournful, ominous, outraged, pitiful, pleasant, sad, scared, surprised, sweet, terrified, touched, unfortunate, wonderful.
Hameed & Garcia-Zapirain [106]	Pc	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Hanjalic & Xu [107]	Pc	Mov	Dm	Not described.
Haq et al. [108]	Es	Mov	Ct	Angry, disgust, fear, happy, neutral, sad, surprise.
Ibrahim et al. [109]	Pc	Tran	Nd	Not described.
Irie et al. [110]	Es	Mov	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Jorge & Chambel [111]	Pc	Mov	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Jorge et al. [112]	Pc	Mov	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Kaklauskas et al. [113]	Pc	User	Ct	Angry, disgusted, happy, neutral, sad, scared, surprised.
Kar et al. [114]	Pc	Mov	He	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Kim & Lee [115]	Pc	Mov	Ct	Anger, contempt, disgust, fear, happiness, neutral, sadness, surprise.
Kolokythas et al. [116]	Es	Tran	Dm	Not described
Koolagudi et al. [117]	Pc	Mov	Ct	Anger, fear, happiness, neutral, and sadness.
Li et al. [118]	Pc	Mov	Dm	Not described
Li & Murata [119]	Es	User	Nd	Anger, calmness, happiness, sadness, surprise.
Mahata et al. [120]	Pc	User	Nd	Anger, contempt, disgust, fear, happiness, neutral, sadness, surprise.
Mariappan et al. [121]	Cs	User	Ct	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, surprise.
Martins et al. [122]	Es	Mov	Ct	Anger, arousing, disgust, fear, festive, happy, lighthearted, passionate, mellow, playful, romantic, sad, surprise, tender, thrilling, weird.
Mokryn et al. [79]	Es	Tran	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Moncrieff et al. [123]	Pc	Mov	Af	Not described.
Moshfeghi [124]	Tp	User	Ct	Interest.
Nagamanjula & Pethalakshmi [125]	Cs	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Niu et al. [126]	Es	Mov	Dm	Arousal, contentment, depression, distress, excitement, misery, pleasure, sleepiness.
Nosshi et al. [127]	Cs	Tran	Ct	Anger, joy, sadness, surprise.
Odić et al. [128]	Es	User	Ct	Angry, disgust, fear, happy, neutral, sad, surprise.
Oh [129]	Es	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Oliveira, Benovoy, et al. [75]	Es	User	Ct/Dm	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness.
Oliveira, Martins, et al. [76]	Es	Mov	Ct	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, surprise.
Oliveira et al. [130]	Es	Mov	Ct	Amused, anger, astonished, bored, compassioned, curious, disgust, disturbed, embarrassed, fear, happiness, inspired, involved, irritated, melancholic, sadness, scared, surprise, tender.
Orellana-Rodriguez et al. [131]	Es	Tran	Ct	Anger, anticipation, disgust, fear, joy, sadness, surprise, trust.
Park et al. [132]	Cs	Mov	Ct	Ambivalence, anger, anxiety, apathy, astonishment, calmness, desire, dislike, ecstasy, embarrassment, expectation, faintness, fearlessness, glow, gratitude, gravity, happiness, humility, humor, liking, pain, pride, sensitivity, sentiment, shame, soul, sympathy, ungratefulness, unhappiness, warm-heartedness.
Poirson & Cunha [6]	Es	Tran	Ct	Amused, angry, anxious, attentive, sad, scared, surprise, happy.
Salway & Graham [133]	Es	Mov	Ct	Not described.
Saraswat & Chakraverty [134]	Cs	Tran	Ct	Anger, fear, joy, love, sadness, surprise.
Saraswat et al. [135]	Cs	Tran	Ct	Anger, fear, joy, love, sadness, surprise.
Shi et al. [136]	Cs	Tran	Nd	Not described.
Shi et al. [137]	Cs	Tran	Nd	Not described.
Sivakumar et al. [138]	Cs	Mov	Cs	Not described.
Song et al. [139]	Es	Tran	Dm	Annoyed, empty, exciting, interesting, morbid, sad, tantalizing, tense, touching, uninteresting.
Tang et al. [140]	Cs	Tran	Ct	Anger, anticipation, blame, boring, disappointment, disgust, doubt, fear, fondness, guilt, happy, hate, hope, jealous, joy, miss, panic, peace, praise, respect, sadness, shy, surprise, trust.
Tarvainen et al. [141]	Es	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Thulasi & Usha [142]	Cs	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Tintarev & Masthoff [143]	Es	Tran	Mo	Not described.
Tkalcic & Ferwerda [144]	Es	User	Pm	Not described.
Topal & Ozsoyoglu [78]	Pc	Tran	He	Acceptance, admiration, amazement, anger, annoyance, anticipation, apprehension, boredom, disgust, distraction, ecstasy, fear, grief, interest, joy, loathing, pensiveness, rage, sadness, serenity, surprise, terror, trust, vigilance.
Torkamaan et al. [145]	Es	User	Dm	Not described.
Tsoneva et al. [146]	Es	Mov	Ct/Dm	Anger-hostility, desire, disgust, fear, fun, happiness, love, optimism, sadness-loneliness, suffering.
Varisco & Interlandi [147]	Es	User	Ct/Dm	Angry, disgusted, happy, sad, scared, surprised.
Wakil et al. [148]	Pc	User	Ct	Anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness.
Wang et al. [149]	Cs	User	Mo	Not described.
Wang et al. [150]	Cs	Tran	Dm	Not described.
Wei et al. [151]	Cs	Mov	Ct	Acceptance, anger, expectancy, fear, joy, rejection, sorrow, surprise.
Winoto & Tang [152]	Es	Tran	Dm	Afraid, angry, calm, confident, dissatisfied with self, excited, happy, interested, lonely, nervous, proud, relaxed, sad, sleepy, surprised, tired.
Xu et al. [153]	Cs	Mov	Ct	Anger, fear, joy, sadness.
Xu et al. [154]	Cs	Mov	Ct/Dm	Anger, fear, happy, neutral, sad.
Xu et al. [155]	Es	Mov	Ct/Dm	Anger, fear, happiness, neutral, sadness.
Yuan et al. [156]	Cs	Tran	Nd	Anger, ecstasy, happiness, sadness.
Zhang [157]	Cs	User	Nd	Anger, disgust, fear, happy, neutral, sad, surprise.
Zheng [158]	Cs	Tran	Ct/Dm	Angry, disgusted, happy, neutral, sad, scared, surprised.
Zheng [159]	Cs	Tran	Ct/Dm	Angry, disgusted, happy, neutral, sad, scared, surprised.

Note. Cs = case study; Es = empirical study; Pc = proof of concept; Tp = theoretical paper; Ct = categorical; Dm = dimensional; Ct/Dm = categorical/ dimensional; Af = affect; Mo = mood; Cs = connotative space; He = hourglass of emotion; Pm = pleasurable and meaningful entertainment; Nd = not described; Mov = movie; Tran = transactions. Words in bold refer to emotion categories. Words with an refer to expressions used to describe core affect experiential states.