Research Article

Mapping the Fundamental Niches of Two Freshwater Microalgae, Chlorella vulgaris (Trebouxiophyceae) and Peridinium cinctum (Dinophyceae), in 5-Dimensional Ion Space

Table 1

ANOVA P-values, regression coefficients and model fit diagnostics for Chlorella vulgaris specific growth rate, μ (d−1), and relative cell density (percent of maximum) for combined, cubic x quadratic Scheffé polynomial models. Only third order or lower terms significant at 𝑃 < 0 . 0 5 for at least one response are presented. Note that the single component P-values (i.e., NO3, PO4, etc.) are covered under “Linear Mixture”. The data were transformed with an inverse square root function before analysis; thus, regression coefficients with lesser values indicate greater effects. C.V.: coefficient of variance, n/s: 𝑃 > 0 . 0 5 .

Specific growth rateRelative cell density
RegressionRegression
SourceCoefficientsP-valuesCoefficientsP-values

Model<0.0001<0.0001
Linear mixture<0.0001<0.0001
 NO3 10.3 9.9
 PO4 10.4 10.0
 K 1.9 2.0
 Na 2.0 2.4
 Cl 10.3 9.8
K * Cl 7.2 0.0001 6.7 0.0002
K * [Conc]n/s −1.7 0.0005
Na * [Conc]n/s −1.4 0.0052
NO3 * PO4 * K 74.0 <0.0001 73.9 <0.0001
NO3 * PO4 * Na 84.6 <0.0001 83.9 <0.0001
NO3 * K * Na −74.0 <0.0001 −87.6 <0.0001
NO3 * K * Cl 53.9 <0.0001 55.0 <0.0001
NO3 * Na * Cl 79.6 <0.0001 74.8 <0.0001
PO4 * K * Na −59.5 <0.0001 −68.4 <0.0001
PO4 * K * Cl 60.3 <0.0001 59.1 <0.0001
PO4 * K * [Conc] 6.0 0.0086 6.9 0.0015
PO4 * Na * Cl 85.8 <0.0001 79.4 <0.0001
K * Na * Cl −79.6 <0.0001 −81.5 <0.0001
Na * Cl * [Conc] 8.4 0.0006 8.5 0.0002
NO3 * K * (NO3-K) 38.4 <0.0001 39.1 <0.0001
NO3 * Na * (NO3-Na) 39.5 <0.0001 39.2 <0.0001
PO4 * K * (PO4-K) 36.4 <0.0001 37.8 <0.0001
PO4 * Na * (PO4-Na) 37.9 <0.0001 38.5 <0.0001
K * Cl * (K-Cl) −44.4 <0.0001 −40.2 <0.0001
Na * Cl * (Na-Cl) −28.5 <0.0001 −27.1 <0.0001
Lack of Fit<0.0001<0.0001

Std. Dev.:1.061.00
Mean:7.547.22
C.V.%:14.1213.89
𝑅 2 :0.950.95
𝑅 2 -adj:0.930.93
𝑅 2 -pred:0.880.89