Research Article

Economic Analysis of Biomass Supply Chains: A Case Study of Four Competing Bioenergy Power Plants in Northwestern Ontario

Table 6

Per unit procurement cost of woody biomass supply to four power plants.

ScenarioUnit procurement cost of biomass supply ($·ODt−1)
ABFFABTBDDPPAGS

BASE65.6464.4961.2060.76
INTC76.81 (17.03%)75.37 (16.87%)71.31 (16.52%)70.39 (15.85%)
INPC70.45 (7.34%)69.24 (7.37%)65.79 (7.51%)65.47 (7.75%)
DEPC60.81 (−7.34%)59.72 (−7.40%)56.57 (−7.56%)56.03 (−7.79%)
INBA65.26 (−0.58%)64.17 (−0.49%)60.86 (−0.54%)60.21 (−0.90%)
IHR W165.26 (−0.58%)64.17 (−0.49%)60.86 (−0.54%)60.21 (−0.90%)
IHR W264.89 (−1.13%)63.89 (−0.93%)60.57 (−1.03%)59.86 (−1.48%)
IHFR65.08 (−0.85%)64.01 (−0.74%)60.61 (−0.95%)60.02 (−1.22%)
DEDP65.21 (−0.64%)64.14 (−0.54%)60.83 (−0.60%)60.17 (−0.97%)
DEBA66.11 (0.72%)64.86 (0.57%)61.58 (0.63%)61.23 (0.77%)
DHR W66.11 (0.72%)64.86 (0.57%)61.58 (0.63%)61.23 (0.77%)
DHFR66.26 (0.96%)65.02 (0.82%)61.85 (1.07%)61.46 (1.16%)
IHOR70.41 (7.27%)68.07 (5.56%)67.30 (9.97%)63.14 (3.93%)
INDP66.06 (0.65%)64.82 (0.52%)61.55 (0.58%)61.18 (0.70%)

ABFF: Abitibi-Bowater Fort Frances Power Plant, ABTB: Abitibi-Bowater Thunder Bay Power Plant, DDPP: Domtar Dryden Power Plant, AGS: Atikokan Generating Station; figures in brackets indicate the % change of per unit biomass procurement costs from the BASE scenario.