Review Article

Open versus Endovascular Repair of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm in the Elective and Emergent Setting in a Pooled Population of 37,781 Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Table 1

Baseline article demographics separated based on trial design and elective versus ruptured repair.

Randomized control trialsPublication yearEVAR/OAR, Age (EVAR/OAR)AAA size, cm (EVAR/OAR)

Matsumura et al. [19]2003235/99
Becquemin et al. [20]2011150/149
Prinssen et al. [21]2004171/174
Greenhalgh et al. [2]2004626/626

Observational trials
Elective repairs
Hansman et al. [22]200350/50
Hynes and Sultan [52]200762/52
Mistry et al. [53]2007122/15666/66
Moore et al. [23]1999100/100
May et al. [24]1998108/19570/695.3/5.6
May et al. [25]2001148/13572/69NR
Moore et al. [54]2003573/111 NR
Paolini et al. [47]200881/69
Porcellini et al. [26]200711/1471.3/69.65.9/6.8
Raval and Eskandari [27]20121634/391>80/>80NR
Schermerhorn et al. [28]200822830/2283076/76NR
Schouten et al. [29]200555/69 6.0/6.0
Steinmetz et al. [30]2010148/13478/76
Tefera et al. [31]200461/2374/746.0/6.0
Teufelsbauer et al. [55]2002206/24873.4/70.6NR
Turnipseed et al. [32]200370/9673/705.9/5.8
Wahlgren and Malmstedt [56]2008217/483 NR
Wang and Carpenter [57]20082664/334
Zeebregts et al. [48]200493/82
Aarts et al. [33]200599/116NR5.8/6.0
Arko et al. [34]2002174/243
de Bruin et al. [35]2010173/178 NR
Becquemin et al. [36]200073/10770/69
Brown et al. [58]2011543/539
Bush et al. [49]2007788/1580 NR
Cao et al. [37]2004534/58573/725.2/5.6
de Virgilio et al. [59]199983/6373/68NR
Chan et al. [38]2007157/32975/726.1/6.3
Chisci et al. [39]200974/61 6.2/6.3
Criado et al. [40]2003240/12675.5/70 5.70.96/NR
Elkouri et al. [41]200494/26177/735.7/5.7
García-Madrid et al. [42]200453/3073/706.2/6.4
Gawenda et al. [43]200310/1657/52.5NR
Gou ffic et al. [60]2005209/289
Gupta et al. [44]2012369/28256/56NR
Hill et al. [61]200279/70
Diehm et al. [62]200825/25
Hoshina et al. [45]2012326/247

Ruptured Repairs
Mcphee et al. [7]20093179/2457174.3/73N/A
Nedeau et al. [8]201219/5578.2/76.3N/A
Saqib et al. [9]201237/111 N/A
Sarac et al. [10]201132/12880.5/72N/A
Sharif et al. [11]200752/7474/74N/A
Vaddineni et al. [12]20059/15 N/A
Verhoeven et al. [13]200836/89 N/A
Visser et al. [14]200958/143 N/A
Alsac et al. [15]200517/20 N/A
Coppi et al. [16] 200625/33 N/A
Bosch et al. [17] 201033/9181/77N/A
Franks et al. [18]200621/22 N/A