Research Article

Hydrodynamics of a Novel Design Circulating Fluidized Bed Steam Reformer Operating in the Dense Suspension Upflow Regime

Table 1

Comparison between fixed bed steam reformers, bubbling fluidized bed steam reformers (BFBMSR), and circulating fluidized bed membrane steam reformer (CFBMSR).

Fixed bedBFBMSRCFBMSR

Catalyst particle size
(for the same flow rate)
Large to decrease pressure drop (8–16 mm)Relatively larger than that of CFBMSR (0.2–0.35 mm)Fine particles are used ensuring higher effectiveness factor
(0.05–0.15 mm)

Pressure dropVery high (2–4 atm)Moderate (0.2–0.4 atm)Low (around 0.1 atm)

Effectiveness factorVery low (10−2–10−3)High (~1)High (~1)

Gas flow rateLowMedium High, allowing for higher productivity

Catalyst regenerationShutdown requiredShutdown typically neededNo need for shutdown due to the presence of downer; also regeneration allows autothermicity of the operation

Thermodynamic equilibrium limitationExisting due to absence of hydrogen membranesNot existing because of hydrogen removalNot existing because of hydrogen removal