[Retracted] Analysis of Dynamic Relationship between Energy Consumption and Economic Growth Based on PVAR Model

Table 2

Variance decomposition results of oil, natural gas, coal consumption, and real GDP.

Period	Developed countries					Developing country
S		Dmdlngdp	Dmlncc	Dmdlnoc	Dmdlngc		Dmdlngdp2	Dmlncc2	Dmdlnoc2	Dmdlngc2
10	Dmdlngdp	0.9769	0.0085	0.0113	0.0031	Dmdlngdp2	0.9161	0.0175	0.0588	0.007
10	Dmlncc	0.0865	0.9110	0.0006	0.0017	Dmlncc2	0.0837	0.8822	0.0300	0.0039
10	Dmdlnoc	0.1230	0.0101	0.8662	0.0006	Dmdlnoc2	0.4329	0.0012	0.5646	0.0011
10	Dmdlngc	0.0349	0.0145	0.0127	0.9378	Dmdlngc2	0.0410	0.0013	0.0342	0.9233
20	Dmdlngdp	0.9764	0.0081	0.0114	0.0040	Dmdlngdp2	0.9115	0.0183	0.0615	0.0085
20	Dmlncc	0.0879	0.9096	0.0006	0.0017	Dmlncc2	0.1119	0.8169	0.0666	0.0043
20	Dmdlnoc	0.1231	0.0102	0.8659	0.0006	Dmdlnoc2	0.4925	0.0047	0.4979	0.0047
20	Dmdlngc	0.0349	0.0145	0.0127	0.9377	Dmdlngc2	0.0575	0.0016	0.0549	0.8858
30	Dmdlngdp	0.9764	0.0081	0.0114	0.0040	Dmdlngdp2	0.9072	0.0185	0.0652	0.0088
30	Dmlncc	0.0880	0.9096	0.0006	0.0017	Dmlncc2	0.1510	0.7280	0.1160	0.0048
30	Dmdlnoc	0.1231	0.0102	0.8659	0.0006	Dmdlnoc2	0.4849	0.0066	0.5016	0.0067
30	Dmdlngc	0.0349	0.0145	0.0127	0.9377	Dmdlngc2	0.0827	0.0020	0.0835	0.8316