A Review of the Research Progress of Motor Vibration and Noise

Wu, Bo; Qiao, Mingzhong

doi:https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5897198

International Transactions on Electrical Energy Systems

On this page

Abstract Introduction Conclusion Data Availability Conflicts of Interest Acknowledgments References Copyright Related Articles

Review Article | Open Access

Volume 2022 | Article ID 5897198 | https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5897198

A Review of the Research Progress of Motor Vibration and Noise

Bo Wu¹and Mingzhong Qiao¹

Academic Editor: Yu-Chi Wu

Received13 Aug 2022

Revised17 Nov 2022

Accepted19 Nov 2022

Published05 Dec 2022

Abstract

Motor vibration and noise is an important index to measure motor performance. How to reduce vibration and noise is one of the important topics in the field of motor design. Analysis, calculation, and reduction of motor vibration and noise have attracted more and more attention from motor designers. Based on the three main types of noise sources of motors, this paper firstly analyzes their causes and mechanisms and secondly introduces their main research methods. Although there are many summary articles on the research of motor vibration and noise, most of the theories and research methods on the causes of various kinds of noise are not comprehensive enough, lacking theoretical calculation and analysis, especially for mechanical noise and aerodynamic noise. This paper summarizes the research in the recent ten years, especially in the recent five years, with a view to providing a reference for the future development of this field.

1. Introduction

The development of new high-performance motors and their drive systems is an important part of the country’s economic, industrial, and technological development, involving civil, aerospace, military, and other fields. According to the development spirit of the country’s “14th Five-Year Plan,” green development is an inevitable trend in the future development of all walks of life, especially in fields sensitive to vibration and noise, such as ship power and electric vehicles. In addition to the strong driving performance of the motor, low vibration and noise is also another important indicator to measure the motor and its driving system, which is one of the goals of green development.

It should be pointed out that the violent vibration of the motor caused by the electromagnetic force will not only affect the driving performance of the motor but also cause serious pollution to people’s living and working environment and affect people’s mental and physical health. How to properly handle the high drive and low noise of the motor is currently a research hotspot of well-known universities and research institutions at home and abroad.

Motor noise is mainly divided into three categories: mechanical noise, aerodynamic noise, and electromagnetic noise. Figure 1 shows the main noise sources of motors and their main causes. The first thing to be clear is that the vibration of the motor is not a single type of noise but a complex superposition of three noise sources. In general research, one or two types of main noise sources will be identified first, and then, the main noise sources will be analyzed separately on this basis. In this paper, for the convenience of discussion, the research progress of three kinds of noise will be discussed separately, focusing on the research progress of electromagnetic noise, in order to provide a reference for future research in this field.

2. Mechanical Noise of the Motor

2.1. Overview of Mechanical Noise

When the motor is running, the noise generated due to friction, the collision between various components, and the imbalance of the rotor and structural resonance are called mechanical noise [1]. Therefore, the study of motor structure noise is also the study of the above parts.

2.1.1. Rotor Unbalanced Noise

During the manufacturing process, assembly, and working process of the motor, the rotor is worn or asymmetrical due to various reasons. These problems will lead to the imbalance of the rotor and cause noise. The rotor unbalanced noise frequency is as follows:where n is the motor speed.

2.1.2. Bearing Noise

Bearings are the key components that support the stator and rotor in the motor. During the working process of the motor, on the one hand, the bearing is subjected to various forces in the motor to generate vibration noise. On the other hand, the rolling elements of the rolling bearing move relative to the inner and outer rings of the bearing when the motor is running, and the friction and collision with the contact surface produce vibration noise [2]. Table 1 lists the possible peak frequencies and causes of bearing noise.

In the table, d represents the diameter of the bearing ball (mm); D represents the diameter of the bearing pitch circle (mm); α represents the contact angle; n represents the speed of the motor shaft (r/min); indicates frequency; Z represents the number of bearing balls.

When the identification accuracy of the noise source is not high, the frequency characteristics of the bearing noise can also be estimated by the number of bearing balls. Table 2 gives the empirical formulas for the characteristic frequencies of different noises of the bearing:

2.2. Research Progress

Zhang et al. used the piezoelectric module in the ANSYS simulation software and used EMI (piezoelectric impedance) technology to determine the resonance frequency bands of the stator and rotor of the small motor at three frequency points and found that by changing the thickness and material of the motor stator. The natural frequency and resonance frequency band, which can be changed by parameters such as EMI, have laid the foundation for EMI technology in the treatment of motor vibration and noise reduction [3]. Song and Lu Lianyong put forward measures and methods to control mechanical noise through the research and analysis of the bearing noise of explosion-proof motors, but they mainly start from the aspects of production, maintenance, and use, without in-depth theoretical analysis [4]. He of Kunming University of Science and Technology, through the test of the vibration and noise of the propulsion motor under the test bench, based on the idea of modal hybrid parameter adjustment and modeling, the experimental modal analysis and finite element modeling of each subcomponent of the motor were carried out. The dynamic model of the connecting bearing of each subcomponent is simplified, and finally, the dynamic equivalent finite element model of the whole machine is obtained [1]. Wang et al. from Southwest Jiaotong University proposed a noise source identification method based on EEMD-FastICA-STFT, analyzed three kinds of automobile starter motors, and concluded that the main mechanical noise of the starter motor is the first order, and the main noise source is the rotor unbalanced noise [5]. Zhang et al. used the power spectrum method to analyze and process the vibration and noise of the motor and identified the mechanical noise of the motor [6]. Generally speaking, the suppression of the mechanical noise of the motor mainly focuses on the machining accuracy of the motor and the degree of lubrication of the bearings, so as to reduce the modal resonance of the motor [7].

3. Aerodynamic Noise of the Motor

3.1. Overview of Aerodynamic Noise

The root cause of the aerodynamic noise of the motor is the sharp pulsation of the airflow pressure in the motor ventilation system and the friction between the airflow and the duct. This type of noise mainly includes the following: the rotation noise generated by the high-speed rotation of the air fan; the eddy current noise generated by the protrusion on the rotor surface of the motor during the rotation process that affects the airflow; the whistle sound generated by the airflow encountering obstacles.

3.1.1. Rotational Noise

When the fan rotates at a high speed, the air particles will be affected by the periodic force of the fan blades, resulting in pressure pulsation and in rotating noise. The frequency of the rotational noise is related to the number of times the blades hit the air particles per second:where k is 1, 2, 3, …; is the number of leaves; n is the fan speed (r/min).

3.1.2. Eddy Current Noise

During the rotation of the fan, any small protrusion on the fan blade will affect the airflow. Due to the action of the viscous force, a series of small eddies will be split, and the splitting of the vortices and the vortices will disturb the air, resulting in noise. The frequency iswhere i = 1, 2, 3, …; Sh is the Stohalide number, between 0.14 and 0.20, generally 0.185; υ is the relative velocity of the gas and the object; D is the projection of the front surface width of the object on the plane perpendicular to the velocity.

3.1.3. Flute

When the airflow encounters an obstruction, a single-frequency whistle will be issued. Common ones are as follows:

(1) Interference between Stator and Rotor Air Ducts. Radial ventilation channels are often arranged in the stator and rotor iron cores of large and medium-sized motors, and they are aligned in the axial direction. Because the spacer is installed in the ventilation duct, when the motor is running, the rotation of the rotor will drive the spacer to vibrate, so that it is sometimes aligned and sometimes staggered, resulting in pressure fluctuations. Its frequency mainly depends on the number of rotor slots and the speed:where k = 1, 2, 3, …; is the number of rotor slots; n is the rotor speed (r/min).

(2) Interference between Rotor Bars and Stator Windings. The gap between the rotor bars of the induction motor and the ends of the stator windings also creates interference and whistles. Medium-sized two-pole asynchronous motors generally do not have rotor ventilation slots in view of mechanical strength. Cooling air enters between the air gap and the rotor wedges from both ends and then flows into the stator radial ventilation slots, which produce a whistle sound.

(3) Interference between the Fan Blades and the Cooling Ribs of the Base. In a closed external fan-cooled motor, if the blades of the fan are relatively close to the cooling ribs of the base, pressure pulsations will be generated at the entrance of the air duct of the cooling ribs, resulting in a whistle sound. Its frequency iswhere M is the least common multiple of the blades and the cooling ribs.

3.2. Main Research Methods

There are two main methods for the study of aerodynamic noise, one is the finite element method based on the Lighthill equation, which is mainly suitable for the calculation of low-frequency noise; the other is the statistical energy method, which is suitable for the calculation of high-frequency noise [8].

3.2.1. Lighthill’s Aeroacoustic Theory

Lighthill composed the fluid equation and the momentum equation into the form of an inhomogeneous wave equation and compared the flow field equation with the sound wave equation, and different parts were regarded as sound sources. The fluid motion equations and momentum equations expressed in the form of Cartesian tensors are as follows:where are the velocity, pressure, and density of the fluid, respectively, t refers to time, for the Kronecker symbol. refers to the fluid viscous stress tensor, which for Stokes fluids iswhere μ is the hydrodynamic viscosity.

Equation (6) takes the partial derivative with respect to time, and subtracting equation (7) from the space divergence, we get

Subtracting both sides at the same time becomes the inhomogeneous wave equation; that is, the Lighthill equation is as follows:where is the Lighthill tensor:

The advantage of the Lighthill equation is that the flow field and the sound field are artificially separated; that is, the turbulent flow field is obtained first, and then, the sound radiation prediction is performed by obtaining the equivalent sound source according to (10).

3.2.2. Basic Principles of Statistical Energy Method

Figure 2 shows the energy flow model of the statistical energy method of the two systems, represents the input power of the ith system, represents the dissipated power of the ith system, and represents the average power delivered by system i to system j.

According to energy conservation law, there is the following energy relationship between the two subsystems:

Due to radiation and other reasons, the power loss of each subsystem iswhere ω is the angular frequency (rad/s), is the average vibrational energy of space-time energy of subsystem i, is the internal loss factor of system i, is the coupling loss factor between subsystems i and j, so the energy delivered by subsystem i to subsystem j is

Therefore, the energy conservation equation shown in equation (12) can also be written as follows:where is the total loss factor of system I and is the internal loss factor of system i and the sum of all coupling loss factors.

Extending equation (15) to a system with N subsystems, if the input power , internal loss factor , and coupling loss factor of all subsystems are known, then the vibration energy of each subsystem can be predicted by the SEA balance equation.

3.3. Research Progress

Many researchers at home and abroad have also carried out a lot of research work on the aerodynamic noise characteristics of motors. ZuoShuguang et al. used the boundary element method to calculate the aerodynamic noise of the claw-pole motor and found that this method can describe the noise generation mechanism more accurately than the FW-H model and has more engineering application value [8]. In order to reduce the ventilation noise of the motor, Ma et al. measured the ventilation noise of different electric fans and determined whether the fan meets the cooling requirements of the motor through the temperature rise test of the motor, providing a new solution for improving the aerodynamic noise of the motor [9]. Wang and SuGuoxia control the aerodynamic noise from the two aspects of the noise source and propagation direction and propose a method to reduce the aerodynamic noise of the high-voltage square box asynchronous motor by optimizing the diameter of the fan and the structure of the fan blade [10]. Qin et al. used the steady SSTk-ω turbulence model to analyze the aerodynamic noise characteristics of PMSM based on the FW-H coupled unsteady flow field, carried out sound field experiments, and found that the main noise source of PMSM is the surface sound of the centrifugal fan. The power can reach 166 dB peak [11]. Jianhua converted the traditional Lighthill equation into the weak integral form of Helmholtz and also used the FW-H equation coupling to calculate the noise radiation of the centrifugal fan [12]. On the basis of the calculation and experimental analysis of the cooling fan of the automobile generator, Wang et al. proposed a set of rotating noise prediction methods for the first time [13]. Zhang and Dong Dawei established a three-dimensional nonconstant numerical simulation method to study the aerodynamic noise optimization design of the front-end cover of the generator [14]. Zhu and Wang established a simulation calculation model of the internal flow field of the traction motor and used the calculation result of the unsteady internal flow field as the sound source to calculate and analyze the aerodynamic noise characteristics of the motor [15]. Chen et al. used the separation eddy simulation method and Lighthill acoustic analogy theory to simulate the sound field and flow field of the traction motor. The results show that the aerodynamic noise source is mainly concentrated in the fan area, which is caused by the periodic rotation of the fan [16]. Gill et al. proposed one-, two-, and three-component integrated turbulent disturbance models for the first time and performed noise calculations [17]. Fenini et al. calculated the aerodynamic noise emitted by the subsonic dry air flow through the orifice plate from the two aspects of the external sound pressure level and the internal sound power level and established a new CFD calculation model for solving the Reynolds number average equation. The problem of sound power generated by the orifice plate [18]. Ding conducted a noise test for an air-cooled permanent magnet motor. When measuring the noise spectrum of the motor, he found that the permanent magnet motor with 2000 rpm/min is mainly aerodynamic noise, and the motor with 1600 rpm/min is mainly electromagnetic noise. Through comparative analysis, he found that unequal-pitch blades are more effective in reducing the aerodynamic noise of the motor [19]. In 2019, Fan et al. used the CFD method to conduct numerical analysis on the steady-state and transient flow and sound field of an air-cooled motor and verified it through experiments [20]. In 2021, Zheng et al. studied the self-fan-cooled traction motor and analyzed the motor’s external flow field based on the principle of computational fluid dynamics. Through fan structure optimization, the fan performance was improved [21]. Weiping Li and Taiming Huang put forward a numerical simulation method to predict the aerodynamic noise of claw-pole motor for vehicles and verified its effectiveness through experiments [22]. Shen et al. established a finite element acoustic calculation model based on the calculation results of the unsteady flow field of the self-ventilated motor, simulated and calculated the aerodynamic noise of the motor at the highest speed, obtained the amplitude and spectrum characteristics of the aerodynamic noise generated by the cooling fan, and compared them with the test results. The results show that the calculation method described in this paper is suitable for predicting the noise in the motor technical design stage [23].

4. Electromagnetic Noise of the Motor

4.1. Overview of Electromagnetic Noise

In the motor, the electromagnetic noise is the main component of the motor noise, which mainly propagates outward through the magnetic yoke. The air-gap magnetic wave acts on the stator core teeth to generate two electromagnetic force components, radial and tangential. The radial component causes the stator core to vibrate and deform, which is the main source of the electromagnetic noise of the motor. The tangential component causes the tooth root to bend and produce local deformation, which is the secondary source of the electromagnetic noise of the motor. When the radial electromagnetic force wave is close to the stator frequency, resonance will occur, which greatly enhances the motor noise. Moreover, most of the motors are driven by inverter source systems. When the drive voltages contain rich harmonic components, especially when these harmonics are large enough and close to the stator frequencies, obvious electromagnetic vibration will also be generated. From Maxwell’s equations, the radial electromagnetic force per unit area in the air-gap magnetic field can be calculated as follows:where B is the air-gap magnetic density, θ is the mechanical angular displacement, and is the vacuum permeability.

There are main wave magnetic potentials and various harmonic magnetic potentials in the stator and rotor windings of the motor, and they superimpose each other to generate various force waves. The radial electromagnetic force wave generated by the main wave magnetic field is

In the formula, , and it is an invariant part of the radial force wave, which acts on the stator core evenly without vibration and noise.

Among them, p is the number of pole pairs of the dominant wave, is the angular velocity of the dominant wave, and is the initial phase angle. is the alternating part of the radial force wave. The angular frequency of this force wave is twice the power frequency, which makes the stator and rotor generate vibration noise twice the power frequency.

Due to the influence of the stator and rotor cogging, the permeance will change periodically, which will cause the periodic change of the air gap magnetic density, which will also generate electromagnetic noise, called tooth harmonic noise. The tooth harmonic noise frequency is

Among them, i is the harmonic order, Q is the cogging number, and n is the rotational speed.

Due to the asymmetry of the magnetic flux distribution caused by the eccentricity of the stator and the rotor or the asymmetry of the magnetic circuit, there will be a unilateral magnetic pull force on one side with a large force and a small force on the other side, which will also generate vibration noise. Figure 3 is the basic flow of research and analysis on electromagnetic vibration.

4.2. Research Progress of Electromagnetic Force Analysis

The radial electromagnetic force wave of the motor is the main reason for the electromagnetic vibration of the motor. After the continuous research on the electromagnetic force characteristics of the motor by domestic and foreign scholars, there are mainly two methods: the analytical method and the finite element method.

The analytical method obtains the distribution of the magnetic field by multiplying the magnetic potential by the magnetic permeability and then obtains the magnitude of the electromagnetic force according to the Maxwell stress tensor method [24]. Professor Hu and Zuo Shuguang proposed an analytical model method for predicting the nonlinear radial electromagnetic force caused by the saturated magnetic field, which can be used to calculate the radial electromagnetic force at any pole-to-pole and any rotor position [25]. Professor Han et al. proposed a quasianalytical calculation method that can analyze the impact of different rotor topologies on vibration and noise, which saves calculation time and resources and improves accuracy [26]. Zhang used the analytical method to deduce the analytic expression of the excitation force wave of the permanent magnet motor under load and pointed out that the asymmetry of the design or installation of the permanent magnet will generate low-order spatial excitation force waves, resulting in larger vibration noise [27]. The exact subdomain method proposed by Wu et al. takes into account the effect of the slot in the stator core of the motor and is currently the most accurate method for solving the surface-mounted permanent magnet motor analytically [28]. Islam and Husain used the Maxwell stress tensor method combined with the air gap radial and tangential magnetic field distributions obtained by the two-dimensional analytical method to study the radial and tangential electromagnetic force distribution of the surface mount permanent magnet motor along the circumference. Analytical model of radial and tangential electromagnetic forces for permanent magnet motors [29]. Liao et al. proposed a novel harmonic current suppression algorithm, which can not only accurately analyze the harmonic voltage, harmonic current, and their effects on the permanent magnet synchronous motor and its drive system but also suppress the harmonic current of the motor due to the distortion of the motor air gap magnetic field [30]. When Xiao et al. studied the variable frequency motor, they calculated and analyzed the electromagnetic excitation force characteristics of the motor air gap under the variable frequency excitation according to Maxwell’s law and found that the high-frequency harmonic introduced by the converter would make the motor radiate a lot of noise near the switching frequency [31]. Huiying studies the soft switching technology to reduce the impact of harmonic input from the drive system on motor vibration [32].

The finite element method discretizes the motor into finite units through the principle of difference, which improves the accuracy of the electromagnetic calculation of the motor, and can deal with nonlinear and local saturation effects through the finite element method. Professor Xing et al. proposed a fast calculation method for electromagnetic force density in 2021 and verified the effectiveness of the method through finite element analysis [33]. Professor Feng et al. established an electromagnetic finite element model for the IPMSM with different air gap states and believed that the air gap deformation would affect the vibration calculation results [34]. Wang and Wu believed that the influence of low-frequency harmonic current on radial electromagnetic force depends on the amplitude and phase of the harmonic current [35]. Professor Wang Dong from the Naval University of Engineering calculated the radial electromagnetic force wave of the motor through the three-dimensional finite element method and summarized the variation law of the electromagnetic force wave along the axial direction of the motor [36]. Sun et al. of Hanyang University in South Korea used the finite element method and the Maxwell stress tensor method to calculate the radial electromagnetic force of two permanent magnet motors with 8 poles, 9 slots and 8 poles and 12 slots, respectively. The results show that the former has a larger lower order than the latter. Radial force [37]. Taking a 32 kW motor as an example, Zhou et al. analyzed the variation characteristics of harmonic magnetic field density and radial electromagnetic force when the power supply contains low-order harmonics by using the time-stepping finite element method and designed a low harmonic winding scheme to reduce the low-frequency vibration of the motor when the power supply contains low-order harmonics [38]. Zechen et al. calculated the magnetic potential and electromagnetic exciting force of single- and double-layer low harmonic winding by analytical method and compared the ordinary double layer short distance winding by 2D finite element analysis simulation. It was found that the single- and double-layer low harmonic winding improved its air gap magnetic density distribution and motor stability due to the reduction of magnetic potential harmonics of its stator winding. At the same time, due to the reduction of its radial magnetic density harmonic amplitude, the electromagnetic excitation force of the motor is reduced, which can effectively weaken the vibration and noise of the motor [39]. Liang et al. established the TMPS-HESM model of magnetic pole eccentricity when studying the vibration and noise of TMPS-HESM and established the vibration and noise model through ANSYS finite element simulation software, which effectively demonstrated that magnetic pole eccentricity can effectively reduce the harmonic content of air gap magnetic flux density, especially the third harmonic [40]. Liu et al. deduced the analytical expression of the electromagnetic force wave of DSR-PMSM by introducing the offset factor. Then, the vibration displacement response spectrum and noise sound pressure characteristics of DSR-PMSM before and after the internal and external armature teeth offset are analyzed and compared with the help of the finite element platform, which has certain theoretical value and engineering significance for improving the NVH performance of the motor [41]. Ai and Lan calculated the static characteristics and electromagnetic force of the motor by the finite element method, and the results verified the feasibility of the magnetic suspension operation of the motor [42].

4.3. Research Progress of Motor Structure Modal

The vibration of the motor is not only related to the electromagnetic excitation force but also to the structural mode of the motor. Common motor modal analysis methods include the analytical method, numerical method, and experimental method. The analytical method is mainly based on equivalent parameters (equivalent mass, equivalent stiffness, etc.), the numerical method is mainly based on the finite element method, and the experimental method is mainly based on the hammer method and the vibration exciter method [43].

The modal analysis of modern motor structures is a combination of the main finite element method and the experimental method. Wang and Wang analyzed the low-order natural frequencies of the large induction motor stator modal with windings and without windings and found that the finite element calculation results were lower than the experimental values when the windings were not considered. The conclusion is that the windings are not negligible and the end windings are negligible [43]. Xie Ying et al. studied the stator modes of small induction motors. She conducted experimental measurements and comparisons of the stator modes with end windings and the end windings removed and came to the conclusion that the end windings have little influence on the stator modes [44]. Dai and Cui Shumei also proposed a method to directly distinguish the natural frequencies of the various orders of the modal under the installed and working conditions of the motor according to the noise spectrum and electromagnetic excitation force characteristics [45]. Professor Hong et al. from Tsinghua University proposed a modal analysis method based on electromagnetic vibration exciter, which can well reflect the running state of the motor [46]. Li et al. studied the effects of windings and dipping paint on the natural frequency of the motor stator structure by a combination of finite element and experimental methods [47]. Jin et al. calculated the vibration characteristics and noise amplitude of the motor with or without stator core magnetostrictive effect and determined the influence of magnetostrictive effect on the harmonic distribution of motor vibration noise [48]. Wang and Wu provided a finite element core parameter prediction method for modal analysis of the motor stator core, which improved the simulation prediction accuracy [49]. Zhang et al. carried out a modal analysis on the stator of the permanent magnet synchronous motor through finite element analysis and hammering method. The results show that the modal frequency of the stator structure of the motor is greatly different from the frequency of the radial electromagnetic force wave, and resonance will not occur due to the radial electromagnetic force of the motor [50]. Professor Liu et al. established an equivalent digital physical three-dimensional model for the motor end cover, obtained the calculation mode and modal vibration mode of the end cover through modal analysis, and used a lightweight design method to optimize the structural topology of the motor end cover [51]. Huo and Hu proposed a dome topology, which is different from the traditional motor controller cover, to reduce motor vibration [52].

4.4. Research Progress of Electromagnetic Vibration of Motors

The natural extension of the electromagnetic force analysis and structural modal analysis of the motor electromagnetic vibration research analysis type is because the electromagnetic force analysis depends on the analysis of the electromagnetic field of the motor, and the characteristics of the electromagnetic field are greatly affected by the nonlinear characteristics of the ferromagnetic material of the motor, so the analytical method is based on the analysis method. The electromagnetic force analysis of the electromagnetic force can only analyze the frequency characteristics of the electromagnetic force but not the amplitude characteristics of the electromagnetic force. Therefore, the frequency characteristics of motor vibration are generally analyzed by analytical method, and the amplitude characteristics of motor vibration are analyzed by numerical method [53].

In the analysis of electromagnetic vibration by analytical method, Fiedler et al. combined the electromagnetic force obtained by the one-dimensional magnetic field and the cylindrical shell model and applied the modal superposition method to deduce the analytical model of electromagnetic vibration of the switched reluctance motor. The salient pole stator of the motor is quite different, and the model does not consider the actual end cover and installation constraints of the motor [54]. He studied the electromagnetic vibration and noise of the brushed DC permanent magnet motor, and his research showed that the thickness of the epoxy resin adhesive between the stator permanent magnet and the casing has a great influence on the stator structural mode and vibration noise [55]. Guo studied the electromagnetic vibration of the disc motor and established an analytical model of the electromagnetic vibration response of the disc motor [56]. Huang studied the electromagnetic vibration characteristics of induction motors with variable frequency power supply, pointed out that the electromagnetic force harmonic content is rich in variable frequency power supply, and suggested that the selection of carrier frequency should avoid the slot frequency of induction motors as much as possible [57]. Xie et al. studied the vibration characteristics of the induction motor when the end ring is broken and found that the side frequency vibration near the fundamental frequency changes significantly after the end ring is broken, and the motor can be diagnosed by analyzing the signal [58]. Yang proposed the method of using harmonic current injection to suppress motor vibration from the perspective of motor control. The effectiveness of this method is verified [59]. Through finite element simulation and prototype tests, Wang and Wang compared and evaluated the performance of two commonly used torque ripple and electromagnetic vibration suppression schemes in electric vehicle drive motor engineering. The results show that the rotor pole segmented motor can achieve the same force and energy quality as the skewed slot motor under the working condition of large load and inertia and has a good suppression effect on electromagnetic vibration [60]. Ren used the finite element method to simulate and analyze the vibration response of the motor for the harmonic current introduced by the inverter and established a multifield coupling vibration response prediction model of the permanent magnet synchronous motor [61].

5. Conclusion

The research on motor noise is very complex, it involves many disciplines, such as electromagnetism, acoustics, mathematics, mechanical structure, fluid mechanics, and the structure of the motor itself is also very complex, which brings more research difficulty. Here, this paper only briefly introduces the causes and research methods of various motor noises and briefly reviews the research progress in this field in recent years. The conclusions are as follows:(1)The mechanical noise of the motor is mainly generated by the interaction between the various components in the operation of the motor. The earliest research on the vibration and noise of the motor in the world is the mechanical noise. Because it is mainly related to the structure and manufacturing materials of the motor, the current research is mainly aimed at this.(2)The aerodynamic noise of the motor is mainly related to the airflow in the motor ventilation pipe, which mainly involves aerodynamics, fluid mechanics, and other disciplines. At present, the main research methods are still based on Lighthill’s aeroacoustic theory and statistical energy method, and numerical simulation of the airflow in the motor is carried out through computer simulation software.(3)The electromagnetic noise of the motor is mainly generated by the radial electromagnetic force, which is also a hot spot in the research field of motor vibration and noise. In recent years, the research mainly focuses on the analysis and calculation of electromagnetic force wave and its vibration principle, as well as the main parameters affecting vibration. The calculation method of electromagnetic force wave and electromagnetic vibration is extended from the simplified analytical method to the finite element method. Because the finite element method has high solution accuracy and fast convergence speed, the numerical simulation is better.

With the progress of society and the development of technology, especially the development of some new special motors, further research is needed on the vibration and noise of motors.

Data Availability

The data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by theNational Natural Science Foundation of China (51877212). The fee for this manuscript is supported by this project.

References

Y. He, Vibration and Noise Reduction of Propulsion Motor, Kunming University of Science and Technology, Kunming, China, 2013.
C. Gong, Study on Vehicle Starting Motor Noise Characteristic and Noise Source Identification, Southwest Jiaotong University, Chengdu, China, 2017.
J. Zhang, D. Zhou, and L. Zhao, “Mechanical Noise Control of Small DC Motors Based on EMI technology,” Journal of Shaoyang University, vol. 18, no. 6, pp. 21–33, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
Q. Song and H. H. Lu Lianyong, “Generation of mechanical noise in medium-size and small-size ex motors and its control,” Electric Explosion Protection, vol. 3, pp. 1–6, 2006.
View at: Google Scholar
Q. Wang, S. F. Li Hongyan, and D. Yuan Meiling, “Motor Noise Source Identification Based on Spectrum analysis,” Technical Acoustics, vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 529–531, 2009.
View at: Google Scholar
P. Zhang, C. ChangFei, and T. D. FanYongli, “Discussion on Noise Reduction Method of Frequency Conversion Drilling Rig Motor,” China Petroleum Machinery, vol. 20, no. 24, pp. 40–43, 2017.
View at: Google Scholar
M. Liu and J. F. Jing, “Research on Methods of Reducing the Motor Noise,” Marine Electric, vol. 20, no. 12, pp. 21–24, 2011.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. ZuoShuguang, W. K. WuXudong, and H. Sun, “Numerical Simulation and Mechanism Analysis of Aerodynamic Noise in Claw Pole alternator,” Journal of Zhejiang University, vol. 202, no. 3, pp. 612–619, 2017.
View at: Google Scholar
D. Ma, Z. H. KongYiming, and H. Huang, “Analysis of Noise on Three-phase Induction Motor with Frequency from 50 Hz to 60 Hz,” Motor and Control Application, vol. 5, pp. 62–64, 2014.
View at: Google Scholar
L. Wang and D. SuGuoxia, “Method Study of Reducing Ventilation Noise of Induction Motor,” Explosion-Proof Electric Machine, vol. 53, no. 4, 2018.
View at: Google Scholar
L Qin, H. Z. YanRui, and Z. W. LiGang, “Analysis of Aerodynamic Noise Characteristics of Electric-Driven Vibrator Permanent Magnet Synchronous motor,” Journal of Safety and Environment, vol. 10, no. 9, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
Z. Jianhua, “Numerical investigation of unsteady aerodynamics and aero-acoustics in a centrifugal fan,” Journal of Aerospace Power, vol. 30, no. 8, pp. 1888–1899, 2015.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. Wang, D. Dong, and B. Yan, “Prediction method of vehicle alternator cooling fan rotation noise,” Journal of Aerospace Power, vol. 30, no. 07, pp. 1711–1720, 2015.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. Zhang and Y. B. DongDawei, “Numerical simulation analysis for aerodynamic noise of a vehicle alternator,” Journal of Vibration and Shock, vol. 35, no. 01, pp. 174–182, 2016.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. Zhu and W. Wang, “Numerical Simulation Research on Aerodynamic Noise Characteristics of Traction Motor,” Motor and Control Application, vol. 2049, no. 1, pp. 56–61, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
Z. Chen, C. R. WuJiangquan, and H. J. LiWeiye, “Aerodynamic Noise Simulation and Mechanical Analysis on Traction Motors Used in Urban Transit,” Electrical Machinery Technology, no. 3, pp. 8–13, 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
J. Gill, X. Zhang, and P. Joseph, “Single velocity-component modeling of leading edge turbulence interaction noise,” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, vol. 137, no. 6, pp. 3209–3220, 2015.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. Fenini, L. N. Quaroni, and S. Malavasi, “Estimation of aerodynamic noise of diaphragms through IEC 60534-8-3 and CFD,” Measurement and Control, vol. 54, no. 3-4, pp. 189–195, 2021.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
J. Ding, “Noise Test and Characteristic Analysis of Permanent Magnet MotorWith Unequal Impeller,” Micromotors, vol. 07, pp. 30–36, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
Z. F. Fan, P. Huang, and W. Zhang, “Analysis and verification of aerodynamic noise of air-cooled motor,” Motor and Control Application, vol. 46, no. 09, pp. 65–68, 2019.
View at: Google Scholar
G. Zheng, Z. Shen, K. Cui, and H. Weilin, “Performance Optimization of Self-Fan-Cooling Traction Motor Fan,” Motor and Control Application, vol. 48, no. 8, pp. 63–89, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
W. Y. WeipingLi and N. J. TaimingHuang, “Optimizing the Aerodynamic Noise of an Automobile Claw Pole Alternator Using a Numerical method,” Applied Acoustics, vol. 171, 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
Z. Shen, W. L He, T. Wang, and K Cui, “Research on aerodynamic noise calculation method of self-ventilated motor,” Chinese Journal of Turbomachinery, vol. 61, no. 05, pp. 79–84, 2019.
View at: Google Scholar
Z. Song, C. Liu, and H. Zhao, “Investigation on Magnetic Force of a Flux-Modulated Double-Rotor Permanent Magnet Synchronous Machine for Hybrid Electric Vehicle,” IEEE Transactions on Transportation Electrification, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 1383–1394, 2019.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. Hu and L. M. ZuoShuguang, “Analytical Modeling of Nonlinear Radial Electromagnetic Force in Switched Reluctance Motors,” Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, vol. 35, no. 06, pp. 1189–1197, 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
X. Han, Z. X. LiChunlei, and S. Wang, “Quasi-analytical Calculation of Vibration and Noise of Permanent Magnet Assister Synchronous Reluctance Motor and Analysis of its Influencing factors,” Electric Machines and Control, vol. 2024, no. 11, pp. 1–8, 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
R. Zhang, Research of Electromagnetic Exciting Force of Surface-Mounted Permanent Magnet Motors and its Reduction Methods, Shandong University, Shandong, China, 2011.
L. J. Wu, Q. ZhuZ, and P. XiaZ, “An accurate subdomain model for magnetic field computation in slotted surface-mounted permanent-magnet machines,” IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 46, no. 4, 2010.
View at: Google Scholar
R. Islam and I. Husain, “Analytical Model for Predicting Noise and Vibration in Permanent-Magnet Synchronous Motors,” IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 46, no. 6, pp. 2346–2354, 2010.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
Y. Liao, Z. H. E. N. Shuai, L. I. U. Ren, and J. Yao, “Torque ripple suppression of permanent magnet synchronous motor by the harmonic injection,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 31, no. 21, pp. 119–127, 2011.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. Xiao, J. Y. Song, and R. H. Qu, “The effect of harmonics on electromagnetic vibration and noise characteristic in inverter-duty motor,” Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, vol. 36, no. 12, pp. 2607–2615, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
J. Huiying, Research on Vibration Noise Caused by Switching Frequency Modulation with Soft-Switching Technology, Shenyang University of Technology, Shenyang, China, 2017.
Z. Xing, Z. W. WangXiuhe, and W. MaGuangqun, “Calculation of electromagnetic force waves and analysis of stator vibration characteristics of surface mount permanent magnet synchronous motor,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 2041, no. 14, pp. 5004–5013, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
C. Feng, L. Yi, P. Yulong, and Y. Yanjun, “Analysis of radial vibration caused by magnetic force and torque pulsation in interior permanent magnet synchronous motors considering air-gap deformations,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 66, no. 9, pp. 6703–6714, 2019.
View at: Google Scholar
H. Wang and J. Wu, “Influence of Low-Frequency Harmonic Currents on Radial Electromagnetic Force of PMSM,” in Proceedings of the 2020 23rd International Conference on Electrical Machines and Systems(ICEMS), pp. 1574–1577, IEEE, Hamamatsu, Japan, November 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
W. D. SuWu, L. N. WeiKun, and G. Y. ZhangXianbiao, “Analysis of radial electromagnetic force wave of consequent pole hybrid excitation synchronous generator,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 40, no. 24, pp. 7869–7879, 2020.
View at: Google Scholar
T. Sun, “Effect of pole and slot combination on noise and vibration in permanent magnet synchronous motor,” IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, vol. 47, no. 5, pp. 1038–1041, 2011.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
Z. Zhou, S. Wang, Z. Li, Z. Wang, and H. Zhao, “Vibration characteristics and its reduction measurements for induction motors with supply containing low-order harmonics,” Journal of North China Electric Power University, vol. 7, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
L. Zechen, B. Xiaohua, X. Wei, and L. Jiwei, “Analysis of vibration and noise for induction motor with single-double layer low harmonic winding,” MICROMOTORS, vol. 51, no. 10, pp. 17–31, 2018.
View at: Google Scholar
P. Liang, S. H. YangQingliang, and Z. C. QinHaihong, “Research on vibration and noise of magnetic pole eccentricity tangential magnetizing parallel structure hybrid excitation synchronous motor,” Energy Reports, vol. 8, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
K. Liu, B. Y. Zhang, and G. H. Feng, “Research on electromagnetic vibration and noise characteristics of dual sided rotor permanent magnet synchronous motor based on armature offset approach,” Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, vol. 36, no. S1, pp. 95–106, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
C. Y. Ai and Y. P. Lan, “Finite element calculation of electromagnetic force of hybrid excitation flux switching linear magnetic suspension motor,” Mot Control Appl, vol. 48, no. 03, pp. 49–54, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
T. Wang and F. Wang, “Vibration and modal analysis of stator of large induction motors,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 27, no. 12, pp. 41–45, 2007.
View at: Google Scholar
W. Y. XieYing, Y. LvSen, and L. Haisong, “Madal calculation and test of small asynchronous motor,” Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, vol. 30, no. 16, pp. 1–9, 2015.
View at: Google Scholar
Y. Dai and S. L. CuiShumei, “Finite element method modal analysis of driving motor for electric vehicle,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 31, no. 9, pp. 100–104, 2011.
View at: Google Scholar
J. Hong, W. Y. Sun, and H. Cao, “A Method of madal parameter estimation of the motor based on electromagnetic vibration exciter,” IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol. 56, no. 3, pp. 2636–2643, 2020.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
X. H. Li, HuangSurong, and Q. Zhang, “Analysis of natural frequencies of stator structure of permanent magnet synchronous motors for electric vehicles,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 37, no. 8, pp. 2383–2390, 2017.
View at: Google Scholar
L. Jin, Y. Shenbo, R. Dou, and F. Zhai, “Analysis of influence of magnetostrictive effect on vibration noise of permanent magnet synchronous motor,” Mechanical Engineering and Automation, vol. 234, no. 05, pp. 4–6, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
F. Wang and J. J. Wu, “Modal analysis of permanent magnet synchronous motor stator and equivalent model parameter prediction,” AUTO SCI-TECH, no. 05, pp. 35–41, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
W. Zhang, W. Wu, and J. Zhang, “Analysis of stator modal of permanent magnet synchronous motor for vehicle,” Journal of ShijiangzhuangTiedaoUniversity(Natural Science Edition), vol. 35, no. 01, pp. 76–80, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
H. Liu, L. Xuewu, D. Jingjuan et al., “Modal analysis and topological optimization of permanent magnet synchronous motor caps,” MICROMOTORS, vol. 54, no. 01, pp. 1–14, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
D. Huo and L. Hu, “Topological structure design for improving the upper cover mode of vehicle-mounted motor controller,” Small & Special Electrical Machines, vol. 50, no. 01, pp. 19–22, 2022.
View at: Google Scholar
C. Jiang, Design of Permanent Magnet Motor for Rim Drive Device and Research on its Electromagnetic Vibration Characteristics, Naval University of Engineering, Wuhan, China, 2020.
J. O. Fiedler, K. A. Kasper, and R. W. D. Doncker, “Calculation of the acoustic noise spectrum of SRM using modal superposition,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 57, no. 9, pp. 2939–2945, 2010.
View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
G. He, Analysis of Electromagnetic Vibration-And-Noise of Permanent-Magnet Direct Current Commutator Motors, Shanghai Jiaotong University, Shanghai, China, 2012.
B. Guo, Design and Multi-Physical Fields Analysis of High Speed Axial Flux Permanent Magnet Machine, Southeast University, Jiangsu, China, 2017.
T. Huang, Research on Electromagnetic Vibration Problems of Inverted-Fed Induction Machine, Wuhan University, Hubei, China, 2014.
Y. Xie, L. Guo Jinpeng, and C. Peng, “Research on electromagnetic performances and vibration variation of induction motor with broken end rings,” Proceedings of the CSEE, vol. 39, no. 6, pp. 1803–1814, 2019.
View at: Google Scholar
H. Yang, Electromagnetic Vibration Analysis of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor, Zhejiang University, Zhejiang, China, 2011.
D. Wang and X. Wang, “Research on different design approaches to mitigate torque ripple and electromagnetic vibration for high-performance electric vehicle traction machine,” Journal of Electrical Engineering, vol. 16, no. 04, pp. 42–50, 2021.
View at: Google Scholar
J. Ren, Multi-field Coupling Vibratio Analysis of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor Considering Harmonic Current, Chongqing University of Technology, Chongqing, China, 2022.

Copyright

Copyright © 2022 Bo Wu and Mingzhong Qiao. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

PDF Download Citation

Download other formats

Order printed copies

Views

1116

Downloads

643

Citations