Stiff Fluid in Accelerated Universes with Torsion
The flat Friedmann universes filled by stiff fluid and a nonminimally coupled material scalar field with polynomial potentials of the fourth degree are considered in the framework of the Einstein-Cartan theory. Exact general solution is obtained for arbitrary positive values of the coupling constant . A comparative analysis of the cosmological models with and without stiff fluid is carried out. Some effects of stiff fluid are elucidated. It is shown that singular models with a de Sitter asymptotic and with the power-law asymptotic at late times are possible. It is found that is a specific value of the coupling constant. It is demonstrated that the bouncing models without the particle horizon and with an accelerated expansion by a de Sitter law of an evolution at late times are admissible.
Recent cosmic observations [1–6] favor an isotropic spatially flat Universe, which is at present expanding with acceleration. The source of this expansion is an unknown substance with negative pressure called dark energy (DE). Establishment of the origin of DE has become an important problem. Different theoretical models of DE have been put forward (see, e.g., the reviews [7–10] and references therein). Among these models various modifications of general relativity (GR) were considered, the Einstein-Cartan theory (ECT) in particular [11–13]. This theory [14–17] is an extension of GR to a space time with torsion, and it reduces to GR when the torsion vanishes. The ECT is the simplest version of the Poincaré gauge theory of gravity (PGTG). It should be noted that the ECT contains a nondynamic torsion, because its gravitational action is proportional to the curvature scalar of the Riemann-Cartan space-time. In this sense, the ECT is a degenerate gauge theory [17–20]. This drawback is absent in the PGTG since its gravitational Lagrangian includes invariants quadratic in the curvature and torsion tensors. Nevertheless the ECT is a viable theory of gravity whose observational predictions are in agreement with the classical tests of GR, and it differs significantly from GR only at very high densities of matter [17, 21, 22].
The ECT finds applications in cosmology [23–28], particle theory [19, 29, 30], and the theory of strong interactions [31, 32]. From some time past, the interest to ECT has grown in connection with the fact that torsion arises naturally in the supergravity [33–35], Kaluza-Klein [36–38], and syperstring [39–41] theories. gravity with torsion has been developed [42–45] as one of the simplest extensions of the ECT. In  it has been demonstrated that, in gravity, torsion can be a geometric source for the accelerated expansion. The equivalence between a Brans-Dicke theory with the Brans-Dicke parameter and the Palatini gravity with torsion has been demonstrated in . gravity has been constructed [46–48] as the extension of the “teleparallel” equivalent of GR , which uses the Weitzenböck connection that has no curvature but only torsion.
At present, the considerably increased precision of measurements in the modern observational cosmology stipulated its essential progress. In this connection, the exact cosmological solutions, which makes it possible to elucidate the detailed picture of an evolution of models, are of great interest. It is well known that in GR the exact solutions of the Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) cosmological models constitute a basis for comparison of theoretical predictions with observations. On the other hand, the problem of the cosmological perturbations may be correct, if it is constructed against a background of the exact solution.
Other problems of the cosmology, singularities, horizons, and so forth, remain no less acute problems. The main aim of this paper is the investigation of the possibility of the solution of some problems of the modern cosmology in the framework of the ECT. Furthermore, the exact integration of the ECT equations for the different combination of sources and the comparative analysis of the corresponding cosmological models are of interest in their own right, since they allows to elucidate the role of the sources of the gravitational field in cosmology.
In the framework of the ECT with a nonminimally coupled material scalar field that has polynomial potentials of the fourth degree, we here study isotropic spatially flat cosmologies in which stiff fluid is taken into account. The motivation to investigate a nonminimally coupled scalar field is based on the results obtained within the framework of the torsionless theories of gravity in connection with the inflationary cosmology (see, e.g., [50–54]) and DE model building [55–57]. On the other hand, the consideration of this version of the ECT in comparison to gravity with torsion and gravity is motivated by the fact that, in my opinion, the ECT requires a further study. It is relevant to remark here that, asitis well known, in the literature there exist a limited number of the exact cosmological solutions in the framework of the ECT.
The interest in a scalar field potential in relativistic theories of gravity has been aroused by a number of circumstances: its role in cosmology with a time variable cosmological constant  and in quantum cosmology ; models with arise in alternative theories of gravity [60, 61] and supergravity ; a scalar potential governs an inflation  and is actively used in theories of dark matter (DM) and dark energy (DE) [7–10]. It is well known from GR that a period of accelerated expansion requires . In the paper we will consider cosmological models with and . The reasons to study cosmology with negative potentials were considered in .
A stiff cosmological fluid, with pressure equal to the energy density, can be described by a massless scalar field, which is predicted by the string theory. On the other hand, the stiff fluid is an important component because, at early times, it could describe the shear dominated phase of a possible initial anisotropic scenario and is dominating the remaining components of the model . Of no little interest is the circumstance that this fluid leads to integrability of the Einstein-Cartan equations.
In , the flat Friedmann universes filled by radiation, stiff fluid and a nonminimally coupled ghost scalar field with polynomial potentials of the fourth degree have been investigated in the framework of the ECT. Exact particular solutions have been obtained and analyzed. The role of sources in the evolution of models has been elucidated.
The exact general solution of an analogous problem for models containing only a nonminimally coupled scalar field with an arbitrary coupling constant has been obtained in . An analysis of the solutions for the material scalar field has shown the following. (i)For the solution exists for , , where is Einstein's constant only and describes a countable number of nonsingular cosmological models with de Sitter asymptotics for the late times. (ii)For the five types of singular models exist: for the first model the scale factor as grows by the law (); for the second model asymptotically tends to a finite value; other three models expand from an initial singularity, reach the maximum, and then begin to contract to a final singularity. (iii)There are the specific values of the parameter : , and . The specific feature of the value consists in the behavior of the scale factor, when : , where for , while for . The value is singled out as only in this case there exists the singular expanding model, which has the asymptotic . From three types of the recollapsing models with only for we have the following behavior of the scale factor: , while for others , we get
The exact general solutions for spatially flat FRW cosmologies with a nonminimally coupled scalar field that has polynomial potentials of the fourth degree have been obtained in . The main results for the material scalar field are as follows. (a)For , , and , the solution describes bouncing models of four types with the accelerated expansion at late times by the laws and . For , , the qualitative character of the model evolution does not change. (b)For , for all , , there are two types of collapsing models and one type of expanding models. For there exists a unified model of DM and DE. The case with describes the recollapsing models.
The paper is organized as follows. In the next section we present the model and corresponding field equations. In Section 3, we obtain exact general solution of the Einstein-Cartan equations for , . In Section 3.1 we consider the models with a scalar-torsion field and stiff fluid and discuss some interesting particular cases. In Section 3.2 we analyze the mixture of stiff fluid with a scalar-torsion field that has polynomial potentials of the fourth degree. We summarize our results in Section 4.
2. Field Equations
The Lagrangian of the model is chosen in the form  where is the curvature scalar obtained from the full connection ; are the Christoffel symbols of the second kind; is the torsion tensor; , where is the Newtonian constant; is the potential of a scalar field; Łfl is the Lagrangian of stiff fluid; conforms to the material scalar field; corresponds to the ghost scalar field.
The metric has the signature (); the Riemann and Ricci tensors are defined as
and . We should note that in the framework of ECT, a scalar field nonminimally coupled to gravity gives rise to torsion, even though the scalar field has zero spin. It follows from (2) that the torsion can interact with a scalar field only through its trace: . Hence, the curvature scalar can be presented in the form  where is the Riemannian part of the curvature built from the Christoffel symbols; is the covariant derivative of the Riemannian space.
One can note that the Lagrangian (2) is a covariant generalization of its counterpart in GR, and, for , we obtain the so-called conformal coupling (for in the torsionless theory). As shown in , when , , , the scalar field corresponding to the Lagrangian (2) is the axion field in GR. In cosmology the axion field is a cold dark matter candidate (see, e.g., [67, 68] and references therein).
Varying the action with the Lagrangian (2) in , , and , we obtain the following set of equations for the gravitational fields and matter: where Here and are the energy density and pressure of stiff fluid, respectively; is the d'Alembertian operator of the Riemannian space; is the four-velocity ; , and .
It is not difficult to verify that the effective scalar-torsion energy-momentum tensor , and the stiff fluid energy-momentum tensor are separately covariantly conserved since no explicit coupling is assumed between stiff fluid and :
For spatially flat isotropic and homogeneous models with the metric
Equations (5) and (7) take the form where the prime denotes differentiation with respect to . Here it is relevant to remark that the use of angular coordinates in metric (13) makes it possible to investigate the horizon problem. The passage to the cosmic synchronous time is fulfilled with the help of the expression
For the stiff fluid we have where is a constant.
From (20) for stiff fluid and the scalar field potential
we obtain where and are integration constants; .
In this paper, we will restrict our discussion to the material scalar field . It follows from (22) that there exist solutions for the following restrictions:
, for all and , . It is not difficult to show that, in terms of physics, reasonable solutions for and do not exist for , for all and , .
3. Exact Solution
The exact general solution to the Einstein-Cartan equations for , can be presented in the form of quadratures: where
An analysis has shown that, depending on the choice of the gravitational field sources, different types of models are possible.
3.1. “Scalar-Torsion Field” + “Stiff Fluid”
Let us consider the models without the scalar field potential . It is convenient to discuss separately the cases and .
From (23), it is possible to express explicitly as where is an integration constant.
For solution (23) describes bouncing models. The minima of the scale factor, are defined from
The asymptotic behavior of , when , is
For solution (23) has the following asymptotics: where .
It should be observed here that we cannot express and in terms of the present values of the cosmographic parameters , and , since three unknown values , , and define the Hubble parameter .
It is easy to see that Hubble's parameter can take large values if . Since the models are considered in the framework of a classical theory of gravity, they will be physically admissible provided , where is the total energy density of the scalar-torsion field and stiff fluid and is the Planck energy density. Consequently, the following restriction on is valid for :
It is interesting to observe that the models (29) are free from the particle horizon; they are nonsingular and admit the late-time accelerating expansion.
For the models with the reverse asymptotics exist:
It follows from (31) that at late times the scalar field disappears with time, and the behavior of the scale factor corresponds to the decelerated expansion.
It is easy to verify that models (29) and (31) are regular due to the violation of the strong energy condition with a scalar-torsion field. It is not difficult to show that, for minima of the scale factor and for the de Sitter-like asymptotics, the contribution of the scalar-torsion field dominates, while for the contribution of the stiff fluid dominates.
As pointed out in [70, 71], since the current torsion is extremely small, only those solutions should be considered as physical solutions towards current epoch, in which torsion disappears with time. In this connection, it should be noted that the square of the trace of torsion has the following asymptotics: (1)stiff fluid dominated era (2)de Sitter regime
It follows from (32) that for the stiff fluid dominated era the torsion disappears with time. The formula (33) shows that for the de Sitter regime the torsion asymptotically tends to a finite value. For the current epoch, provided that , where is the present-day value of the Hubble's parameter, we have the following in natural units (): That is, the current torsion is very small.
For minima of the scale factor the square of the trace of torsion is That is, the torsion is finite.
It must be noted that, for , the solution may be written in a parametric form where , for and for .
For , , solution (23) corresponds to the singular expanding models with de Sitter asymptotics for the late times: while for , this solution conforms to the models with the reverse asymptotics, which describe the collapsing models.
It is easy to verify that for the contribution of the stiff fluid dominates. The behavior of for is described by the formula (33). It is interesting to observe that the square of the trace of torsion has the following asymptotics for : That is, there is the specific value of the coupling constant: .
Thus, for the Big Bang singularity of the form : , , , where is the total pressure of the scalar-torsion field and stiff fluid, the torsion can be singular for , constant for , or tend to zero for . The solutions for the three types of behavior can be presented in a parametric form ():
, where .
, where .
, where .
An analysis has shown that for the solution exists only for and describes nonsingular expanding models with the asymptotics: where , .
It is not difficult to show that for , we have the same qualitative picture of the evolution of models as for .
3.2. “Scalar-Torsion Field” + “)” + “Stiff Fluid”
Let us consider the models for which all sources of gravitational field from the Lagrangian (2) are taken into account.
From (23) we find the expression for , where ; is an integration constant.
An analysis has shown that this solution with , for all and , , and for describes singular expanding models with the de Sitter asymptotic at late times: where . Note that for the reverse asymptotic behavior takes place.
For , , , and , the solution can be expressed in elementary functions: where , .
It should be pointed out that, for , we have the expanding models, while, for , we get the collapsing models.
For , , , and , this solution corresponds to the singular expanding models with the power-law asymptotic at late times:
It is easy to see that the case for conforms to the models with the reverse asymptotics.
It should be observed here that the accelerated expansion of models with the power-law asymptotic at late stages of the cosmological evolution has its origin in “Scalar-torsion field” + “.”
For , the solution can be presented in elementary functions: where . It follows from (47) that for the square of the trace of torsion has the following behavior: .
The analytic solution in elementary functions for , where , corresponds to the following behavior of for : .
The solution in a parametric form for , conforms to the following behavior of for : .
(a), where ,
(b), where .
It is easy to see that for the solution describes the expanding nonsingular models. Here it is relevant to remark that the accelerated expansion both at early stages and at late stages of the cosmological evolution is characteristic for case (b).
It is not difficult to verify that for we get the models with the reverse asymptotics.
For , , and , solution (23) describes bouncing models with the asymptotics where .
The minima of the scale factor, where , are defined from
The asymptotic behavior of , when , is where
The value of for minima of the scale factor is That is, the torsion is finite.
An analysis has shown that with for all only the nonsingular expanding models of types (42) are possible.
In this paper, exact general solution for spatially flat isotropic and homogeneous cosmological models in ECT with stiff fluid and a nonminimally coupled material scalar field with a potential has been obtained and analyzed for an arbitrary positive coupling constant .
In order to elucidate the role of the stiff fluid in the Einstein-Cartan cosmology, we should carry out a comparative analysis of the corresponding cosmological models obtained in this paper and those in  for “Scalar-torsion field” and in  for “Scalar-torsion field” + “.”
By comparing these models, we arrive at the conclusion that for the cosmological models with “Scalar-torsion field” + “Stiff fluid” and “Scalar-torsion field” + “” + “Stiff fluid” the presence of stiff fluid leads to (i)integrability of the Einstein-Cartan equations for , only, (ii) the existence of singular expanding models with the power-law evolution at early times and de Sitter evolution at late times, (iii) the existence of nonsingular (not bouncing) expanding models with de Sitter asymptotic at late times, (iv) the existence of the specific value of the coupling constant : .
Furthermore, for the models with the “Scalar-torsion field” + “Stiff fluid” the presence of stiff fluid leads to the existence of asymmetrically bouncing models with the asymptotics and . These bouncing models are of interest from the viewpoint of modern cosmology: these models are free from the particle horizon, they are nonsingular, they admit the late-time accelerating expansion, and the current torsion for them is very small.
Additionally, stiff fluid in the mixture with the “Scalar-torsion field” + “” results in a decreased number of types of bouncing models and the existence of singular expanding models with the power-law evolution at early times and with the power-law evolution at late times.
It should be observed that the existence of the power-law evolution of the scale factor in the presence of stiff fluid is expected but not necessary. For example, for flat Friedmann universes filled by radiation, stiff fluid, and a nonminimally coupled ghost scalar field with polynomial potentials of the fourth degree , there is not such asymptotic for the scale factor, since the “kinetic term” of the scalar-torsion field compensates for the energy density of stiff fluid.
Comparing the models obtained in this work with the DE models that could admit similar behaviors we note the following. The behavior of the scale factor by the law at late times corresponds to CDM model, while the behavior like at late times conforms to a quintessence model of DE [10, 72].
The author is grateful to the unknown reviewers for the useful remarks.
A. M. Galiakhmetov, “Exact anisotropic scalar field cosmologies in Einstein-Cartan theory,” Gravitation and Cosmology, vol. 13, pp. 217–223, 2007.View at: Google Scholar
É.. Cartan, “Sur les espaces à connexion affine et la théorie de la relativité généralisée, partie I,” Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure, vol. 40, supplement, p. 325, 1923.View at: Google Scholar
E. Cartan, “Sur les varietes à connexion et la theorie de la relativité généralisée (suite),” Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure, vol. 41, supplement, pp. 1–25, 1924.View at: Google Scholar
E. Cartan, “Sur les espaces à connexion affine et la théorie de la relativité généralisée partie II,” Annales Scientifiques de l'École Normale Supérieure, vol. 42, supplement, pp. 17–88, 1925.View at: Google Scholar
F. W. Hehl and Y. N. Obukhov, “Elie Cartan's torsion in geometry and in field theory, an essay,” Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie, vol. 32, p. 157, 2007.View at: Google Scholar
V. N. Ponomarev, A. O. Barvinsky, and N. Yu. Obuhov, Geometrodynamics Methods and Gauge Approach in the Theory of Gravity, Energoatomizdat, Moscow, Russia, 1985.
A. Trautman, “Einstein-Cartan theory,” in Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics, J. P. Françoise, G.-L. Naber, and S. T. Tsou, Eds., pp. 189–195, Elsevier, Oxford, UK, 2006.View at: Google Scholar
J. Tafel, “Cosmological models with a spinor field,” Bulletin de L'Académie Polonaise des Sciences, Série des Sciences Mathématiques, Astronomiques et Physiques, vol. 25, p. 593, 1977.View at: Google Scholar
M. Gasperini, “Repulsive gravity in the very early Universe,” General Relativity and Gravitation, vol. 30, pp. 1703–1709, 1998.View at: Google Scholar
H. Rumph, “Particle creation by torsion and electromagnetic fields,” General Relativity and Gravitation, vol. 10, p. 456, 1979.View at: Google Scholar
D. D. Ivanenko, P. I. Pronin, and G. A. Sardanashvili, Gauge Theory of Gravity, Moscow State University Press, Moscow, Russia, 1985.
V. Krechet, Problems of gravitational interaction of the phisical fields in an affine connected spaces [PhD thesis], Yaroslavl State Pedagogical University, 1984.
M. W. Kalinowski, “On a generalization of the Einstein-Cartan theory and the Kaluza-Klein theory,” Letters in Mathematical Physics, vol. 5, p. 489, 1958.View at: Google Scholar
S. Yu. Vladimirov and A. D. Popov, “Compound torsion and spontaneous compactification in Kaluza-Klein theories,” Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta, Fizika, Astronomiya, vol. 29, no. 4, pp. 28–32, 1988.View at: Google Scholar
E. V. Linder, “Einstein’s other gravity and the acceleration of the Universe,” Physical Review D, vol. 81, no. 12, Article ID 127301, 2010.View at: Google Scholar
K. P. Staniukovich and V. N. Melnikov, Hydrodynamics, Fields and Constants in Gravitation Theory, Energoatomizdat, Moscow, Russia, 1983.
A. de la Maccora, “Realistic particle physics dark energy model,” Physical Review D, vol. 72, no. 4, Article ID 043508, 7 pages, 2005.View at: Google Scholar
A. Linde, Particle Physics and Inflationary Cosmology, Gordon and Breach, New York, NY, USA, 1990.
G. Felder, A. Frolov, L. Kofman, and A. Linde, “Cosmology with negative potentials,” Physical Review D, vol. 66, no. 2, Article ID 023507, 26 pages, 2002.View at: Google Scholar
V. G. Krechet and D. V. Sadovnikov, “Cosmology in an affine-metric theory of gravity with a scalar field,” Gravitation and Cosmology, vol. 3, pp. 133–1140, 1997.View at: Google Scholar
M. Yu. Khlopov and A. S. Sakharov, “Cosmoparticle physics: as a probe for the theory of physical space-time,” Gravitation and Cosmology, vol. 1, pp. 164–176, 1995.View at: Google Scholar
I. L. Buchbinder, S. D. Odintsov, and I. L. Shapiro, Effective Action in Quantum Gravity, IOP, Bristol, UK, 1992.
I. L. Buchbinder, S. D. Odintsov, and I. L. Shapiro, “Nonsingular cosmological model with torsion induced by vacuum quantum effects,” Physics Letters B, vol. 162, no. 1–3, pp. 92–96, 1985.View at: Google Scholar
I. L. Buchbinder and S. D. Odintsov, “Effective action in the de Sitter space with torsion,” Acta Physica Polonica B, vol. 18, pp. 237–242, 1987.View at: Google Scholar