Machine Learning-Based Parameter Tuned Genetic Algorithm for Energy Minimizing Vehicle Routing Problem

Table 3

Detailed results of the GA.

CVRPLib file name	Rate of mutation
	0.0010	0.0025	0.0050	0.0075	0.0100
X-n1001-k43.vrp	12.80103	11.88827	10.85936	9.694029	9.556848
X-n101-k25.vrp	32.02678	35.75923	37.56841	40.00939	35.55532
X-n106-k14.vrp	30.27717	33.81137	34.26686	35.76881	33.72598
X-n110-k13.vrp	33.95242	40.20993	42.49106	39.00524	36.37393
X-n115-k10.vrp	50.81193	52.37917	55.09787	54.92929	53.33978
X-n120-k6.vrp	42.11564	45.09899	43.3998	44.35186	42.59954
X-n125-k30.vrp	26.52183	29.63255	31.01679	27.39243	27.4007
X-n129-k18.vrp	31.66396	33.715	34.8625	32.79096	32.22348
X-n134-k13.vrp	37.75922	42.5249	42.52067	42.57679	40.28671
X-n139-k10.vrp	37.36237	38.82001	38.74307	36.62869	35.8474
X-n143-k7.vrp	37.54207	43.38776	41.28395	37.84237	37.53593
X-n148-k46.vrp	31.93441	33.53385	34.04095	32.45357	30.09326
X-n153-k22.vrp	49.45064	49.81333	54.32997	52.78865	45.06589
X-n157-k13.vrp	42.86481	46.98111	45.72171	42.56459	42.47363
X-n162-k11.vrp	34.27922	38.17874	38.77056	37.83853	35.89787
X-n167-k10.vrp	31.62204	35.85662	37.1133	33.45995	32.22809
X-n172-k51.vrp	28.99557	34.80488	36.56064	29.37898	27.77682
X-n176-k26.vrp	39.44419	41.23805	40.69566	39.15282	36.88177
X-n181-k23.vrp	30.22022	33.84771	32.57614	30.78921	27.88417
X-n186-k15.vrp	34.75806	35.94411	33.87898	29.67616	30.61732
X-n190-k8.vrp	34.53248	36.59408	36.81079	36.82402	32.81114
X-n195-k51.vrp	31.78228	32.85653	29.30497	26.42445	22.69677
X-n200-k36.vrp	27.0885	28.60889	25.96263	24.49728	23.69031
X-n204-k19.vrp	31.70243	33.92431	30.44077	31.17991	27.19798
X-n209-k16.vrp	31.60467	32.05206	29.85411	27.84361	24.32678
X-n214-k11.vrp	32.55193	35.04465	33.91079	29.86931	64.77444
X-n219-k73.vrp	20.10571	22.6770	20.8841	19.1462	17.90529
X-n223-k34.vrp	30.40860	30.14028	29.89211	25.98539	20.03798
X-n228-k23.vrp	45.04471	45.64562	45.38162	40.09223	35.30641
X-n233-k16.vrp	31.90803	33.2655	33.22402	25.19938	25.45072
X-n237-k14.vrp	32.55161	32.68141	31.20284	30.6823	28.61488
X-n242-k48.vrp	23.91807	26.61617	20.90652	19.31902	14.68955
X-n247-k47.vrp	35.5378	38.53135	36.33797	30.11682	29.20752
X-n251-k28.vrp	30.01463	28.47438	24.65875	24.20706	22.11476
X-n256-k16.vrp	33.25466	34.19156	34.25381	28.92623	25.92442
X-n261-k13.vrp	29.70967	30.71204	28.49667	24.99286	23.82931
X-n266-k58.vrp	23.88774	26.97132	22.6137	17.39035	16.23727
X-n270-k35.vrp	27.88478	28.69578	24.80018	22.34739	20.61391
X-n275-k28.vrp	31.94181	32.22524	31.55025	29.16687	26.01753
X-n280-k17.vrp	36.40002	40.28805	37.492	31.2107	32.18607
X-n284-k15.vrp	29.24362	29.22297	25.84051	24.31867	22.31105
X-n289-k60.vrp	26.03244	24.4524	21.37549	17.71002	16.30786
X-n294-k50.vrp	27.29334	26.12614	22.5941	18.20006	16.88417
X-n298-k31.vrp	27.38218	25.41562	22.39082	18.86125	19.93721
X-n303-k21.vrp	27.91977	31.20337	25.23259	24.35885	20.68154
X-n308-k13.vrp	33.39066	36.73234	35.50009	32.08833	31.20307
X-n313-k71.vrp	24.28404	23.18796	19.81391	18.23606	16.86009
X-n317-k53.vrp	32.08766	31.86606	28.42572	25.00814	25.18776
X-n322-k28.vrp	25.12437	27.05396	23.15435	21.11874	17.37640
X-n327-k20.vrp	26.26653	26.12335	22.98445	21.70285	20.14563
X-n331-k15.vrp	29.44784	28.36366	27.57544	25.02837	22.02214
X-n336-k84.vrp	22.6318	22.90019	18.02802	16.15295	14.52159
X-n344-k43.vrp	24.32391	25.13196	22.02908	21.00029	17.65428
X-n351-k40.vrp	27.68809	26.01819	23.83853	22.73273	18.48367
X-n359-k29.vrp	21.84092	21.23801	17.35729	15.69808	13.77700
X-n367-k17.vrp	38.19213	33.30166	31.86441	27.12176	24.79421
X-n376-k94.vrp	20.09361	20.08725	17.43900	14.55602	15.48883
X-n384-k52.vrp	23.58085	23.29087	18.4361	17.41201	14.50117
X-n393-k38.vrp	25.30698	22.72104	19.75677	17.32702	16.88916
X-n401-k29.vrp	23.39231	21.57439	18.24951	18.13344	16.87411
X-n411-k19.vrp	39.58560	37.58242	31.96097	28.89972	25.96533
X-n420-k130.vrp	22.02357	21.37115	17.82149	15.26686	13.76679
X-n429-k61.vrp	22.76805	19.75252	15.07036	12.97871	14.51224
X-n439-k37.vrp	23.90484	25.4478	22.03636	19.64785	19.02882
X-n449-k29.vrp	22.58562	18.94513	16.51374	14.83471	13.86315
X-n459-k26.vrp	25.01886	25.35202	21.53826	19.56277	19.13728
X-n469-k138.vrp	15.98851	14.69173	13.00686	10.68891	10.80067
X-n480-k70.vrp	20.17462	18.28826	13.21342	13.50108	12.19322
X-n491-k59.vrp	22.35715	17.40456	16.12807	13.92029	12.32098
X-n502-k39.vrp	29.43752	28.93300	25.58213	23.71366	22.40697
X-n513-k21.vrp	20.66056	22.19829	17.66711	17.38231	15.59318
X-n524-k137.vrp	29.25552	25.00689	21.94620	18.42015	16.28576
X-n536-k96.vrp	22.00046	21.26785	15.21787	14.84602	13.92225
X-n548-k50.vrp	20.21664	19.10249	16.73358	17.28269	15.87240
X-n561-k42.vrp	19.32241	17.75355	14.06087	12.41879	12.15678
X-n573-k30.vrp	24.01248	23.39799	19.72642	18.85806	16.65078
X-n586-k159.vrp	17.84853	14.28692	13.70556	10.91328	10.95873
X-n599-k92.vrp	17.81388	15.09005	12.12366	11.29734	10.65991
X-n613-k62.vrp	19.58326	15.61245	13.32296	11.98591	11.20262
X-n627-k43.vrp	21.24216	18.5817	15.72306	13.56177	15.04474
X-n641-k35.vrp	17.08436	16.39485	13.36082	13.64283	11.30660
X-n655-k131.vrp	15.48288	14.88927	12.54741	12.25737	11.85345
X-n670-k126.vrp	28.71788	26.85190	20.31016	19.55446	17.42389
X-n685-k75.vrp	18.45748	15.06038	12.07450	10.94300	11.51439
X-n701-k44.vrp	16.57985	12.76328	11.40417	9.379679	8.427837
X-n716-k35.vrp	20.86056	19.27732	16.90755	14.85372	15.44707
X-n733-k159.vrp	17.96192	15.17854	12.20108	10.38958	8.888177
X-n749-k98.vrp	15.74652	14.80900	10.89733	11.00262	9.564129
X-n766-k71.vrp	27.54911	24.8529	19.96212	16.19431	13.99631
X-n783-k48.vrp	16.50255	11.88705	10.22504	12.07379	10.41174
X-n801-k40.vrp	17.87667	16.77141	14.99016	13.30332	13.53483
X-n819-k171.vrp	14.42093	13.74995	11.63282	11.58539	11.08715
X-n837-k142.vrp	13.10938	10.77977	9.634830	7.912295	9.019517
X-n856-k95.vrp	16.6359	15.19706	13.46041	13.24301	12.79089
X-n876-k59.vrp	16.99766	12.49846	13.28471	10.75942	11.86574
X-n895-k37.vrp	15.00296	14.3762	13.11793	11.61722	10.35098
X-n916-k207.vrp	11.61902	10.47219	8.532556	7.726192	7.366569
X-n936-k151.vrp	25.03095	24.13244	17.19300	14.26762	14.49740
X-n957-k87.vrp	14.77510	14.11095	12.44374	12.33696	11.75502
X-n979-k58.vrp	14.69893	12.25920	11.47749	9.918681	9.964106