Journal of Materials / 2014 / Article / Tab 1

Review Article

A Reconciliation of Packed Column Permeability Data: Deconvoluting the Ergun Papers

Table 1


Column numberAAAAAAABBBBBBBCCCCCCC

Reported
cm14.0514.0514.0514.0514.0514.0514.0523.5623.5623.5623.5623.5623.5623.568.468.468.468.468.468.468.46
g500500500500500500500200200200200200200200300300300300300300300
g−1cm2111111111111114242424242424210101010101010
gcm−310.810.810.810.810.810.810.82.52.52.52.52.52.52.510.810.810.810.810.810.810.8

gcm−37.0257.0257.0257.0257.0257.0257.0251.6761.6761.6761.6761.6761.6761.6766.9996.9996.9996.9996.9996.9996.999

none0.3500.3500.3500.3500.3500.3500.3500.3300.3300.3300.3300.3300.3300.3300.3520.3520.3520.3520.3520.3520.352

cm0.0500.0500.0500.0500.0500.0500.0500.0570.0570.0570.0570.0570.0570.0570.0560.0560.0560.0560.0560.0560.056
C0005111522280310182738490025811

Sutherland
gcm−1sec−11.66E − 041.66E − 041.66E − 04
cm3sec−1550100160200250300550100150200250300550100150200250300
gsec−1cm−20.0020.012 0.025 0.040 0.049 0.062 0.074 0.0020.012 0.025 0.037 0.049 0.062 0.074 0.0020.012 0.025 0.037 0.049 0.062 0.074
cmsec−11.009.8619.7331.6339.4549.3259.181.009.8619.7329.5939.4549.3259.181.009.8619.7329.5939.4549.3259.18
gcm−1sec−21,35914,35130,80553,46770,02292,784117,6502,14022,85249,57680,172114,640152,981195,1945816,22313,54821,97431,50342,13453,867
gsec−1cm−397104 111 120 126 134 142 9198 107 115 123 132 140 6975 81 88 94 101 108
none1.005.6911.4218.4023.0328.9234.861.006.3412.7619.2725.8732.5739.361.006.4412.9019.39025.932.4639.05
g/cm−32.17E − 031.95E − 031.91E − 03

g/cm−32.17E − 031.95E − 031.91E − 03

g/cm−3

g−1cm5233840574057405740574057405726034057405740564056405540542652405740574057405740574057

none145145145146146147148141141142143144145146134134135135135135136

none1.162.012.012.012.012.012.011.322.062.062.062.062.062.061.322.032.032.032.032.032.03


none2.02.02.02.02.02.02.12.02.02.02.02.02.02.01.91.91.91.91.91.91.9


none1.52.72.72.72.72.72.71.82.82.72.72.72.72.71.82.72.72.72.72.72.7
g2cm−60.800.310.90
none0.350.350.350.350.350.350.350.330.330.330.330.330.330.330.350.350.350.350.350.350.35

none0.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0

none515151515151524747474748484847474747484848


none146156168183193205218142154169183197212227136147161174188201215

Corrected
cm15.3415.3415.3415.3415.3415.3415.3425.6825.6825.6825.6825.6825.6825.689.359.359.359.359.359.359.35
g500500500500500500500200200200200200200200300300300300300300300
g−1cm2111111111111114242424242424210101010101010
gcm−310.810.810.810.810.810.810.82.52.52.52.52.52.52.510.810.810.810.810.810.810.8

gcm−36.4316.4316.4316.4316.4316.4316.4311.5371.5371.5371.5371.5371.5371.5376.3316.3316.3316.3316.3316.3316.331

none0.4040.4040.4040.4040.4040.4040.4040.3850.3850.3850.3850.3850.3850.3850.4140.4140.4140.4140.4140.4140.414

cm0.0500.0500.0500.0500.0500.0500.0500.0570.0570.0570.0570.0570.0570.0570.0560.0560.0560.0560.0560.0560.056
C0000000000000000000000

Sutherland
gcm−1sec−11.66E − 041.66E − 041.66E − 04
cm3sec−1546921471832292755469213818422927654590136181226272
gsec−1cm−20.0020.011 0.023 0.038 0.048 0.061 0.075 0.0020.011 0.023 0.036 0.050 0.064 0.080 0.0020.011 0.022 0.034 0.045 0.057 0.070
cmsec−11.009.0318.0628.9636.1345.1754.211.009.0518.0927.1536.2145.1454.351.008.9217.8426.7735.7044.6453.6
gcm−1sec−21,48414,25930,44852,55768,61490,597114,5222,33322,68648,92578,746112,132148,538189,7256426,16613,33121,49930,67340,84952,055
gsec−1cm−397103 110 118 124 131 138 9198 105 113 121 128 136 6974 80 86 92 98 104
none1.005.6911.5618.9423.9830.6037.531.006.3913.1120.2227.8135.8044.661.006.4012.9019.5126.2533.1540.23
g/cm−31.99E − 031.79E − 031.73E − 03

g/cm−31.99E − 031.79E − 031.73E − 03

g/cm−3

g−1cm5255340523988390438453768368728384018391838093695357834542932408440554023398739483906

none267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267267

none2.143.403.343.273.223.163.092.513.553.463.363.263.163.052.633.663.643.613.583.543.50


none3.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.73.7


none2.94.54.54.44.34.24.13.34.74.64.54.44.24.13.54.94.84.84.84.74.7
g2cm−60.760.300.84
none0.400.400.400.400.400.400.400.390.390.390.390.390.390.390.410.410.410.410.410.410.41

none0.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.00.0

none108108108108108108108103103103103103103103110110110110110110110


none269286306329344364383270290312335358380403270290314337361384408