Journal of Mathematics / 2023 / Article / Tab 9 / Research Article
A New Conformable Fractional-Order Time-Delay Grey Bernoulli Model with the Arithmetic Optimization Algorithm and Its Application in Rural Regional Economy Table 9 The APE (%) of ten models in the case of the rural residents’ consumption level.
Year Data CFTDNGBM FDGM FNDGM FDGMP FDGM (1, 1, t α ) FGDGMP WDGM FTDGM LSSVM CFDGM (1, 1) 2002 2157.00 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 — 0.0000 2003 2292.00 0.1565 2.1977 0.0429 0.2762 0.0000 0.1742 3.4295 0.0072 — 8.2182 2004 2521.00 0.5770 2.2560 0.6182 0.1334 0.0021 0.1048 1.4957 1.1816 2.1115 4.8482 2005 2784.00 0.0097 1.3041 0.3309 0.0362 0.1672 0.1499 0.2503 0.0565 0.8273 2.0857 2006 3066.00 0.4498 0.6178 0.9874 1.0370 1.2046 0.8249 2.4693 1.4940 1.6371 0.8440 2007 3538.00 2.6829 1.7214 1.8263 1.9858 1.8618 2.1156 0.1000 1.2557 2.2765 0.9958 2008 3981.00 2.4331 1.3137 1.7237 2.0194 1.9055 2.0101 0.4101 1.3299 1.0541 0.4018 2009 4295.00 2.6555 3.5212 2.9430 2.5829 2.7130 2.7246 5.1667 3.0585 4.9064 4.4362 2010 4782.00 5.0069 5.3473 4.7742 4.4558 4.5911 4.6699 6.8427 4.5558 3.8395 6.0658 2011 5880.00 2.6626 2.8471 3.2196 3.3780 3.2935 3.2022 1.6254 3.6680 7.0002 2.4963 2012 6573.00 0.8611 1.3865 1.4745 1.4085 1.4457 1.3543 0.2869 2.0183 1.5995 1.4355 2013 7397.00 0.0554 0.5254 0.2005 0.1812 0.1007 0.0006 0.4676 0.5674 1.4126 1.0515 2014 8365.00 0.1553 0.1095 0.7420 1.5246 0.8410 0.9942 0.7991 0.9505 0.1670 1.1695 2015 9409.00 0.4076 0.8763 2.3670 3.6397 2.3588 2.6388 1.7335 3.7035 0.3651 0.7729 2016 10609.00 0.0030 1.6470 3.8764 5.7206 3.6223 4.1322 2.4786 7.0837 1.7253 0.6308 2017 12145.00 2.3140 0.8981 3.9151 6.3749 3.2603 4.1161 1.7187 9.8920 5.1769 2.0004 2018 13985.00 5.5321 0.4161 3.4289 6.5449 2.2111 3.5411 0.4141 13.3098 9.0740 3.9261 2019 15382.00 4.7495 2.9102 7.8491 11.8467 5.8069 7.8421 3.8130 23.8467 9.2864 1.4045 2020 16046.00 0.8617 12.1405 18.6433 23.9165 15.3447 18.4668 13.1973 44.8144 7.6374 6.6758