Table of Contents
Journal of Thermodynamics
Volume 2016 (2016), Article ID 9137926, 13 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2016/9137926
Review Article

Historical Prospective: Boltzmann’s versus Planck’s State Counting—Why Boltzmann Did Not Arrive at Planck’s Distribution Law

1Technical University of Applied Sciences Wildau, Hochschulring 1, 15745 Wildau, Germany
2Kazakh National Pedagogical Abai University, Dostyk avenue 13, Almaty 050010, Kazakhstan

Received 7 August 2015; Accepted 11 November 2015

Academic Editor: Shripad T. Revankar

Copyright © 2016 Peter Enders. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Linked References

  1. L. Boltzmann, “Über die Beziehung zwischen dem zweiten Hauptsatze der Mechanischen Wärmetheorie und der Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung, respective den Sätzen über das Wärmegleichgewicht,” Wiener Berichte, vol. 76, pp. 373–435, 1877, Reprint in: Wiss. Abhandlungen, vol. 2, Leipzig: Barth, #42, F. Hasenöhrl, ed., pp. 164–223, 1909. View at Google Scholar
  2. K. Sharp and F. Matschinsky, “Translation of Ludwig Boltzmann's paper ‘on the relationship between the second fundamental theorem of the mechanical theory of heat and probability calculations regarding the conditions for thermal equilibrium’,” Entropy, vol. 17, no. 4, pp. 1971–2009, 2015. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  3. L. Boltzmann, “Ableitung des Stefanschen Gesetzes, betreffend die Abhängigkeit der Wärmestrahlung von der Temperatur aus der elektromagnetischen Lichttheorie,” Wiedemanns Annalen, vol. 22, pp. 291–294, 1884. View at Google Scholar
  4. M. Planck, Vorlesungen Über die Theorie der Wärmestrahlung, Vierter Abschnitt. Entropie und Wahrscheinlichkeit, Barth, Leipzig, Germany, 1906; English: The Theory of Heat Radiation (Authorized Translation of the 2nd ed. 1913 by M. Mortius), Blakiston, Philadelphia, Pa, USA, 1914, Dover, New York, NY, USA, 1959, Part III. Entropy and Probability, 1991, https://archive.org/details/vorlesungenberd04plangoog, https://archive.org/details/theoryofheatradi00planrich.
  5. A. Münster, Statistical Thermodynamics, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1969.
  6. P. Ehrenfest and V. Trkal, “Deduction of the dissociation-equilibrium from the theory of quanta and a calculation of the chemical constant based on this,” Annals of Physics, vol. 65, pp. 609–628, 1921. View at Google Scholar
  7. N. G. Van Kampen, “The gibbs paradox,” in Essays in Theoretical Physics in Honour of Dirk ter Haar, W. E. Parry, Ed., pp. 303–312, Pergamon Press, Oxford, UK, 1984. View at Google Scholar
  8. E. Jaynes, “The Gibbs paradox,” in Maximum Entropy and Bayesian Methods, C. Smith, G. Erickson, and P. Neudorfer, Eds., pp. 1–22, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1992, http://bayes.wustl.edu/etj/articles/gibbs.paradox.pdf. View at Google Scholar
  9. R. H. Swendsen, “Statistical mechanics of colloids and Boltzmann's definition of the entropy,” American Journal of Physics, vol. 74, no. 3, pp. 187–190, 2006. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Zentralblatt MATH · View at MathSciNet · View at Scopus
  10. W. Pauli, Statistical Mechanics, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass, USA, 1973, reprint: vol. 4 of Pauli Lectures on Physics, Dover, New York, NY, USA, 2000.
  11. G. Gallavotti, Statistical Mechanics: A Short Treatise, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1999. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at MathSciNet
  12. J. W. Gibbs, “On the equilibrium of heterogeneous substances,” Transactions of the Connecticut Academy of Arts and Sciences, vol. 3, pp. 108–245, 1875/76, pp. 343–524, 1877/78; The Scientific Papers of J. Willard Gibbs, vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 55–353, 1961, https://archive.org/details/scientificpapers01gibbuoft. View at Google Scholar
  13. J. W. Gibbs, Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics Developed with Especial Reference to the Rational Foundation of Thermodynamics, Scribner, Yale Bicentennial, New York, NY, USA, 1902, https://archive.org/details/elementaryprinci00gibbrich.
  14. M. Planck, Zur Theorie des Gesetzes der Energieverteilung im Normalspektrum, vol. 2 of Verhandlungen der Deutschen Physikalischen Gesellschaft, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1900, Reprint in: Planck, Die Ableitung der Strahlungsgesetze, no. V, 1997; English in: D. ter Haar, The Old Quantum Theory, no. 2, 1967.
  15. M. Planck, “Über das Gesetz der Energieverteilung im Normalspectrum,” Annalen der Physik, vol. 4, pp. 553–563, 1901, reprint in: M. Planck, Die Ableitung der Strahlungsgesetze, No. VI, 1997; English: “On the law of distribution of energy in the normal spectrum”, http://strangepaths.com/files/planck1901.pdf. View at Google Scholar
  16. A. Einstein, “Die Plancksche Theorie der Strahlung und die Theorie der spezifischen Wärme,” Annalen der Physik, vol. 222, pp. 180–800, 1907, Reprint in: Einstein's Annalen Papers, J. Renn, ed., pp. 280–291 resp. 296, 2005, http://www.physik.uni-augsburg.de/annalen/history/einstein-papers/1907_22_800.pdf, http://www.physik.uni-augsburg.de/annalen/history/einstein-papers/1907_22_180-190.pdf. View at Google Scholar
  17. A. Bach, Indistinguishable Classical Particles, vol. 44 of Lecture Notes in Physics, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1997.
  18. L. Boltzmann, “Studien über das Gleichgewicht der lebendigen Kraft zwischen bewegten materiellen Punkten,” Wiener Berichte, vol. 58, pp. 517–560, 1868, reprint in: Wissenschaftliche Abhandlungen, F. Hasenöhrl, Ed., vol. 1, Barth, Leipzig, Germany, pp. 49–96, 1909. View at Google Scholar
  19. M. Planck, “Entropie und Temperatur strahlender Wärme,” Annalen der Physik, vol. 1, pp. 719–737, 1900. View at Google Scholar
  20. M. Planck, Über eine Verbesserung der Wienschen Spektralgleichung, vol. 2 of Verhandlungen der Deutschen Physikalischen Gesellschaft, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1900, Reprint in: Planck, Die Ableitung der Strahlungsgesetze, no. IV, 1997; English in: D. ter Haar, The Old Quantum Theory, no. 1, 1967.
  21. M. Thiesen, Ueber das Gesetz der Schwarzen Strahlung, VDPG 2, 1900.
  22. O. Lummer and E. Jahnke, “Ueber die Spectralgleichung des schwarzen Körpers und des blanken Platins,” Annalen der Physik, vol. 308, no. 10, pp. 283–297, 1900. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  23. O. Lummer and E. Pringsheim, “Ueber die Strahlung des schwarzen Körpers für lange Wellen,” Verhandlungen der Deutschen Physikalische Gesellschaft, vol. 2, no. 12, pp. 163–180, 1900. View at Google Scholar
  24. H. Rubens and F. Kurlbaum, Anwendung der Methode der Reststrahlen zur Prüfung des Strahlungsgesetzes, vol. 41 of Sitzungsberichte der Kaiserlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1900, Annalen der Physik, vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 649–666, 1901, http://www.ing-buero-ebel.de/strahlung/Original/RubKur1901.pdf.
  25. M. Badino, The Bumpy Road: Max Planck from Radiation Theory to the Quantum (1896–1906), Springer Briefs in History of Science and Technology, Springer, 2015.
  26. W. Pauli, “Quantentheorie,” in Handbuch der Physik, H. Geiger and K. Scheel, Eds., vol. 23, pp. 1–278, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1926, reprint in: Handbuch der Physik, S. Flügge, Ed., vol. V/1, p. 136ff, Springer, Berlin, Germany, 1958. View at Google Scholar
  27. A. Messiah, Quantum Mechanics, 2 Volumes, Wiley, New York, NY, USA, 1958, reprint: Dover, New York, NY, USA, 1 Volume, 1999.
  28. N. Bohr, “I. On the constitution of atoms and molecules,” Philosophical Magazine, vol. 26, no. 151, pp. 1–25, 1913. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  29. A. Sommerfeld, “Zur Quantentheorie der Spektrallinien,” Annalen der Physik, vol. 356, no. 18, pp. 1–94, 125–167, 1916. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  30. W. Wilson, “LXXXIII. The quantum-theory of radiation and line spectra,” Philosophical Magazine Series 6, vol. 29, no. 174, pp. 795–802, 1915. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  31. L. De Broglie, Recherches sur la théorie des quanta [Thésis] [M.S. thesis], University of Paris, Paris, France, 1924, Annales de Physique 10, vol. 3, pp. 22–128, 1925, reprint: Annales de la Fondation Louis de Broglie, vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 1–109, 1992, https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00006807.
  32. W. Heisenberg, “Über quantentheoretische Umdeutung kinematischer und mechanischer Beziehungen,” Zeitschrift für Physik, vol. 33, pp. 879–893, 1925, English: Quantum-Theoretical Re-Interpretation of Kinematic and Mechanical Relations, in Sources of Quantum Mechanics, paper 12, van der Waerden, ed., pp. 261–276, 1968. View at Google Scholar
  33. E. Schrödinger, “Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem. Zweite Mitteilung,” Annalen der Physik, vol. 384, no. 6, pp. 489–527, 1926. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  34. P. Enders and D. Suisky, “Quantization as selection problem,” International Journal of Theoretical Physics, vol. 44, no. 2, pp. 161–194, 2005. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at Scopus
  35. P. Enders, “Quantization as selection rather than eigenvalue problem,” in Advances in Quantum Mechanics, P. Bracken, Ed., chapter 23, pp. 543–564, InTech, Rijeka, Croatia, 2013, http://cdn.intechopen.com/pdfs/41542/InTech-Quantization_as_selection_rather_than_eigenvalue_problem.pdf. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  36. P. Enders, “Equality and identity and (In)distinguishability in classical and quantum mechanics from the point of view of Newton's notion of state,” in Frontiers of Fundamental Physics: Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium ‘Frontiers of Fundamental and Computational Physics’, Udine, Italy, 26–29 September 2004, B. G. Sidharth, F. Honsell, and A. De Angelis, Eds., pp. 239–245, Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2006. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar
  37. P. Enders, “Is classical statistical mechanics self-consistent? (A paper of honour of C. F. von Weizsäcker, 1912–2007),” Progress in Physics, vol. 3, pp. 85–87, 2007. View at Google Scholar
  38. P. Enders, “Equality and identity and (In)distinguishability in classical and quantum mechanics from the point of view of Newton's Notion of State,” ICFAI University Journal of Physics, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 71–78, 2008, http://www.iupindia.org/108/IJP_Classical_and_Quantum_Mechanics_71.html. View at Google Scholar
  39. P. Enders, “Gibbs' paradox in the light of Newton's notion of state,” Entropy, vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 454–456, 2009. View at Publisher · View at Google Scholar · View at MathSciNet · View at Scopus
  40. P. Enders, “State, statistics and quantization in Einstein's 1907 paper,‘Planck's theory of radiation and the theory of specific heat of solids’,” ICFAI University Journal of Physics II, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 176–195, 2009, http://www.iupindia.org/709/IJP_Einsteins_1907_Paper_176.html. View at Google Scholar
  41. P. Enders, “Are there physical systems obeying the Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics?” Apeiron, vol. 16, no. 4, pp. 542–554, 2009, http://redshift.vif.com/JournalFiles/V16NO4PDF/V16N4END.pdf. View at Google Scholar
  42. P. Enders, “Bose-Einstein versus Maxwell-Boltzmann distributions,” Apeiron, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 15–17, 2011, http://redshift.vif.com/JournalFiles/V18NO1PDF/V18N1EN1.pdf. View at Google Scholar
  43. A. Sommerfeld, Vorlesungen über Theoretische Physik, vol. 1, Harri Deutsch, Frankfurt, Germany, 8th edition, 1994.
  44. H. V. Helmholtz, Einleitung zu den Vorlesungen über theoretische Physik, vol. I/1, Barth, Leipzig, Germany, 1903, edited by: A. König, C. Runge, Reprint of: pp. 1–50, in: Rompe & Treder, Zur Grundlegung der Theoretischen Physik, pp. 11–62, 1984.
  45. W. Feller, An Introduction to Probability Theory and Its Applications, vol. 1, Wiley, New York, NY, USA, 3rd edition, 1968.
  46. S. G. Brush, Kinetic Theory, vol. 2, Pergamon, Oxford, UK, 1966, (Selected Readings in Physics).
  47. I. S. Alekseyeva, “O svyazi mezhdu vtorym nachalom mekhanicheskoi’ teorii teploty i teoriyei’ veroyatnostyei’ v teoremakh o teplovom ravnovesii,” in Lyudvig Bol'tsman, Izbrannyye Trudy, L. S. Polak, Ed., pp. 190–235, Nauka, Moscow, Russia, 1984 (Russian).
  48. D. ter Haar, The Old Quantum Theory, Pergamon Press, Oxford, UK, 1967, (Selected Readings in Physics).
  49. M. Planck, Selected Works, Science Classics, Nauka, Moscow, Russia, Edited by L. S. Polak, 1975 (Russian).
  50. A. Einstein, “Über einen die Erzeugung und Verwandlung des Lichtes betreffenden heuristischen Gesichtspunkt,” Annals of Physics, vol. 17, pp. 132–148, 1905, Reprint in: Einstein's Annalen Papers, J. Renn, Ed., pp. 164–181, 2005, English: On a Heuristic Point of View about the Creation and Conversion of Light, The Old Quantum Theory, D. ter Haar, pp. 91–107, 1967, http://users.physik.fu-berlin.de/~kleinert/files/eins_lq.pdf, http://www.strangepaths.com/files/1905.pdf. View at Google Scholar
  51. M. Planck, Die Ableitung der Strahlungsgesetze. Sieben Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der elektromagnetischen Strahlungstheorie, vol. 206 of Ostwalds Klassiker, Geest & Portig, Leipzig, Germany; Deutsch, Frankfurt, Germany, 2001.
  52. C. Truesdell, Essays in the History of Mechanics, Springer, New York, NY, USA, 1968. View at MathSciNet
  53. K. Simonyi, Kulturgeschichte der Physik, Urania, Leipzig, Germany, 1990.