Research Article | Open Access
Selective Excitations of Transverse Vibrational Modes of a Carbon Nanotube through a “Shuttle-Like” Electromechanical Instability
We study the dynamics of transverse oscillations of a suspended carbon nanotube into which electron current is injected from the tip of a scanning tunneling microscope (STM). In this case the correlations between the displacement of the nanotube and its charge state, determined by the position-dependent electron tunneling rate, can lead to a “shuttle-like” instability for the transverse vibrational modes. We find that selective excitation of a specific mode can be achieved by an accurate positioning of the STM tip. This result suggests a feasible way to control the dynamics of this nano-electromechanical system (NEMS) based on the “shuttle instability.”
There are several reasons for the considerable current interest in nano-electromechanical systems (NEMSs), both for technological applications and fundamental research. The peculiar combination of several features such as high vibrational frequencies and small masses which characterize most NEMS makes these systems very suitable for the realization of new measurement tools with extremely high sensitivity in mass sensing and force microscopy applications [1, 2]. Furthermore, the mechanical elements of the NEMS (typically cantilevers or beams) are considered the most promising structures where quantum features of motion could be experimentally detected .
The physical basis for many of the interesting functionalities of NEMS is the strong interplay between mechanical and electronic degrees of freedom [4–8]. In the particular case of a nano-electromechanical single-electron transistor device having a metallic dot as movable part, the equilibrium position of the dot can become unstable as a consequence of the electromechanical coupling. In this case the dominant mechanism for the transport of charge is based on the oscillations of the dot which can “shuttle” the tunneling electrons across the system [9, 10].
The typical setup for many NEMS includes a spatially extended movable element such as a suspended carbon nanotube, whose dynamics has been demonstrated to be characterized by a number of different vibrational modes . The relevance of many mechanical modes in the transport of charge suggests that the variety of effects due to the electromechanical coupling in suspended carbon nanotube-based NEMS may be even richer than in the ordinary “shuttle” system. Jonsson et al. have shown [12–14] that if extra charge is injected into the movable part of the device from the tip of a scanning tunneling microscope (STM) a nano-electromechanical “shuttle-like” instability can be induced for the transverse vibrational modes of the nanotube.
The selective promotion of the electromechanical instability for different vibrational modes provides an interesting perspective for probing the dynamics of NEMS. Here we show that such selective excitation can be achieved by means of local injection of electric charge. The main idea is to optimize the electromechanical coupling for the mode(s) which we want to make unstable. The local character of the electric charge injection makes the selective excitation of the nanotube transverse modes possible by varying the position of the STM tip.
We will consider here the same device analyzed by Jonsson et al. since it provides a convenient set-up to control the electromechanical coupling of different vibrational modes. The system is sketched in Figure 1 and it consists of a metallic carbon nanotube suspended over the trench between two electrodes and an STM whose tip is positioned above a certain point along the nanotube axis. A bias voltage is applied between the STM tip and the supporting leads (which are both mantained at the same electrochemical potential) so that electrons can tunnel from the STM tip to the leads across the suspended carbon nanotube.
We take the -axis along the nanotube axis, while its cross-section lies in the plane. The STM tip is put over point () and its distance from the nanotube at equilibrium is 1 nm.
In order to describe the motion of the nanotube we model it as a classical elastic beam of length clamped at both ends and focus on its flexural vibrations.
The motion of the nanotube in the plane can be described through , its displacement along the axis from the static equilibrium configuration. If the amplitude of the oscillations is small enough for linear elasticity theory to be valid, the time evolution of is determined by the following equation :
In (1), is the carbon nanotube density, the cross section, the Young modulus, the cross section moment of inertia, the extra charge on the nanotube at time , and the component of the external force (per unit length) generated by the electrostatic interaction between the STM tip and the nanotube.
The precise spatial distribution of depends on the details of the geometric structure of the tip apex. However, a simple electrostatic analysis indicates that for , (where m is the effective size of the STM tip), the force decays at least as . Therefore the influence of the metallic leads can be ignored as long as the STM tip is not too close to them and we can write .
The displacement field and the force per unit length can be expressed as linear combinations of eigenfunctions of the operator with the boundary conditions , .
The expansion of and over the complete set of functions makes it possible to decompose (1) into a set of equations of motion for the eigenmode amplitudes , which can be written in hamiltonian form by introducing the conjugate momenta :
In (2a) and (2b), are the coefficients in the expansion of over the complete set of functions (which are chosen to be dimensionless), is the mass of the nanotube, and are the frequencies of the transverse vibrational modes, given by , where the eigenvalues can be found by solving: .
We introduced in (2b) a phenomenological damping force for each mode, , where has the dimension of inverse time. The motion of the nanotube is inevitably affected by dissipative mechanisms, which can be related to its coupling to the environment and to several internal processes. We will later consider a general form for which can be used to describe the damping induced by a wide class of phenomena.
An approximate expression for the force coefficients in (2b) can be found through some physical considerations on the characteristic lengths of the system. Since the eigenfunctions vary appreciably only over distances of the order of , we can express each as a sum of a sharply localized contribution at plus a correction:
where is a phenomenological parameter which provides the magnitude of the effective electrostatic field between the STM and the nanotube.
The size of the correction in (3) can be estimated in terms of the characteristic lengths of the system: for the typical values m and m, the condition is fulfilled and that defines the range of validity of the approximation which we will use from now on.
For what concerns the transport of charge the system is equivalent to a double tunnel junction, having one potential barrier localized between the STM tip and the nanotube and the another one between the nanotube and the leads. In our analysis we will consider the case of electrons for which the decoherence rate is much greater than the tunneling rates, so that the description of tunneling as a stochastic (rather than coherent) process is sufficient.
Furthermore, we consider the system in the Coulomb blockade regime and limit to one the number of extra electrons which can charge the nanotube, that is, with 0, 1. This condition can be realized if the electron temperature and the bias voltage are in the range defined by , where , are the effective capacitances of the STM-nanotube and nanotube-leads junctions, respectively, and .
Following the approach presented in  for a point-like oscillator coupled to a single-electron transistor, we define a probability density in the phase space of the system such that (with all the and scaled by proper dimensional factors) is the joint probability that at time there is an extra charge on the nanotube while the values of the eigenmode amplitudes and momenta , are within the phase space region defined by . In the regime of single charging of the nanotube only the probability densities and play a role in the description of the nanotube dynamics.
The coupling between the mechanical and electronic degrees of freedom arises because the tunneling rate between the STM tip and the nanotube, , is affected by their relative distance at point : , where is the effective tunneling length of the STM-nanotube junction and is a constant. The factor is the tunneling rate that would characterize the junction if the motion of the nanotube could be neglected. The tunneling rate between the nanotube and the leads, , does not depend on the nanotube displacement.
We remark that all the tunneling rates are generally functions of the , which has to be larger than the threshold value in order to make electrons tunnel from the STM tip to the nanotube. However, since here we always assume fixed at some value we do not explicitly indicate this dependence in the tunneling rates.
The time evolution of the probability densities and is determined by the following equations:
where , and the Liouvillian operators and are defined as follows:
From (4a) and (4b) we can derive the equations of motion for any dynamical variable averaged over the probability densities and : , where . The set of equations of motion for the first moments , , is:
The set of equations (6a), (6b), and (6c) is not closed because the exponential form of the tunneling rate introduces a coupling between the first and all the other moments. However in the limit of small oscillation amplitudes we can expand to first order in which reduces (6a), (6b), and (6c) to a closed set of linear equations.
The static solution of the linearized equations of motion, , , , where and are constant, describes the nanotube as a slightly bent beam at rest. The stability of this solution can be investigated by substituting the expressions (where is any of the dynamical variables , , and is constant) in the linearized equations of motion and solving for the exponents .
This procedure leads to an algebraic equation which in general cannot be solved analytically. However, if the dimensionless parameters are much smaller than 1 and the nanotube is only weakly damped (), we can look for exponents of the form , with and derive an analytical expression for the which up to the first order in all and reads
where . The condition can be taken as a definition of the weak electromechanical regime, since it implies that the shift in the equilibrium position of the nanotube at point when it is charged by one extra electron, , is much smaller than the tunneling length .
For realistic values of the parameters which are consistent with the conditions of validity of our model ( 0.1 V, , F as reported in , m, MHz), kg, m, the regime of weak electromechanical coupling is attained: for all the modes at any point along the nanotube axis.
The sign of the real part of in (7) determines the stability of the static solution for the th average mode amplitude. If then increases exponentially in time, hence the static solution for the th mode is unstable. This is the signature of a “shuttle-like” electromechanical instability. On the other hand, if the energy pumped into the vibrational mode by the electrostatic field is not able to compensate the loss due to dissipation and after a time interval of the order of the th mode amplitude decays to its static value.
For fixed values of , and , the sign of becomes a function of and , that is, it depends only on the position of the STM tip in the plane. We would like to point out that even if the onset of the electromechanical instability requires a bias voltage that overcomes the threshold value set by the Coulomb repulsion, , the magnitude of the Coulomb gap itself does not affect the stability of the vibrational modes, since appears in (7) only through the difference , which determines the tunneling rates , and the effective electrostatic field .
The set of values of and for which the real part of is positive defines the instability region for the th mode amplitude in the plane (,).
In order to map the instability regions we have to specify an analytic expression for the damping rates . The dissipation of mechanical energy in NEMS can take place through several mechanisms. However, in spite of the variety of the dissipative processes in solids, their effect on the NEMS performance can be described by considering the retardation induced in the NEMS response to mechanical perturbations (which adds to the “instantaneous” elastic behaviour).
In order to include this effect in our model we follow the approach introduced by Zener and formally replace the Young modulus with a frequency dependent complex function which results in the following expression for the damping rates: .
A large class of dissipative phenomena in solids (e.g., thermoelasticity, dislocations, and defects dynamics) can be parametrized though the dimensionless coefficient and the relaxation time , which both depend on temperature as well as on several geometric and material properties .
We first consider the limit in which the characteristic inverse time of the retarded mechanical response is much smaller than the frequencies of the nanotube eigenmodes: . In this case the damping term in (7) does not depend on the frequency and the dissipation rate is the same for all the modes.
In Figure 2 the instability regions determined by (7) for the first three modes are plotted together with the real parts of the exponents obtained from the numerical analysis of the linear stability problem. The areas labeled by 1, 2 and 3 correspond, respectively to the values of (, ) for which only mode 1, 2 and 3 is unstable. The overlap of the instability regions for different modes indicate the possibility of simultaneous excitation of several vibrational modes of the nanotube.
The physical picture presented in Figure 2 changes drastically in the opposite limit, , as can be seen in Figure 3. In this case the first mode is characterized by the smallest dissipation rate, , therefore if any of the modes is unstable, also the first one is unstable. That excludes the possibility of promoting a selective instability in the limit .
The dynamical behaviour of the nanotube in the regime of single-mode instability is qualitatively the same of the ordinary “shuttle” system . The amplitude of the oscillations increases exponentially until it reaches a certain steady value which depends on the parameters of the system. This transition is characterized by a large enhancement of the current (with respect to the static tunneling regime) that can be experimentally detected by measuring the current flowing through the device for different positions of the STM tip.
In the phase space of the system the dynamical state in this situation is described by a limit cycle, that is, an isolated closed trajectory characterized by finite amplitude oscillations . Here we have shown that the frequency of this stable self-oscillating state can be selected among the whole set of nanotube resonant frequencies through an accurate positioning of the STM tip.
In conclusion in the present work we studied the dynamics of the flexural vibrations of a suspended carbon nanotube in which extra electrons are injected at a position-dependent rate. We showed that a localized constant electrostatic field can excite many transverse vibrational modes of the nanotube into a “shuttle-like” regime of charge transport. For a fixed bias voltage and in presence of dissipative processes with inverse characteristic times much smaller than the frequencies of the nanotube vibrational modes, we found that it is possible to induce a selective instability through an accurate positioning of an STM. It thus seems possible to extend the approach followed here to other systems characterized by a nontrivial coupling between charge transport and mechanical degrees of freedom.
The author wants to thank L. Y. Gorelik, R. I. Shekhter, and M. Jonson for fruitful discussions and support. Partial financial support from the Swedish VR and from the Faculty of Science at the University of Gothenburg through its “Nanoparticle” Research Platform is gratefully acknowledged.
- K. L. Ekinci and M. L. Roukes, “Nanoelectromechanical systems,” Review of Scientific Instruments, vol. 76, Article ID 061101, 12 pages, 2005.
- M. P. Blencowe, “Nanoelectromechanical systems,” Contemporary Physics, vol. 46, no. 4, pp. 249–264, 2005.
- K. C. Schwab and M. L. Roukes, “Putting mechanics into quantum mechanics,” Physics Today, vol. 58, no. 7, pp. 36–42, 2005.
- P. Poncharal, Z. L. Wang, D. Ugarte, and W. A. de Heer, “Electrostatic deflections and electromechanical resonances of carbon nanotubes,” Science, vol. 283, no. 5407, pp. 1513–1516, 1999.
- S. T. Purcell, P. Vincent, C. Journet, and V. T. Binh, “Tuning of nanotube mechanical resonances by electric field pulling,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 89, no. 27, Article ID 276103, 4 pages, 2002.
- S. Sapmaz, Y. M. Blanter, L. Gurevich, and H. S. J. van der Zant, “Carbon nanotubes as nanoelectromechanical systems,” Physical Review B, vol. 67, no. 23, Article ID 235414, 7 pages, 2003.
- V. Sazonova, Y. Yalsh, I. Üstünel, D. Roundy, T. A. Arias, and P. L. McEuen, “A tunable carbon nanotube electrochemical oscillator,” Nature, vol. 431, no. 7006, pp. 284–287, 2004.
- B. Lassagne, Y. Tarakanov, J. Kinaret, D. Garcia-Sanchez, and A. Bachtold, “Coupling mechanics to charge transport in carbon nanotube mechanical resonators,” Science, vol. 325, no. 5944, pp. 1107–1110, 2009.
- L. Y. Gorelik, A. Isacsson, M. V. Voinova, B. Kasemo, R. I. Shekhter, and M. Jonson, “Shuttle mechanism for charge transfer in coulomb blockade nanostructures,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 80, no. 20, pp. 4526–4529, 1998.
- A. V. Moskalenko, S. N. Gordeev, O. F. Koentjoro et al., “Nanomechanical electron shuttle consisting of a gold nanoparticle embedded within the gap between two gold electrodes,” Physical Review B, vol. 79, no. 24, Article ID 241403, 2009.
- A. K. Hüttel, M. Pott, B. Witkamp, and H. S. J. van der Zant, “Nano-electromechanics of suspended carbon nanotubes,” New Journal of Physics, vol. 10, no. 9, Article ID 095003, 2008.
- L. M. Jonsson, L. Y. Gorelik, R. I. Shekhter, and M. Jonson, “Electromechanical instability in suspended carbon nanotubes,” Nano Letters, vol. 5, no. 6, pp. 1165–1169, 2005.
- L. M. Jonsson, L. Y. Gorelik, R. I. Shekhter, and M. Jonson, “Electromechanical instabilities of suspended carbon nanotubes—multi mode excitations,” New Journal of Physics, vol. 9, no. 4, p. 90, 2007.
- L. M. Jonsson, F. Santandrea, L. Y. Gorelik, R. I. Shekhter, and M. Jonson, “Self-organization of irregular nanoelectromechanical vibrations in multimode shuttle structures,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 100, no. 18, Article ID 186802, 2008.
- A. N. Cleland, Foundations of Nanomechanics, Springer, New York, NY, USA, 2003.
- A. D. Armour, M. P. Blencowe, and Y. Zhang, “Classical dynamics of a nanomechanical resonator coupled to a single-electron transistor,” Physical Review B, vol. 69, no. 12, Article ID 125313, 5 pages, 2004.
- S. Strogatz, Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos: With Applications to Physics, Biology, Chemistry and Engineering, Perseus Books, Cambridge, UK, 2001.
- B. J. LeRoy, S. G. Lemay, J. Kong, and C. Dekker, “Scanning tunneling spectroscopy of suspended single-wall carbon nanotubes,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 84, no. 21, pp. 4280–4282, 2004.
- A. S. Nowick and B. S. Berry, Anelastic Relaxation in Crystalline Solids, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1972.
Copyright © 2010 F. Santandrea. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.