Research Article

Tuberculosis Drug Susceptibility, Treatment, and Outcomes for Belarusian HIV-Positive Patients with Tuberculosis: Results from a National and International Laboratory

Table 3

Individual results of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) drug-susceptibility testing performed in two different laboratories (Belarus vs. Denmark) for 30 TB/HIV patients from Minsk, Belarus.

PIDPlace of analysisIsoniazidRifampicinEthambutolPyrazinamideStreptomycinAmikacinKanamycinCapreomycinMoxifloxacinOfloxacinLevofloxacinE-/prothionamideLinezolidCycloserinep-Amino salicylic acidLineage

Drug-sensitive TB
1MinskSSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSBeijing
2MinskSSSRSSSRSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSEAS
3MinskSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSBeijing
4MinskSSSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSBeijing
5MinskSSSSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSEAS
6MinskSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSEAS
7MinskSSSSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSUral
8MinskSSSSRSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPASSSSSS
WGSFailed
9MinskSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPASSSSSSS
WGSFailed
10MinskSSSSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSEAS
Monoresistant TB
11MinskRSSSSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRSSSSSSSSSSS
LPARSSSSSS
WGSRSSSSSSSSSBeijing
12MinskRSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRSSSSSSSSSSS
LPARS
WGSRSSSSSSSSSLAM
Multidrug-resistant TB
13MinskRRSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPA
WGSSSSSSSSSSSEAS
14MinskRRSSRSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoSSSS
LPAN/A
WGSFailed
15MinskRRRRRSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRSRRSSSSSRS
LPARRSSSSS
WGSRRRRRSSSSSBeijing
16MinskRRRRSSSSSRR
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRNG
LPARRSSSSS
WGSRRRSRSSSSSLAM
17MinskRRRRRSSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPARRSSSSS
WGSFailed
18MinskRRRRRSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRSSRSRSSSRS
LPARRSSSSS
WGSRRRSRSSSSSBeijing
19MinskRRRRSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRSSSSSRS
LPARRRRRSS
WGSRRRRRSSSSSLAM
20MinskRRRRRSSSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRSRSSSRS
LPARRRRRSS
WGSRRRRRSSSSSLAM
Preextensive drug-resistant TB
21MinskRRSRRRRRSSRR
CopenhagenPhenoRRSRRRRRSSSS
LPARRRRRSS
WGSFailed
22MinskRRSRRRSSSSS
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPARRRRRSS
WGSFailed
23MinskRRRRRSSRRR
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPARNCRRRSS
WGSFailed
24MinskRRRRSRSSRSR
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPARRRRRSS
WGSRRRRRSSSSSLAM
25MinskRRRRRSSSRSSSR
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRSRSRRSS
LPARRSSSRR
WGSRRRRRSSSRRBeijing
Extensive drug-resistant TB
26MinskRRRSRRRRRSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRSRSRRRRSSSS
LPARSRRRSS
WGSRRRSRRRRSSBeijing
27MinskRRRRRRRRRSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRRRSRRRS
LPARRRRRRR
WGSRRRRSRRRRRBeijing
28MinskRRRRRSRSRRRSS
CopenhagenPhenoFailed
LPARRRRRRR
WGSFailed
29MinskRRRRRRRRSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRRRSRRRS
LPARRRRRRR
WGSRRRSSRRRRRBeijing
30MinskRRRRRRRRRSSS
CopenhagenPhenoRRRRRRRRRRRS
LPARRRRRRR
WGSRRRRRRRRRRBeijing

Abbreviations: PID = patient’s identification number. DST = drug susceptibility testing. LPA = line probe assay. Pheno = phenotypic resistance. R = resistant. S = sensitive. WGS = whole-genome sequencing. Genotypic resistance was determined by detection of mutations in the inhA/katG genes for isoniazid, in the rpoB gene for rifampicin, in the embB gene for ethambutol, and in the pncA gene for pyrazinamide. For second-line drugs, resistance was determined for a drug class by detection of the following mutations: aminoglycosides (amikacin, capreomycin, and kanamycin) in the rrs and eis genes; streptomycin in the rpsL gene; fluoroquinolones (moxifloxacin, levofloxacin, and ofloxacin) in the gyrA and gyrB genes. EAS = Euro-American superlineage, LAM = Latin American-Mediterranean lineage. In Minsk, DST was performed at the Republican Scientific and Practical Center for Pulmonology and TB, Minsk, Belarus. In Copenhagen, DST was performed at the WHO TB Supranational Reference Laboratory, Copenhagen, Denmark. Drug-sensitive TB = Mtb sensitive to all first-line anti-TB drugs. Monoresistant TB = Mtb resistant to one first-line anti-TB drug only. Multidrug resistant TB = Mtb resistant to at least both isoniazid and rifampicin. Preextensive drug resistance = Mtb resistant to isoniazid and rifampicin and either to any fluoroquinolone or a second-line injectable agent but not to both. Extensive drug resistance = Mtb resistant to isoniazid and rifampicin and to any fluoroquinolone and to at least one of three second-line injectable drugs.