Research Article
Genetic Variability Analysis and Association of Traits in Common Bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) Landraces Collected from Ethiopia at Jimma
Table 4
Mean performance of one hundred genotypes tested at Jimma during 2020/21.
| Landraces | DTF | DTM | PH | NPP | NSP | PL | PW | HI | HSW | YLD |
| 1 | 51a-f | 94.5r-t | 52.4q-w | 16.8n-x | 80.4b-r | 13.05 b | 0.515l-m | 29.895x-z | 16.510r-z | 3444.9c-s | 2 | 49.5d-i | 98.5j-n | 86.05a-f | 18.4h-w | 95.7a-e | 13.05 b | 0.905d-e | 35.285s-u | 17.525p-z | 3203.5f-t | 3 | 50 d-h | 97.5l-p | 56.8p-w | 20.2b-s | 61.6o-z | 10.05l-o | 0.705i-j | 22.070n-q | 16.350s-z | 3631.2b-q | 4 | 49.5d-i | 96.5n-r | 52.6q-w | 25.3a-b | 94.8a-f | 13.15 b | 0.6k-l | 29.83x-z | 16.065u-z | 2753.0l-v | 5 | 48.5f-k | 97m-q | 53.35q-w | 15.5q-x | 63.5n-z | 11.55d-h | 0.66i-k | 54.055a-c | 15.735v-z | 3005.8h-u | 6 | 54a | 100.5f-j | 61.95j-w | 17m-x | 56.1t-z | 10.05l-o | 0.515l-m | 30.025x-z | 18.330i-y | 2832.3k-v | 7 | 48g-l | 99i-m | 57.8n-w | 19.1d-u | 56t-z | 12.05c-d | 0.705i-j | 50.19f-j | 17.125p-z | 2912.9i-v | 8 | 45.5 l | 96o-s | 67e-u | 17.6k-x | 38.6c | 9.15p-s | 0.705i-j | 49.01i-j | 18.360i-y | 2659.1n-v | 9 | 47i-l | 99.5h-l | 79.40a-l | 17.5k-x | 62.5n-z | 11.1g-i | 0.615k-l | 44.18l-m | 19.556e-r | 4087.2a-l | 10 | 53a-c | 101.5d-h | 99.26a | 17.8j-x | 58.2r-z | 10.05l-o | 0.615k-l | 22.885l-q | 16.730q-z | 3571.2b-s | 11 | 53.5a-b | 102c-g | 67.6d-t | 21b-o | 88.1a-m | 12c-e | 0.75f-i | 28.435z | 15.635w-z | 3551.7b-s | 12 | 49e-j | 104.5 b | 69.3d-r | 19e-v | 75.6b-w | 11g-j | 0.6k-l | 49.9f-j | 17.440p-z | 3102.1g-u | 13 | 52a-d | 95q-t | 76.3b-p | 23.6a-h | 84.6b-n | 12.05c-d | 1.1b-c | 35.21s-u | 12.405 l | 3295.5f-t | 14 | 48.5f-k | 100.5f-j | 77.9b-n | 24a-f | 77.7b-t | 11g-j | 0.7i-j | 24.96g-l | 18.165m-z | 4526.0a-f | 15 | 46.5j-l | 96o-s | 67.85d-t | 21.3b-o | 60.4o-z | 13.05 b | 0.605k-l | 21.330p-q | 16.900q-w | 2839.6k-v | 16 | 53.5a-b | 100g-k | 68.2d-s | 19.4c-u | 80.4b-r | 11.15f-i | 0.505l-m | 21.835n-q | 17.830n-z | 4381.6a-g | 17 | 49-j | 103.5b-d | 84.6a-i | 17.5k-x | 55.9t-z | 12.1c-d | 0.71i-j | 30.55x-z | 19.625e-q | 3744.9b-p | 18 | 53a-c | 102c-g | 65.7f-w | 18.8f-v | 64.2n-z | 9.1q-s | 0.515l-m | 34.945s-u | 13.680h-l | 2549.4o-v | 19 | 48g-l | 95.5p-t | 63.1j-w | 20.6b-r | 70.50h-z | 13.15 b | 0.705i-j | 29.1y-z | 18.735g-v | 4528.4a-f | 20 | 49e-j | 101.5d-h | 65.6g-w | 22.9a-j | 66.1l-z | 9.05q-s | 0.55k-m | 39.855o-p | 15.650v-z | 2278.0r-v | 21 | 49e-j | 102c-g | 85.2a-h | 21b-o | 69.6h-z | 10.05l-o | 0.61k-l | 21.540o-q | 18.020n-z | 3279.0f-t | 22 | 48g-l | 93.5 t | 47.8t-w | 23.5a-i | 74.2c-x | 12c-e | 1.1b-c | 26.745d-i | 14.925b-l | 2253.1s-v | 23 | 47i-l | 98.5j-n | 64.5i-w | 20.6b-r | 75c-w | 12c-e | 0.7i-j | 33.715t-v | 14.060g-l | 3953.0a-n | 24 | 47.5h-l | 98.5j-n | 67.3e-t | 22.5a-l | 80.9b-q | 11.05g-j | 0.81g-h | 51.22d-i | 14.680d-l | 3023.5h-u | 25 | 46.5j-l | 96.5n-r | 80.4a-j | 17.2m-x | 59.6p-z | 11.9c-f | 0.605k-l | 50.8e-i | 21.165b-m | 3303.8f-t | 26 | 49.5d-i | 94s-t | 51.3r-w | 22.2a-m | 69.9h-z | 11.15f-i | 0.72g-j | 20.725q | 15.275a-y | 3235.9f-t | 27 | 48g-l | 95q-t | 60.8j-w | 18.9f-v | 68.5i-z | 10.05l-o | 0.65i-k | 30.86w-y | 23.385a-c | 3689.5b-p | 28 | 48.5f-k | 97.5l-p | 78.3b-m | 17.8j-x | 68i-z | 13.1 b | 0.65i-k | 24.59h-m | 19.270f-t | 2634.2n-v | 29 | 50.5c-g | 102.5b-f | 79.9a-k | 18.5g-w | 61.7o-z | 12.05c-d | 1c-d | 30x-z | 17.385p-z | 2853.9j-v | 30 | 53.5a-b | 102c-g | 59.9k-w | 20.4b-r | 80.9b-q | 12.1c-d | 0.61k-l | 30.89w-y | 15.430a-y | 3215.8f-t | 31 | 53.5a-b | 103b-e | 72.3c-q | 18.9f-v | 55.4t-z | 11.1g-i | 0.605k-l | 27.380c-f | 16.465r-z | 4128.9a-k | 32 | 45.5 l | 97.5l-p | 62.7j-w | 15.4r-x | 56.3t-z | 10l-o | 0.6k-l | 33.2u-v | 22.51a-e | 4039.4a-m | 33 | 49.5d-i | 97.5l-p | 58.7m-w | 18.4h-w | 69.3h-z | 10.1l-o | 0.6k-l | 29.775x-z | 17.400p-z | 2827.1k-v | 34 | 46.5j-l | 99.5h-l | 68.8d-r | 23.2a-i | 70.4h-z | 11.05g-j | 0.5l-m | 27.04c-g | 16.825q-w | 2525.7o-v | 35 | 51a-f | 95q-t | 66.3f-u | 24.25a-e | 82.7b-o | 11.1g-i | 0.605k-l | 29.89x-z | 17.210p-z | 3946.3a-n | 36 | 47i-l | 98k-o | 69.3d-r | 27.4a | 91.4a-h | 10.05l-o | 0.705i-j | 37.025q-s | 17.670p-z | 3088.0g-u | 37 | 51.5a-e | 101e-i | 64.1j-w | 18.7g-v | 73.4e-y | 12.05c-d | 0.61k-l | 35.05s-u | 18.530h-w | 3785.0b-p | 38 | 49.5d-i | 97m-q | 63.00j-w | 19.9c-u | 54.6x-z | 9.1q-s | 0.705i-j | 43.715m-n | 17.735o-z | 3430.1c-s | 39 | 50.5c-g | 99.5h-l | 58.9m-w | 21.5b-n | 66.7l-z | 13b | 0.5l-m | 53.115b-d | 16.805q-w | 4345.0a-h | 40 | 48g-l | 96.5n-r | 55.25q-w | 22.7a-k | 90a-j | 11.15f-i | 1.2a-b | 50.05f-j | 13.690h-l | 3231.5f-t | 41 | 51.5a-e | 101.5d-h | 45.65v-w | 24.5a-c | 98a-b | 11g-j | 0.5l-m | 49.75h-j | 13.610i-l | 2811.1k-v | 42 | 47i-l | 95q-t | 65.6g-w | 20.2b-s | 63.8n-z | 12.1c-d | 0.705i-j | 55.55a | 22.045a-f | 3295.0f-t | 43 | 49.5d-i | 98k-o | 60.4j-w | 18.4h-w | 67.9j-z | 10.9h-k | 0.515l-m | 50.705e-i | 20.070d-p | 5263.7a | 44 | 47.5h-l | 95.5p-t | 48.4s-w | 18.4h-w | 74.5c-w | 14.05a | 0.505l-m | 41.455n-o | 50.705a | 4682.2a-e | 45 | 47.5h-l | 94s-t | 60.55j-w | 12.9x | 50.5z | 12.1c-d | 0.605k-l | 55.03a-b | 18.205l-z | 2691.2m-v | 46 | 48g-l | 94s-t | 57.45w | 17.1m-x | 55u-z | 11.75d-g | 0.7i-j | 23.91j-n | 18.155m-z | 3907.9b-n | 47 | 46.5k-l | 95.5p-t | 52.85q-w | 19.6c-u | 73.6d-y | 9.5n-q | 1.25a | 51.415d-h | 21.620a-h | 3412.1c-s | 48 | 48.5f-k | 97m-q | 57.7n-w | 17.5k-x | 63.2n-z | 12.55b-c | 0.61k-l | 42.865m-n | 21.350a-k | 4691.4a-d | 49 | 50d-h | 96.5n-r | 64.85hw | 22.57a-l | 89.2a-k | 11.95c-e | 0.845e-g | 36.995q-s | 15.305a-y | 3665.7b-p | 50 | 50.5c-g | 102c-g | 69.8c-r | 21.1b-o | 96.6a-c | 11.25e-i | 0.65i-k | 23k-q | 15.705v-z | 3668.0b-p | 51 | 52a-d | 99.5h-l | 53.8q-w | 17.5k-x | 54.5x-z | 12.15c-d | 0.71i-j | 30.105x-z | 16.250t-z | 4040.7a-m | 52 | 48.5f-k | 99i-m | 63.3j-w | 17m-x | 65.7m-z | 11.05g-j | 0.505l-m | 34.93s-u | 15.670v-z | 3114.2g-t | 53 | 49e-j | 99.5h-l | 72.2c-q | 17.4l-x | 76.4b-v | 11.1g-i | 0.705i-j | 25.000g-l | 18.410i-x | 3608.8b-r | 54 | 49.5d-i | 101.5d-h | 69.95c-r | 18.3i-w | 61.2o-z | 12.05c-d | 0.6k-l | 24.52i-m | 16.325s-z | 4242.6a-i | 55 | 47i-l | 96.5n-r | 70.4c-r | 15.4r-x | 62.9n-z | 10.15k-n | 0.5 m | 38.94p-q | 15.685v-z | 2023.6t-v | 56 | 47i-l | 97.5l-p | 62.4j-w | 19.4c-u | 54.1x-z | 8.05 t | 0.55k-m | 23.845j-n | 16.570q-z | 1751.8u-v | 57 | 49e-j | 97.5l-p | 67.6d-t | 20.9b-o | 67.9j-z | 9.05q-s | 0.515l-m | 27.06c-g | 19.530e-r | 3868.6b-o | 58 | 46.5k-l | 97m-q | 68.6d-s | 17m-x | 64.4n-z | 10.05l-o | 0.515l-m | 53.38a-d | 23.060a-d | 4800.0a-b | 59 | 48g-l | 99.5h-l | 90.1a-c | 16.2o-x | 66.3l-z | 13b | 0.7i-j | 34.14t-v | 19.505e-r | 4110.9a-k | 60 | 50.5c-g | 96.5n-r | 68d-t | 19.7c-u | 57.2s-z | 10.1l-o | 0.605k-l | 23.155k-o | 18.545h-w | 4218.5a-i | 61 | 47.5h-l | 101.5d-h | 77.5b-o | 22.2a-m | 81.6b-p | 10.05l-o | 0.75f-i | 25.6e-j | 18.695g-w | 2249.1s-v | 62 | 49.5d-i | 95.5p-t | 51.55r-w | 20.8b-p | 88.4a-l | 8.55s-t | 0.8e-h | 50.19f-j | 12.945k-l | 3031.7g-u | 63 | 45.5 l | 94.5r-t | 57.9n-w | 20.2b-s | 62.3n-z | 13.05 b | 0.61k-l | 27.625b-e | 23.975a-b | 3200.7f-t | 64 | 49.5d-i | 96.5n-r | 54.55q-w | 19.8c-u | 90.4a-i | 10.65k-m | 0.805e-h | 24.635h-m | 14.270f-l | 2753.5l-v | 65 | 49e-j | 94.5r-t | 58.05m-w | 20.9b-o | 77.1b-u | 8.15 t | 1.105b-c | 26.65d-i | 13.000j-l | 4197.6a-j | 66 | 47i-l | 97m-q | 66.5e-u | 20.1b-t | 53.6x-z | 10.1l-o | 0.515l-m | 23.77j-o | 16.690q-z | 3346.7d-t | 67 | 51.5a-e | 100g-k | 58.7m-w | 22.6a-l | 77.2b-u | 8.6r-t | 0.705i-j | 52.72c-e | 14.830c-l | 3238.1f-t | 68 | 47.5h-l | 115.5a | 70.9c-r | 24.3a-d | 72.56f-z | 10.05l-o | 0.61k-l | 26.845c-h | 19.230f-t | 2284.2q-v | 69 | 49.5d-i | 95q-t | 70.3c-r | 20.7b-q | 89.3a-k | 9.35o-r | 0.85e-f | 29.845x-z | 16.045u-z | 3419.2c-s | 70 | 47i-l | 99i-m | 66.6e-u | 19.2d-u | 48.8a-c | 12.15c-d | 0.61k-l | 28.885y-z | 17.680p-z | 3054.0g-u | 71 | 47i-l | 96.5n-r | 65.55g-w | 17.2m-x | 69.6h-z | 9.05q-s | 0.505l-m | 29.745x-z | 21.355a-k | 3276.9f-t | 72 | 50.5c-g | 97.5l-p | 94a-b | 14.75u-x | 66.9k-z | 10.05l-o | 0.805e-h | 38.43p-q | 17.885n-z | 3385.2c-s | 73 | 47.5h-l | 100g-k | 66.6e-u | 16.2o-x | 51.9x-z | 12.05c-d | 0.515l-m | 25.25f-k | 15.810u-z | 3155.2g-t | 74 | 47i-l | 98k-o | 79.4a-l | 13.8v-x | 57.6s-z | 9.05q-s | 0.7i-j | 33.11u-w | 20.780c-o | 3156.5g-t | 75 | 50.5c-g | 97m-q | 69.1d-r | 17.9j-x | 68.4i-z | 12c-e | 0.6k-l | 35.88r-t | 18.835g-u | 3570.3b-s | 76 | 48g-l | 99i-m | 58.6m-w | 19.6c-u | 59.6p-z | 11.15f-i | 0.71i-j | 52.07c-g | 15.170a-z | 3846.4b-o | 77 | 48g-l | 95.5p-t | 71.5c-r | 16.2o-x | 58.8q-z | 11.05g-j | 0.605k-l | 28.165a-d | 18.715g-w | 3002.0h-u | 78 | 48g-l | 104b-c | 86.8a-e | 13.3w-x | 46.9b-c | 11.1g-i | 0.61k-l | 42.13m-o | 21.285a-l | 3475.2b-s | 79 | 47i-l | 97.5l-p | 54.7q-w | 20.3b-s | 79.2b-s | 9.1q-s | 0.505l-m | 49.83g-j | 20.840c-n | 3244.0f-t | 80 | 47.5h-l | 99i-m | 67.3e-t | 19.9c-u | 56.8s-z | 11.15f-i | 0.65i-k | 25.59e-j | 16.100u-z | 2248.0s-v | 81 | 50d-h | 97m-q | 59.3l-w | 18.6g-v | 70.3h-z | 8.05 t | 0.55k-m | 22.365m-q | 18.310j-z | 2814.5k-v | 82 | 51.5a-e | 101e-i | 87.7a-d | 18.3i-w | 71.57g-z | 10l-o | 0.6k-l | 22.805l-q | 17.245p-z | 3371.6c-t | 83 | 48.5f-k | 96.5n-r | 70.4c-r | 21.2b-o | 90.1a-j | 10.05l-o | 0.91d-e | 53.8a-c | 16.730q-z | 3503.6b-s | 84 | 49e-j | 101.5d-h | 70c-r | 17.2m-x | 59.1q-z | 9.05q-s | 0.605k-l | 22.390m-q | 18.230l-z | 3337.8e-t | 85 | 47i-l | 97.5l-p | 60k-w | 18.3i-w | 57.9s-z | 10.05l-o | 0.605k-l | 38.02p-r | 21.365a-j | 3171.4g-t | 86 | 50d-h | 96.5n-r | 66f-v | 18.4h-w | 51.7y-z | 11.1g-i | 0.605k-l | 43.405m-n | 18.265k-y | 3727.4b-p | 87 | 47.5h-l | 97.5l-p | 53.2q-w | 15.4r-x | 55.9t-z | 10.15k-n | 0.65i-k | 31.945v-x | 21.415a-i | 3251.6f-t | 88 | 48g-l | 97.5l-p | 85.7a-g | 19.5c-u | 67.8j-z | 10.05l-o | 0.515l-m | 30.12x-z | 19.400f-s | 4346.9a-h | 89 | 47.5h-l | 94.5r-t | 70.1c-r | 20c-u | 53.7x-z | 12.05c-d | 0.6k-l | 34.91s-u | 21.700a-g | 4688.7a-e | 90 | 45.5 l | 95q-t | 46.9u-w | 20.8b-p | 67.2k-z | 10.05l-o | 0.6k-l | 27.22c-g | 23.520a-c | 3535.3b-s | 91 | 49e-j | 97m-q | 62.5j-w | 22.6a-l | 108a | 10.7k-l | 0.7i-j | 48.16j-k | 16.195t-z | 3308.7f-t | 92 | 46.5k-l | 94s-t | 45.5w | 17.8j-x | 66.3l-z | 11.1g-i | 0.505l-m | 40.215o-p | 24.160a-b | 4709.0a-c | 93 | 46.5j-l | 102.5b-f | 76.4b-p | 23.7a-g | 93.4a-g | 12c-e | 0.8e-h | 24.990g-l | 14.520e-l | 1642.1v | 94 | 50d-h | 97m-q | 54.2q-w | 14.9t-x | 51.2y-z | 10.05l-o | 0.705i-j | 24.105j-n | 16.815q-w | 2933.3i-v | 95 | 50.5c-g | 97.5l-p | 77.8b-o | 20.4b-r | 96a-d | 10.3k-m | 0.9d-e | 46.025k-l | 15.120a-l | 2728.0m-v | 96 | 48g-l | 96o-s | 79.9a-k | 15.6p-x | 65.1n-z | 9.9m-p | 0.605k-l | 29.775x-z | 22.005a-f | 3517.0b-s | 97 | 50d-h | 103b-e | 76.2b-p | 19.5c-u | 66l-z | 12.95 b | 0.725f-j | 23.425j-p | 17.080p-z | 3302.0f-t | 98 | 47i-l | 97m-q | 59.4l-w | 15.1s-x | 50.4z | 12.05c-d | 0.75f-i | 23.34j-p | 17.985n-z | 2483.3p-v | 99 | 50.5c-g | 96o-s | 59.25l-w | 16.5n-x | 51.7y-z | 10.15k-n | 0.605k-l | 22.825l-q | 16.395s-z | 2738.9l-v | 100 | 45.5 l | 96.5n-r | 51.2r-w | 17.1m-x | 66.6l-z | 11.1g-i | 0.505l-m | 52.15c-f | 23.475a-c | 2946.6i-v | Mean | 48.83 | 98.225 | 66.1486 | 19.2817 | 68.8923 | 10.9225 | 0.666749 | 34.5544 | 17.90786 | 3367.471 | min | 45.1973 | 93.5 | 45.5 | 12.9 | 38.6 | 8.05 | 0.4452 | 20.725 | 12.405 | 1642.08 | Max | 54.0298 | 115.5 | 99.26 | 27.4 | 108 | 14.05 | 1.2401 | 55.55 | 24.32 | 5263.66 | LSD (0.05% | 2.54 | 2.2 | 20.39 | 5.29 | 22.42 | 0.77 | 0.12 | 2.28 | 3.09 | 1351.9 | CV% | 2.61 | 1.12 | 15.49 | 13.81 | 16.36 | 3.55 | 9.65 | 3.32 | 8.67 | 20.17 |
|
|