Advances in Civil Engineering

Research Article

Ranking Sustainable Projects through an Innovative Hybrid DEMATEL-VIKOR Decision-Making Approach Using Z-Number

Table 47

Quantified probabilistic linguistic scoring spectrum for sustainability criteria for proposed projects.
 E1E2E3E4S1S2S3S4G1G2G3G4
P1(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.668, 0.89, 0.89)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0.75, 1, 1)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.75, 1, 1)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)
P2(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0, 0, 0.193)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0, 0, 0.223)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0, 0, 0.223)(0, 0, 0.193)
P3(0.578, 0.77, 0.77)(0, 0.158, 0.315)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)(0.578, 0.77, 0.77)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0, 0.178, 0.355)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.473, 0.63, 0.63)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)
P4(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0, 0, 0.25)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)
P5(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.158, 0.315, 0.473)(0, 0, 0.158)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)(0, 0.158, 0.315)(0, 0, 0.238)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0, 0, 0.223)
P6(0.533, 0.71, 0.71)(0.578, 0.77, 0.77)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0, 0, 0.238)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.178, 0.355)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)(0, 0.178, 0.355)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)
P7(0, 0, 0.193)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0, 0, 0.158)(0.158, 0.315, 0.473)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0, 0.178, 0.355)
P8(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.75, 1, 1)(0.668, 0.89, 0.89)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.713, 0.95, 0.95)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)
P9(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.315, 0.473, 0.63)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0.315, 0.473, 0.63)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.668, 0.89, 0.89)(0.473, 0.63, 0.63)(0.315, 0.473, 0.63)
P10(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0, 0, 0.25)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0, 0, 0.238)(0, 0, 0.238)
P11(0.713, 0.95, 0.95)(0, 0.25, 0.5)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.533, 0.71, 0.71)(0, 0.178, 0.355)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0, 0.25, 0.5)
P12(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)
P13(0, 0, 0.223)(0, 0, 0.178)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0, 0, 0.193)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0, 0, 0.223)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)
P14(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0, 0, 0.25)(0, 0.25, 0.5)(0, 0, 0.178)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)
P15(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0, 0, 0.25)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0, 0, 0.223)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.5, 0.75, 1)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.713, 0.95, 0.95)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0, 0.223, 0.445)(0.668, 0.89, 0.89)
P16(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)(0.315, 0.473, 0.63)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0.578, 0.77, 0.77)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0.533, 0.71, 0.71)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)
P17(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.178, 0.355)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0, 0.178, 0.355)
P18(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0.713, 0.95, 0.95)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)(0.315, 0.473, 0.63)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)(0, 0.25, 0.5)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.158, 0.315, 0.473)(0.355, 0.533, 0.71)
P19(0.193, 0.385, 0.578)(0, 0, 0.178)(0, 0, 0.178)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0, 0.25, 0.5)(0.178, 0.355, 0.533)(0.385, 0.578, 0.77)(0, 0.193, 0.385)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0, 0, 0.223)(0.238, 0.475, 0.713)(0, 0.238, 0.475)
P20(0.75, 1, 1)(0, 0, 0.25)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.445, 0.668, 0.89)(0.75, 1, 1)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.475, 0.713, 0.95)(0, 0, 0.238)(0, 0.238, 0.475)(0.223, 0.445, 0.668)(0.25, 0.5, 0.75)