Review Article

A Decade of Value Engineering in Construction Projects

Table 3

VE tools.

NoToolsMethodology

1Original VE approachUsing the original VE job plan including information, function analysis, creativity, evaluation, development, and presentation
2FAST (functional analysis system technique)FAST diagram is a technique developed to improve function determination, classification, and evaluation according to the How-Why logic formula, with results plotted into a block diagram
3Value indexValue is defined as the ratio of performance to cost Value (V) = Performance (P)/Cost (C)
4VE-KMS (value engineering knowledge management system)Integrates TRIZ into the creativity phase, including analysis of: (1) technical contradictions, (2) physical contradictions, (3) substance field, and (4) technological evolution. This allows workshop participants to maximize the impact of their engineering experience and proficiencies, as explicit knowledge. The system saves this knowledge in a database for continued use in the VE process and is continuously updated
5RETRIEVE (remembering tool for reusing the ideas evolved in value engineering)VE proposals are collected from previous VEW sessions for use in reference to current problems. RETRIEVE identifies similarities between new and old cases using an algorithm developed in VBA for MS Office™ and MS Office Access™
6Fuzzy case-based reasoningIntegrates case-based reasoning (CBR) with fuzzy logic concepts to measure similarities of new and previously solved problems
7ELECTRE IIIELECTRE III is used to rank alternative solutions in the evaluation phase to aid decision-making
8GDSS-IVMS (group decision support system)Creates a virtual online VE workshop phase, mooting the need for face-to-face meetings
9BIM-based idea bankUsing 2D BIM objects, workshop participants may reuse previous VE cases and ideas to produce alternative solutions for current projects
10LiVE (Lean integrated VE)Integrates lean concepts to eliminate waste in VE processes to identify necessary functions through creating an 8-phase job plan
11Performance assessmentUsed in the postworkshop phase to evaluate the success of results generated from the workshop phase. It also appraises workshop process performance as a reference to improve future workshops
12Pareto’s lawHolds that 80% of the cost or risk can be found in 20% of the project’s function
13BIM integrationIntegrating building information modelling with value engineering
14Grey multicriteria decision-makingFramework for utilizing a value engineering approach to supply chain cost management and overcoming the limitations with VE by utilizing grey multicriteria decision-making