Abstract

In our previous work the possibility to use the Aharonov-Anandan invariant as a tool in the analysis of disparate systems has been shown, including Hawking and Unruh effects, as well as graphene physics and thermal states. We show that the vacuum condensation, characterizing such systems, is also related with geometric phases and we analyze the properties of the geometric phase of systems represented by mixed state and undergoing a nonunitary evolution. In particular, we consider two-level atoms accelerated by an external potential and interacting with a thermal state. We propose the realization of Mach-Zehnder interferometers which can prove the existence of the Unruh effect and can allow very precise measurements of temperature.

1. Introduction

It is hard to observe phenomena like Unruh [1], Hawking [2], and Parker effects [3, 4]. However it has been shown [5] that in such phenomena as well as in all the systems where the vacuum condensates are generated [612], the Aharonov-Anandan invariant (AAI) [13] is produced in their evolution. Moreover, it has been shown [14, 15] that such an invariant is related to the geometric phase [1637]. This fact suggests that in all the above phenomena, in which the presence of AAIs has been revealed [5], an associated geometric phase also appears. Then, the study of such a phase could open a new way to the detection of effects elusive to the detection.

Here, instead of using AAI, which is experimentally difficult to be observed, we use geometric phases to study the Unruh effect and the possibility to perform very precise measurement of temperature. Geometric phases have been detected in many physical systems [3842] and have been also related to CPT symmetry [43] and SUSY violation in thermal states [44].

In the present paper, we focus our attention on systems of atoms accelerated in an electromagnetic field and atoms interacting with thermal states, so that we study geometric phases for mixed states in nonunitary, noncyclic evolution. Different approaches exist in dealing with geometric phases and mixed states [3137]; in this paper we mostly follow the Wang and Liu approach [30].

In our treatment, besides the relation between boson condensation and geometric phase, we obtain two novel results, one concerning atoms accelerated in an electromagnetic field and the Unruh effect and the other one exhibiting the possibility to perform very precise measurement of temperature. In the first case, a detectable difference of the geometric phases appears between the accelerated and the inertial atoms. Such a phase difference is due only to the Unruh effect. In the second case, the difference between geometric phases produced by atoms interacting with two different thermal states allows to determine the temperature of a sample once the temperature of the other one (assumed as reference temperature) is known.

The idea of using geometric phases and invariants to probe the Unruh effect [5, 45, 46] and to build a thermometer [5, 47] has been already presented in previous works (the study of dynamical phase to have precise estimation of the temperature has been proposed in [48]). In this paper we consider a realistic scheme for experimental implementations and we study the geometric phase defined in [30], which generalize the Berry phase (used in [46, 47]), to the case of quantum open systems. The use of the phase presented in [30] allows to consider time intervals arbitrary small (we do not need to consider cyclic evolutions and their related period). In a similar way the discussion reported in [30] allows to consider the cases of very low transition frequencies, as well as spontaneous emission rates characterizing fine and hyperfine atomic structures. Indeed, in the short time intervals which we consider, the number of spontaneously emitted particle is negligible and the systems are quasistable.

The Berry phase for mixed states cannot be used in the study of the systems which we consider. One reason is that our systems do not undergo cyclic evolutions because of their interaction with the environment [30]. Even in the approximation of a quasicyclicity of mixed states, the number of spontaneously emitted particles becomes not negligible in time intervals of the order of (with atomic transition frequency). Thus the analysis of the geometric phase loses meaning.

Our treatment offers other improvements, which cannot be obtained by using the Berry phase. For example, in the present treatment, by considering the fine and hyperfine atomic structure, we have access to lower acceleration regimes, which in turn improves the detection of Unruh effect and permits very precise temperature measurements.

We consider the structure of the atomic levels of , , and . We suggest that a Mach-Zehnder interferometer of 4 cm, where the hyperfine level of these atoms is considered, may reveal the Unruh effect with accelerations of order of 1016 m/s2 and that a similar device could be used also for very precise temperature measurements.

In Section 2 we link together AAI, geometric phase, and vacuum condensates and introduce the geometric phase for mixed states in nonunitary evolution. In Section 3 we analyze the geometric phase for a two-level atom undergoing a nonunitary evolution and in Sections 4 and 5 we study the realization of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer to reveal the Unruh effect and to build a very precise thermometer. Section 6 is devoted to the conclusions.

2. Geometric Phase

The geometric phase for pure states can be expressed as [15] which also establishes the relation with the AAI. Here denotes the infinitesimal “reference distance” in the projective Hilbert space and is given by with . In (1), is the Fubini-Study metric given byThe AAI is the total length of the path measured using the Fubini-Study metric expressed as [13]. In the above formulas is a nonstationary state with energy uncertainty given by . Since the length of the path “” is the minimum length measured by the “reference distance” function “” [14, 15], the presence of the AAI in the evolution of a system implies the presence of the “” invariant and consequentially the existence of the geometric phase (1). As already mentioned in the Introduction, the AAI is produced in the evolution of systems with vacuum condensates [5] (see the Appendix); then (1) suggests that vacuum condensation is also related with geometric phases.

Vacuum fluctuations may produce particle creation from vacuum or vacuum condensate in disparate ways [112]. Then the geometric phase may provide the possibility to study the properties of many systems and could be used to detect effects so far elusive to the observations, ranging from the Unruh effect to Casimir effect, including other phenomena of quantum field theory (QFT) in curved background.

As said, in the present paper we focus on the Unruh effect and on thermal states, studying the possible realization of a quantum thermometer. In our analysis we consider quantum open systems and analyze the geometric phase for mixed states in nonunitary, noncyclic evolution. In particular, we use the Wang and Liu approach [30] and the geometric phase defined aswhere the first term of the right side represents the total phase, while the second term is the dynamic one. In (4), is the Block radius, satisfying the condition , , and are the eigenvalues of the operator (with traceless and hermitian operators and ) which permits to write as . Moreover, and are eigenstates and eigenvalues of the density matrix of -level mixed states, respectively:Then the geometric phase (4) can be expressed also as

We consider a two-level open system. In this case, , , and the density matrix is expressed in terms of Pauli matrices as with and radius of Block sphere given by . Explicitly, one hasIntroducing the angles such as the eigenvectors and (apart from overall phase factors which do not contribute to ) areand the eigenvalues of the operator are and . Therefore and .

3. Geometric Phase and Two-Level Atoms

We consider the interaction of an atom with vacuum modes of the electromagnetic field in the multipolar scheme [49] and treat the atom as an open system with a nonunitary evolution in the reservoir of the electromagnetic field. The Hamiltonian of the atom and the reservoir is where is the energy level spacing of the atom, is the Pauli matrix, is the electromagnetic field Hamiltonian, is the matrix element of the dipole momentum operator connecting single-particle states and (see [49]), , and is the strength of the electric field. Denoting by and the vacuum and the initial reduced density matrix of the atom, respectively, we analyze the evolution of the total density matrix , in the frame of the atom. We assume a weak interaction between atom and field; then the evolution can be written as [50, 51] Here is the proper time and are the coefficients of the Kossakowski matrix with is the Fourier transform of : is the effective hamiltonian, , where is the renormalized energy level spacing containing the Lamb shift terms. Such terms can be neglected in the computation of the geometric phase; thus we approximate the effective level spacing of the atoms with the atomic transition frequency ; that is .

By writing in terms of Pauli matrices, as in (7), and considering the initial state of the atom, with , one can derive the reduced density matrix [5, 45]

Denoting by and the following quantitiesthe matrix (18) can be written asThen, (8), the Block radius and the angles defined in (9) are given by respectively. The eigenvalues of are and the corresponding eigenvectors are We consider the initial time . Being , the phase (6) becomes which reduces to with .

In the next sections we consider the use of (29) in the detection of Unruh effect and in the building of a quantum thermometer.

4. Unruh Effect

For an accelerated observer the ground state of an inertial system appears at a nonzero temperature depending on the acceleration of the observer. Such a phenomenon is called the Unruh effect. It has not yet been detected. Recently it has been shown that geometric phases and invariants could allow its detection in table top experiments [5, 45, 46].

Here we show that the realization of an interferometer is possible, in which paths of slightly different lengths can be chosen in order to let the geometric phase be dominating over the relative dynamical phase. We compute the geometric phase (29) for the two-level system in the presence of an acceleration and in the inertial case. The atom interaction with the electromagnetic field itself produces a geometric phase; however, the difference between the two phases is due only to the atom acceleration and then to the Unruh effect, since the accelerated system sees the Minkowski vacuum as a thermal Rindler vacuum.

A two-level atom uniformly accelerated in the direction with acceleration , through Minkowski spacetime, is conveniently described with Rindler coordinates , . For this system, the field correlation function is given by [5, 45] and its Fourier transform isThen, the coefficients and in (14) become [5, 45]where is the spontaneous emission rate and is the atomic transition frequency. The function in (29) becomes and similar for . Here .

For an inertial atom, , the geometric phase assumes the identical expression of (29), with , , and replaced by , , and in which the coefficients , , are replaced by , with spontaneous emission rate, and , respectively.

The phase difference between the accelerated and inertial atoms, , gives the geometric phase in terms of the acceleration of the atom. The value of depends on the ratios and and on the time interval . Indeed increases for values of the acceleration which approach ; that is . Moreover, is detectable when . Therefore a crucial role is played by the choice of the atomic systems used in the interferometer. Moreover, depends on ; it reaches the maximum value for . We consider an initial state with angle and, in order to decrease the value of the acceleration, we consider the hyperfine level structure of different atoms.

In Figure 1 we plot the difference of geometric phase as function of the acceleration for different systems.

The (blue) dashed line in the inset of the figure is obtained considering the energy splitting between the levels and of the ground state of ( is the total atomic angular momentum, with total electron angular momentum and total nuclear angular momentum). For this system one has  GHz, and we considered the transition for which  MHz [52]. A similar plot is obtained if we consider the transition for which  MHz [52]. We derive the (red) dot dashed line in the inset by studying the energy splitting between the levels and of the line of . In this case,  GHz and we consider the transition with  MHz [53]. Similar plot can be derived in the case of the transition with  MHz [53]. Such plots show that a phase is obtained for accelerations of order of 1017 m/s2 and the times of order of , (inset of Figure 1). For such time interval, the speed of the atoms is of order of and the spontaneous emission can be neglected, since . The values of the phases obtained are accessible with the current technology.

Better results can be also obtained by considering other splitting between the levels of the , and the energy splitting between the levels of the , as shown in the main pictures of Figure 1. Here, the (gray) dot dashed line represents for the energy splitting between the and levels of the . In this case,  MHz and  MHz [53]. The (green) solid line is achieved by considering the line splitting between the and levels of . For this system,  MHz and  MHz [54]. In these cases can be achieved for accelerations of order of 1016 m/s2 and speeds of order of , as shown in the main plots of Figure 1 and one has .

We now analyze the characteristic of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer able to reveal the geometric phase (28) related to the Unruh effect. The geometric phase can be detected when the dynamical phase is negligible compared with the geometric one. The total phase, for the accelerated and for the inertial atoms, is given in terms of the geometric phase by the formula where the second term on the right side is the dynamical phase.

We note that the dynamic phases can be made negligible compared to the geometric ones, if the branches of the interferometer are built in order that the two dynamical phases are almost equal; that is In this case the difference of total phases detected in the cross point of the interferometer corresponds almost completely to the difference of geometric phases ; that is . For example, by considering as two-level system the energy splitting between the and levels of , and an acceleration of order of 5 × 1016 m/s2, one has that, in an interferometer with branches of length of 4 cm, the dynamical phase differences can be completely neglected when in such interferometer there is a difference in the arm lengths of about 0.1 μm.

5. Quantum Thermometer

In this section we consider the interaction of an atom with thermal states. A geometric phase identical to the one in (29) appears also in this case. The analysis of the geometric phase (29) in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer could allow very precise measurement of the temperature.

For thermal states, the coefficients and are replaced by the coefficients and depending on the temperature [5], , and .

Thus an interferometer in which an atom follows two different paths and interacts with two thermal states at different temperatures can represent a very precise quantum thermometer. Indeed, if the reference temperature of one thermal state is known, the temperature of the other one can be defined by measuring the difference between the geometric phases generated in the two paths.

For example, by measuring , one can derive precise estimations of the temperature of the colder source, if the temperature of the hotter source is known.

We consider the hyperfine structure of atoms and we plot in Figure 2   as function of the temperatures of cold sources , for different , and lines and values. In such a figure, the (blue) dashed line is obtained for the energy splitting between the levels and of the line of . In this case  MHz and  MHz [54] and we considered a reference temperature  K. The (red) dot-dashed line represents for the transition of the line of , for which  MHz and  MHz [53]. A value of  K has been taken into account. We derive the (gray) solid line by considering  K and the splitting between and levels of the line of , for which  MHz and  MHz [54]. Moreover, we obtain the (black) dotted line by analyzing the transition of the line of . In this case  GHz,  MHz [54], and  K.

The time considered is  s in order that the particle decay can be neglected. The result we obtain is that, considering the hyperfine structure of the atoms, one can measure temperatures of the cold source of ~2 orders of magnitude below the reference temperature of the hot source.

In [47] the Berry phase generated by an atom coupled just to a single mode of a quantum field within a cavity is studied. Here we have studied the role of the geometric phase in the realistic case of the nonunitary evolution of specific atoms interacting with thermal states. Notice that any quantum system interacting with an external field is an open system. Therefore, what is really needed is the analysis of a geometric phase, such as the one in (29), which is defined for mixed states with nonunitary evolution. Moreover, the phase equation (29), contrarily to the Berry phase and its generalization to the mixed state [37], covers the case of noncyclic and nonadiabatic evolution; therefore we are not forced to consider time intervals equal to the period, but we can consider times arbitrarily small, in order to have negligible spontaneous decay in such intervals for the energy level splitting analyzed. Also in this case, paths of slightly different lengths can be chosen in order to let the geometric phase be dominating over the relative dynamical phase.

Our results are thus realistic and new since they refer to specific atoms and their effective nonunitary evolution.

6. Conclusions

We have shown that all the phenomena where vacuum condensates appear generate geometric phases in their time evolution. In particular, we have analyzed the geometric phase for mixed state with a nonunitary evolution for a two-level atom system. We have shown that atoms with hyperfine structure of the energy levels, as for example , accelerated in an interferometer with branches of length of 4 cm and a difference in the branch lengths of 0.1 μm could represent an efficient tool in the laboratory detection of the Unruh effect. On the other hand, we have shown that similar atoms interacting with two different thermal states can be utilized in an interferometer to build a very precise quantum thermometer.

Appendix

Vacuum Condensate and AAI

In this Appendix, for the reader’s convenience we summarize briefly how the presence of the AAI occurs [5] in all the phenomena in which the vacuum condensate appears [112]. For these systems, the physically relevant states , (, with some physically relevant parameter) have indeed nonzero energy variance, , and AAI is given by with . Here and are the Bogoliubov coefficients entering in the transformation , with original state and generator of the Bogoliubov transformation: and depend on the system one considers and satisfy the relation , with + for fermions and − for bosons.

Notice that the vacuum state for such systems is related to the original one by the relation, . Therefore, (1) shows that all the phenomena characterized by the presence of modifications of vacuum fluctuations (which are all described by Bogoliubov transformations) are also characterized by the presence of the geometric phase in their evolution.

For example, in the case of the Unruh effect, the Bogoliubov coefficients that allow to express the Minkowski vacuum in terms of Rindler states are for bosons and and similar for fermions. Here is the acceleration of the observer. The relation between the Minkowski and Rindler vacua in the case of a single scalar field [55] is where and refer to modes supported in the right and left Rindler wedges, respectively.

Conflict of Interests

The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper.

Acknowledgment

Partial financial support from MIUR and INFN is acknowledged.