Application of the Conditional Nonlinear Optimal Perturbations Method in the Shallow Lake Ecological Degradation and Restoration

Table 3

CNOP-I, CNOP-P, CNOP, and (CNOP-I, CNOP-P) corresponding to different ground states and the corresponding objective function values, where obj means the objective function values.

Basic state			CNOP-I	CNOP-P	CNOP	(CNOP-I, CNOP-P)
CES A	0.8	1.0	(−0.772944, 0.206295)	−1.0	(−0.756869, 0.259131, 1.0)	(−0.772944, 0.206295, −1.0)
obj			0.89778821	0.11352425	0.99494645	0.79613468
TES B	1.5	1.0	(0.424979, −1.438538)	−1.0	(0.468807, −1.424858, −1.0)	(0.424979, −1.438538, −1.0)
obj			1.65155171	0.63125732	2.28696025	2.28461456
CES C	0.45	1.0	(−0.426888, 0.142361)	−1.0	(−0.413473, 0.177594, 1.0)	(−0.426888, 0.142361, −1.0)
obj			0.48494774	0.11790117	0.58937605	0.38767470
TES D	1.5	2.0	(0.956400, −1.155551)	2.0	(0.981794, −1.134055, −2.0)	(0.956400, −1.155551, 2.0)
obj			3.11289007	1.03696634	4.11767312	2.07934424