Advances in Orthopedic Surgery / 2016 / Article / Tab 2 / Research Article
Reducing Shoulder by Vertical Traction: A One-Man Method for Shoulder Reduction Table 2 Table showing various studies conducted so far by various authors using different techniques. Only studies having fifty (
) or more cases have been included.
Study type Reduction method Year Author No. of patients Success rate Complications Without premedication Case series Snow bird looped technique 1995 Westin et al. [4 ] 118 114 (97%) 0% 93% Case series Autoreduction 1997 Ceroni et al. [9 ] 100 60 (60%) 0% 70% Case series Milch 1981 Russell et al. [10 ] 76 68 (89%) 0% 69% Case series Milch 1982
Janecki and Shahcheragh [6 ] 50 50 (100%) 0% 34% RCT Milch 1986 Beattie et al. [11 ] 56 39 (70%) 0% NA Case series Milch 1992 Johnson et al. [12 ] 142 122 (86%) 0% 73% Case series
Modified Milch 1989 Canales Cortés et al. [13 ] 128 107 (84%) NA 33% Case series Modified Milch 1992 Garnavos [14 ] 75 71 (95%) 0% 100% RCT Kocher 1986 Beattie et al. [11 ] 55 40 (73%) 2% NA Case series External rotation 1977 Leidelmeyer [15 ] 50 50 (100%) 0% 0% Case series External rotation 1979 Mirick et al. [16 ] 85 68 (80%) 0% NA Case series External rotation 1986 Danzl et al. [17 ] 100 78 (78%) 1% 0% Case series Scapular manipulation 1982 Anderson et al. [18 ] 51 47 (92) 0% 34% Case series
Scapular manipulation-seated 1993 McNamara [19 ] 61 48 (79%) 0% 64% Present study Spaso technique 2013-2014 Khan et al. 60 100% 0% 91.67%