Bacterial Infections and Their Antibiotic Resistance Pattern in Ethiopia: A Systematic Review
Background. Antibiotic resistance is a global challenge in the public health sector and also a major challenge in Ethiopia. It is truly difficult to report bacterial antibiotic resistance pattern in Ethiopia due to the absence of a review which is done comprehensively. The aim of this systematic review was to provide an overview of the works of literature on the antibiotic resistance pattern of the specific bacterial isolates that can be obtained from different clinical samples in the context of Ethiopia. Materials and Methods. A web-based search using PubMed, Google Scholar, Hinari, Sci Hub, Scopus and the Directory of Open Access Journals was conducted from April to May 2018 for published studies without restriction in the year of publication. Works of literature potentially relevant to the study were identified by Boolean search technique using various keywords: Bacterial infection, antimicrobial resistance, antibiotic resistance, drug resistance, drug susceptibility, anti-bacterial resistance, Ethiopia. Study that perform susceptibility test from animal or healthy source using <10 isolates and methods other than prospective cross-sectional were excluded. Results. The database search delivered a total of 3459 studies. After amendment for duplicates and inclusion and exclusion criteria, 39 articles were found suitable for the systematic review. All studies were prospective cross-sectional in nature. The review encompasses 12 gram-positive and 15 gram-negative bacteria with their resistance pattern for around 12 antibiotics. It covers most of the regions which are found in Ethiopia. The resistance pattern of the isolates ranged from 0% up to 100%. The overall resistance of M. tuberculosis for antituberculosis drugs ranges from 0% up to 32.6%. The percentage of resistance increases among previously treated tuberculosis cases. Neisseria gonorrhea, S. typhimurium, S. Virchow, Group A Streptococci (GAS), and Group B Streptococci (GBS) were highly susceptible for most of the tested antibiotics. Methicillin-Resistant Staphylococcus aureus was highly resistant to most of the antibiotics with a slightly increased susceptibility to gentamycin. Conclusions. Total bacterial isolates obtained from a different source of sample and geographic areas were 28, including M. tuberculosis. Majority of the bacterial isolates were resistant to commonly used antibiotics. A continuous monitoring and studies on the multidrug-resistant bacterial isolates are important measures.
Human beings have been living unfriendly with a lot of microorganisms that can be a potential cause of infections and diseases. In the case of bacterial infections, due to the introduction of Penicillin for treatment in the early 1940s, there was an improvement . Majority of naturally derived antibiotics are produced from Actinomycetes [2, 3]. In this day, even though the struggle to defeat bacterial pathogens continues, bacteria are evolving ever more clever by manifesting different forms of resistance .
The current antimicrobial profile studies have been proved that, bacteria that can cause nosocomial as well as community acquired infections become pan resistant for different groups of antibiotics. Hence, this situation becomes a clinical threat to the human beings [5–13]. Most of the bacterial antibiotic resistance mechanisms are acquired by altering of target genes or acquisition of plasmid encoding resistance genes. These encoded genes may lead to the production of lytic enzymes, change of membrane permeability, efflux action, and hiding from the action of antibiotics .
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) stated that antibiotic resistance is responsible for around 2 million infections, more than twenty thousand deaths and, costs $55 billion each year in the United States . The national pharmaceutical sales data on global antibiotic consumption (2000-2010) reveals that total antibiotic consumption grew by more than 30%. The greatest increase in antibiotics use was recorded in Low and Middle Income Countries (LMIC) .
As long as Ethiopia is one of the LMICs, antibiotic resistance is a major challenge. Yet, there is no antibiotic stewardship that helps to establish surveillance system for tracking current antibiotic use and its resistance in Ethiopia. Therefore, it is truly difficult to report bacterial antibiotic resistance pattern in Ethiopia. So, the aim of this systematic review emphasizes on the antibiotic resistance pattern of the specific bacterial isolates that can be obtained from different clinical samples in the context of Ethiopia.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Eligibility Criteria
All available studies and data were incorporated based on the following predefined eligibility criteria:(1)should be published and written in English,(2)had to describe the microbial isolation, identification, and antimicrobial sensitivity test methods according to the criteria of the Clinical Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI) and defined antimicrobial resistance range according to CLSI manual,(3)studies which used human infection sample (isolated from a diseased individual),(4)had to report the number of tested isolates (>10) and the number of isolates resistant or sensitive,(5)should be a prospective cross-sectional study.
2.2. Study Selection Procedure and Search
The search and selection of eligible studies were shown in Figure 1. To make it more elaborative; a web-based search using PubMed, Google Scholar, Hinari, Sci Hub, Scopus, and the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) was conducted from April to May 2018 and pieces of literature potentially relevant to the study were identified. The search was performed using various keywords: Bacterial infection, antimicrobial resistance, antibiotic resistance, drug resistance, drug susceptibility, anti-bacterial resistance, Ethiopia. These key terms were used in various combinations using Boolean search technique. The search was not limited to the year of publication.
Relevant search results from the above site were individually downloaded and the reference lists of the identified studies were used to scrutinize to identify extra articles.
2.3. Data Extraction
Essential data were extracted from eligible studies using Excel spreadsheet format prepared for this purpose and any discrepancies were resolved by the author. The data extracted from eligible studies include the name of regions, study area/city, the name of the author(s), year of the study, study design, types of specimens, numbers of patients/study participants, number of resistant isolates, resistance pattern of the isolates, and references.
3.1. Literature Search Results
The search from PubMed, Google Scholar, Hinari, Sci Hub, Scopus, and DOAJ delivered a total of 3459 studies. After amendment for duplicates, 901 endured. Of these, 780 studies were castoff, since, after a review of their titles and abstracts, they did not meet the criteria. The full texts of the remaining 121 studies were reviewed in detail. Of these, 85 studies were discarded after the full text had been reviewed for appropriate study method, sample source, number of isolates, and standard bacteriological test. Finally, 39 studies were included in the review (Figure 1).
3.2. Antibiotic Resistance for Gram-Positive Bacteria
The review tries to encompass 12 gram-positive bacteria and their resistance pattern for around 12 antibiotics. It covers most of the regions which are found in Ethiopia. The resistance pattern of the isolates ranged from 0% up to 100%. GAS and GBS were highly susceptible for most of the tested antibiotics, but they have a relatively increased resistance to tetracycline. In contrast with these, MRSA was highly resistant for most of the antibiotics with a slightly increased susceptibility to gentamycin. The rest bacterial isolates have a different resistance pattern for different antibiotics and also a variable pattern from sample to sample (Table 1). The average resistance pattern of gram-positive bacteria shows a cumulative antibiotic resistance pattern of bacterial isolates from different clinical cases, geographic location, and source of sample for a similar antibiotic. Still, the average resistance range of the gram-positive bacteria is similar with the detailed resistance pattern (Figure 2).
3.3. Antibiotic Resistance for Gram-Negative Bacteria
Fifteen gram-negative bacteria were recovered from various specimens. Like the gram-positive bacteria, the resistance pattern ranges from 0% up to 100%. Almost all bacterial isolates were highly resistant for ampicillin. Relatively, isolates obtained from conjunctival swab were highly susceptible to different antibiotics. Neisseria gonorrhea, S. typhimurium, and S. Virchow were susceptible for many antibiotics. Moraxella spp. and S. Virchow had a similar resistance pattern for different antibiotics, even if the number of isolates varies between the two (Table 2). The average resistance pattern of gram-negative bacteria shows a cumulative antibiotic resistance pattern of bacterial isolates from different clinical cases, geographic location, and source of sample for a similar antibiotic. Still, the average resistance range of the gram-negative bacteria is similar with the detailed resistance pattern (Figure 3).
3.4. Drug Resistance of M. tuberculosis
The overall resistance of M. tuberculosis for antituberculosis drugs ranges from 0% up to 32.6%. The percentage of resistance increases among previously treated tuberculosis cases. New pulmonary and extra-pulmonary cases relatively had decreased resistance for antituberculosis drugs (Table 3).
Our results indicate that the antibiotic resistance pattern of both gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria varied across the studies reviewed, ranging from 0% to 100%. This variation was found depending on the type of isolate, the source of the sample, type of infection, type of antibiotics, and geographical difference used in each study.
Even though it is difficult to discuss average resistance pattern of gram positive and gram negative bacteria with a single study for various antibiotics, a study done in Nigeria revealed that gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria had a resistance pattern of 19.8%-92.3% and 10%-87%, respectively . And also a study in Gondar, Northwest Ethiopia, showed 20%–100% and 23.5%–58.8% for gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria, respectively . If we look at the overall resistance pattern of the above studies, it ranges from 10% to 100%. This was relatively comparable to the current review result.
A systematic review done on antimicrobial resistance in Sub-Saharan Africa (1990–2013) has been reported that Gram-positive pathogens show high prevalence of resistance to chloramphenicol, trimethoprim/sulfamethoxazole, and tetracycline and gram negative bacteria specifically the enterobacteriaceae groups show resistance to chloramphenicol, isolated from patients with a febrile illness, ranged between 31.0% and 94.2%, whereas resistance to third-generation cephalosporins ranged between 0.0% and 46.5% .
The current review revealed that majority of the bacterial isolates are resistant to commonly used antibiotics in Ethiopia [19–54]. The possible reason might be related to scientific justifications like the following: numerous antibacterial agents, effective previously, are no longer used today because of the rise of resistance genes in the bacterial genome . The emergence of resistance genes can be through natural selection in the environment over a long period of time or by a spontaneous mutation in the bacterial DNA. The resistant pattern has been reported by almost all antibiotics that have been developed .
5. Limitations of the Study
Most of the studies done in Ethiopia do not document the antibiogram; due to this we were unable to review and extract data related to multidrug resistance.
The main result of this study is to obtain an internationally valid reference to know the antibiotic resistance pattern in Ethiopia. The review encompasses 12 gram-positive bacteria and their resistance pattern for around 12 antibiotics. It covers most of the regions which are found in Ethiopia. The resistance pattern of the isolates ranged from 0% up to 100%. Fifteen gram-negative bacteria were recovered from various specimens. Like the gram-positive bacteria, the resistance pattern ranges from 0% up to 100%. Almost all bacterial isolates were highly resistant for ampicillin. Relatively, isolates obtained from conjunctival swab were highly susceptible to different antibiotics. Neisseria gonorrhea, S. typhimurium, and S. Virchow were susceptible for many antibiotics. The overall resistance of M. tuberculosis for antituberculosis drugs ranges from 0% up to 32.6%. Given the limitations of the current study, these findings should be interpreted carefully but warrant further evaluation in consequent studies.
Our study provides evidence that majority of the bacterial isolates were resistant to commonly used antibiotics. Antibiotic resistance should be a substantial concern for Ethiopia as well as for all countries around the globe. So to alleviate such problems and to advance the effectiveness of antibiotics in Ethiopia, the government of Ethiopia as well as the international community should do the following:(i)Prepare the guidelines for proper use of antibiotics in the health institutions.(ii)Establish antimicrobial resistance stewardship.(iii)Increase proper immunization coverage that may reduce the use of antibiotics.(iv)Implement one health policy (reduce antimicrobial use for agricultural practice and animals).(v)Create community awareness on rational use of drugs.(vi)Make strong policy for antibiotic dispensing by drug venders.(vii)Control Hospital and community acquired infections.(viii)Ensure political commitment to meet the threat of antibiotic resistance.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Alemayehu Reta carried out interpretation of data, drafted the manuscript, revised it critically for important intellectual content, and gave final approval of the version to be published. Abebaw Bitew Kifilie revised it critically and searched literatures. Abeba Mengist revised it critically and searched literatures. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
We would like to acknowledge Debre Markos University Digital Library staffs for their contribution during article searching.
F. C. Tenover, “Mechanisms of antimicrobial resistance in bacteria,” American Journal of Infection Control, vol. 34, no. 5, pp. S3–S10, 2006.View at: Google Scholar
R. J. Fair and Y. Tor, “Antibiotics and bacterial resistance in the 21st century,” Perspectives in Medicinal Chemistry, vol. 28, no. 6, pp. 25–64, 2014 (Arabic).View at: Google Scholar
M. Otto, “Staphylococcus epidermidisthe accidental pathogenInt,” Journal of Antimicrobial Agents, vol. 29, pp. S23–S32, 2009.View at: Google Scholar
S. Schaefler, “Staphylococcus epidermidis BV: antibiotic resistance patterns, physiological characteristics, and bacteriophage susceptibility.,” Journal of Applied Microbiology, vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 693–699, 1971.View at: Google Scholar
S. Muthupandian, R. Balajee, and H. Barabadi, “The prevalence and drug resistance pattern of extended spectrum β–lactamases (ESBLs) producing enterobacteriaceae in Africa,” Microbial Pathogenesis, 2017.View at: Google Scholar
S. J. Leopold, F. van Leth, H. Tarekegn, and C. Schultsz, “Antimicrobial drug resistance among clinically relevant bacterial isolates in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review,” Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, vol. 69, no. 9, Article ID dku176, pp. 2337–2353, 2014.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
L. A. Dever and T. S. Dermody, “Mechanisms of bacterial resistance to antibiotics,” Archives of internal medicine, vol. 151, no. 5, pp. 886–895, 1991.View at: Google Scholar
Health UDo and H. Services, Antibiotic Resistance Threats in The United States, 2013, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Georgia, Ga, USA, 2013.
A. O. Komolafe and A. A. Adegoke, “Incidence of bacterial septicaemia in Ile-Ife metropolis, Nigeria,” Malaysian Journal of Microbiology, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 51–61, 2008.View at: Google Scholar
A. Alemu, F. Moges, Y. Shiferaw et al., “Bacterial profile and drug susceptibility pattern of urinary tract infection in pregnant women at university of gondar teaching hospital, Northwest Ethiopia,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 5, article 197, no. 1, 2012.View at: Google Scholar
J. L. Martínez, T. M. Coque, and F. Baquero, “What is a resistance gene? ranking risk in resistomes,” Nature Reviews Microbiology, pp. 1–8, 2014.View at: Google Scholar
A. Assefa, B. Gelaw, Y. Shiferaw, and Z. Tigabu, “Nasopharyngeal carriage and antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of streptococcus pneumoniae among pediatric outpatients at gondar university hospital, north west ethiopia,” Pediatrics and Neonatology, vol. 54, no. 5, pp. 315–321, 2013.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
T. Tesfaye, G. Beyene, Y. Gelaw, S. Bekele, and M. Saravanan, “Bacterial profile and antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of external ocular infections in jimma university specialized hospital, Southwest Ethiopia,” American Journal of Infectious Diseases and Microbiology, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 13–20, 2013.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
T. Aweke, G. Dibaba, K. Ashenafi, and M. Kebede, “Bacterial pathogens of exterior ocular infections and their antibiotic vulnerability pattern in southern Ethiopia,” African Journal of Immunology Research, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 019–025, 2014.View at: Google Scholar
A. G. Wasihun, L. N. Wlekidan, S. A. Gebremariam et al., “Bacteriological profile and antimicrobial susceptibility patterns of blood culture isolates among febrile patients in mekelle hospital, Northern Ethiopia,” SpringerPlus, vol. 4, article 314, no. 1, 2015.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
H. Legese, A. G. Kahsay, A. Kahsay et al., “Nasal carriage, risk factors and antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus among healthcare workers in Adigrat and Wukro hospitals, Tigray, Northern Ethiopia,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 11, no. 1, article 250, 2018.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. Deyno, A. Toma, M. Worku, and M. Bekele, “Antimicrobial resistance profile of Staphylococcus aureus isolates isolated from ear discharges of patients at University of Hawassa comprehensive specialized hospital,” BMC Pharmacology & Toxicology, vol. 18, article 35, 2017.View at: Google Scholar
M. Mama, A. Abdissa, and T. Sewunet, “Antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of bacterial isolates from wound infection and their sensitivity to alternative topical agents at jimma university specialized hospital, South-West Ethiopia,” Annals of Clinical Microbiology and Antimicrobials, vol. 13, article 14, no. 1, 2014.View at: Google Scholar
M. Dagnew, G. Yismaw, M. Gizachew et al., “Bacterial profile and antimicrobial susceptibility pattern in septicemia suspected patients attending gondar university hospital, Northwest Ethiopia,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 6, no. 1, article 283, 2013.View at: Google Scholar
D. Muluye, Y. Wondimeneh, F. Moges, T. Nega, and G. Ferede, “Types and drug susceptibility patterns of bacterial isolates from eye discharge samples at gondar university hospital, Northwest Ethiopia,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 7, article 292, no. 1, 2014.View at: Google Scholar
R. E. Mengesha, B. G.-S. Kasa, M. Saravanan, D. F. Berhe, and A. G. Wasihun, “Aerobic bacteria in post surgical wound infections and pattern of their antimicrobial susceptibility in Ayder Teaching and Referral Hospital, Mekelle, Ethiopia,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 7, no. 1, article 575, 2014.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
M. Teweldemedhin, M. Saravanan, A. Gebreyesus, and D. Gebreegziabiher, “Ocular bacterial infections at quiha ophthalmic hospital, Northern Ethiopia: an evaluation according to the risk factors and the antimicrobial susceptibility of bacterial isolates,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 17, article 207, 2017.View at: Google Scholar
E. Getahun, B. Gelaw, A. Assefa, Y. Assefa, and A. Amsalu, “Bacterial pathogens associated with external ocular infections alongside eminent proportion of multidrug resistant isolates at the University of Gondar Hospital, northwest Ethiopia,” BMC Ophthalmology, vol. 17, article 151, 2017.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
T. Dilnessa and A. Bitew, “Prevalence and antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of methicillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus isolated from clinical samples at yekatit 12 hospital medical college, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 16, article 398, no. 1, 2016.View at: Google Scholar
A. Bitew, M. Tamirat, and M. Chanie, “Species distribution and antibiotic susceptibility profile of bacterial uropathogens among patients complaining urinary tract infections,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 17, article 654, 2017.View at: Google Scholar
A. Abdissa, D. Asrat, G. Kronvall et al., “Throat carriage rate and antimicrobial susceptibility pattern of group a streptococci (gas) in healthy Ethiopian school children,” Ethiopian Medical Journal, vol. 49, no. 2, pp. 125–130, 2011.View at: Google Scholar
A. Yilema, F. Moges, S. Tadele et al., “Isolation of enterococci, their antimicrobial susceptibility patterns and associated factors among patients attending at the university of gondar teaching hospital,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 17, article 276, 2017.View at: Google Scholar
A. Abamecha, B. Wondafrash, and A. Abdissa, “Antimicrobial resistance profile of Enterococcus species isolated from intestinal tracts of hospitalized patients in Jimma, ethiopia microbiology,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 8, articlec 213, 2015.View at: Google Scholar
G. Alemseged, S. Niguse, H. Hailekiros, M. Abdulkadir, M. Saravanan, and T. Asmelash, “Isolation and anti-microbial susceptibility pattern of group B Streptococcus among pregnant women attending antenatal clinics in ayder referral hospital and mekelle health center, Mekelle, Northern Ethiopia Health Services Research,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 8, article 518, 2015.View at: Google Scholar
M. Dereje, Y. Woldeamanuel, D. Asrat, and F. Ayenachew, “Urinary tract infection among fistula patients admitted at Hamlin fistula hospital, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 17, article 150, 2017.View at: Google Scholar
W. Mulu, M. Yimer, Y. Zenebe, and B. Abera, “Common causes of vaginal infections and antibiotic susceptibility of aerobic bacterial isolates in women of reproductive age attending at Felegehiwot referral Hospital, Ethiopia: a cross sectional study,” BMC Women's Health, vol. 15, article 42, 2015.View at: Google Scholar
T. Bekele, A. Tesfaye, T. Sewunet, and H. D. Waktola, “Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolates and their antimicrobial susceptibility pattern among catheterized patients at Jimma University Teaching Hospital, Jimma, Ethiopia,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 8, article 488, 2015.View at: Google Scholar
A. Tadesse, A. Mekonnen, A. Kassu, and T. Asmelash, “Antimicrobial sensitivity of Neisseria gonorrhoea in Gondar, Ethiopia,” East African Medical Journal, vol. 78, no. 5, pp. 259–261, 2001.View at: Google Scholar
S. Ali, T. Sewunet, Z. Sahlemariam, and G. Kibru, “Neisseria gonorrhoeae among suspects of sexually transmitted infection in Gambella hospital, Ethiopia: risk factors and drug resistance,” BMC Research Notes, vol. 9, article 439, 2016.View at: Google Scholar
T. Eguale, W. A. Gebreyes, D. Asrat, H. Alemayehu, J. S. Gunn, and E. Engidawork, “Non-typhoidal Salmonella serotypes, antimicrobial resistance and co-infection with parasites among patients with diarrhea and other gastrointestinal complaints in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 15, article 497, no. 1, 2015.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
J. Bruchfeld, G. Aderaye, I. B. Palme et al., “Molecular epidemiology and drug resistance of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates from ethiopian pulmonary tuberculosis patients with and without human immunodeficiency virus infection,” Journal of Clinical Microbiology, vol. 40, no. 5, pp. 1636–1643, 2002.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
S. A. Yimer, M. Agonafir, Y. Derese, Y. Sani, G. A. Bjune, and C. Holm-Hansen, “Primary drug resistance to anti-tuberculosis drugs in major towns of Amhara region, Ethiopia,” APMIS-Acta Pathologica, Microbiologica et Immunologica Scandinavica, vol. 120, no. 6, pp. 503–509, 2012.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar
W. Korma, A. Mihret, J. Hussien, R. Anthony, M. Lakew, and A. Aseffa, “Clinical, molecular and drug sensitivity pattern of mycobacterial isolates from extra-pulmonary tuberculosis cases in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia,” BMC Infectious Diseases, vol. 15, no. 1, article 456, 2015.View at: Publisher Site | Google Scholar