Research Article

Determining the Best Treatment for Coronal Angular Deformity of the Knee Joint in Growing Children: A Decision Analysis

Table 1

Definition of variables with baseline probabilities in the decision tree.

VariableTree definitionBaselineRangeStudies

Rate of outcomes after temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using stapling_staple_Cx0.2250.000~0.667 Pistevos and Duckworth [16], Zuege et al. [17], Fraser et al. [18], Mielke and Stevens [19], Stevens et al. [20], Raab et al. [8], Degreef et al. [21], Westberry et al. [9], Park et al. [10], Eidelman and D’Agostino [23], Stevens and Pease [11], Novais and Stevens [24], Castañeda et al. [27], Stevens and Klatt [12], Wiemann et al. [31], Courvoisier et al. [32], Bushnell et al. [33], Cho et al. [34], Shin et al. [36], Jelinek et al. [41], Gottliebsen et al. [42]
_staple_metal failure0.1080.000~0.453
_staple_incomplete correction0.1180.000~0.576
  _staple_incomplete
  correction_observation
0.0530.000~0.303
  _staple_incomplete
  correction_osteotomy
0.0640.000~0.273

Rate of outcomes after temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using screw_screw_Cx0.1480.000~0.333 Métaizeau et al. [5], Nouh and Kuo [22], Khoury et al. [25], Brauwer and Moens [28], Mesa and Yamhure [29], Shin et al. [36]
_screw_metal failure0.0000.000~0.000
_screw_incomplete correction0.1480.054~0.333
  _screw_incomplete
  correction_observation
0.0920.000~0.333
  _screw_incomplete
  correction_osteotomy
0.0560.000~0.115

Rate of outcomes after temporary hemiepiphysiodesis using tension band plate_plate_Cx0.0920.000~0.278 Stevens and Pease [11], Stevens [6], Stevens and Klatt [12], Burghardt et al. [26], Wiemann et al. [31], Schroerlucke et al. [30], Burghardt and Herzenberg [37], Ballal et al. [35], Guzman et al. [38], Boero et al. [39], Scott [40], Jelinek et al. [41], Gottliebsen et al. [42]
_plate_metal failure0.0420.000~0.258
_plate_incomplete correction0.0500.000~0.125
  _plate_incomplete
  correction_observation
0.0060.000~0.056
  _plate_incomplete
  correction_osteotomy
0.0440.000~0.103

: probability; Cx: complication.