Review Article

A Systematised Review of Primary School Whole Class Child Obesity Interventions: Effectiveness, Characteristics, and Strategies

Table 1

Summary of study methodology, main findings, and critical appraisal scores.

LocationStudy ID (author et al., year, intervention name, and citation number)Participants ()Intervention length (months)TheoryPrimarily delivered byStudy designStrategiesIntervention characteristicsCritical appraisal score (out of 27)

Canada, British ColumbiaStock et al., 2007, Healthy Buddies [38]36010N/ATeacher and older studentsNRCTED, PEducational intervention: older students received 45-minute healthy living lesson from the leader weekly; older students paired with younger students and taught the lesson to the younger students in 30-minute sessions, 21 lessons taught, school-wide healthy living theme day. Physical intervention: pairs participated in 30-min aerobic circuits twice a week and were encouraged to engage vigorously19

Chile,
Ñuñoa
Kain et al., 2014 [37]147112N/ATeachersRCTED, P, and PIEducational intervention: 8 lessons of HE education for students lasting 90 minutes each. Physical intervention: PE teachers were trained to increased time in PE as well as increased MVPA during PE. Parental involvement: motivational, instructional meetings with parents totaling 45 minutes21

England, Wigan BoroughFairclough et al., 2013, CHANGE! [39]3185Social Cognitive TheoryTeachersRCTED, PIEducational intervention: teacher training; weekly lessons lasting 60 minutes of healthy lifestyle curriculum with HE and PA topics. Parental involvement: homework assignments involving parents22

England, northeastGorely et al., 2009 GreatFun2Run [35]58910Social Cognitive TheoryTeachersNRCTEN, ED, P, and PIEnvironmental intervention: local media campaign, running event promotion. Educational intervention: HE and PA components across the curriculum, interactive website. Physical intervention: PE centered around running. Parental involvement: an interactive website was available to parents highlighting the importance of HE and PA, child homework assignments to be completed with parents, information and child PA planner provided19

England, southwestKipping et al., 2014, Active for Life Year 5 (AFLY5) [40]21236Social Cognitive TheoryTeachersRCTED, PIEducational intervention: 16 lesson plans for PA and HE were delivered over the course of 2-3 school terms. Information on HE and PA was provided to schools intended for newsletters. Parental involvement: interactive homework assignments were given intended to be completed with parents and other family members; information on HE and PA was provided to schools intended for parents22

Greece, IoanninaAngelopoulos et al., 2009, CHILDREN Study [36]64612Theory of Planned BehaviourTeachersRCTEN, ED, P, and PIEnvironmental intervention: access to playgrounds. Fruits and fresh fruit juice were available in the school canteen.
Educational intervention: cross-curricular approach across science, environmental, and PE curriculums; 1-2 hours each week and covered HE and PA topics.
Approaches utilized to facilitate behaviour change are discussion, active learning, cues, modelling, guided practice, enactment, problem solving, goal setting, self-reevaluation, environmental reevaluation, arguments, direct experience, and mobilizing social support. Physical intervention: two 45-minute activity sessions during PE each week at a moderate intensity with a focus on fun. Parental involvement: take home assignments to be completed with guardians; parents were encouraged to make fruit and fresh fruit juice available at home; school events involving the family were also held as tasting sessions of different fruits and vegetables
19

Netherlands, Rotterdam Jansen et al., 2011, Lekker fit [42]26228Theory of Planned Behaviour; Ecological Model of Egger and SwinburnTeachers/PE teachersRCTED, P, and PIEducational intervention: health education curriculum including 3 lessons focused on HE, active living, and healthy lifestyle choices. Physical intervention: 3 PE lessons a week taught by a PE teacher; additional activities and sports coordinated with local sports clubs were offered outside school hours on a volunteer basis. Parental involvement: a fitness report card was sent home to parents including child’s weight status, as well as annual health promotion events with local sports clubs18

New Zealand, OtagoTaylor et al., 2007, APPLE [32]73024N/ACommunity activity coordinatorsNRCTEN, PEnvironmental intervention: installed water coolers; new sport and games equipment being supplied; and discouraged SSBs and encouraged intake of fruits and vegetables. Physical intervention: encouraged PA at lunch, recess, and after school through introduction of new games, sports, and activities. Resources were given to teachers to incorporate activity in class19

New
Zealand, Waikato
Rush et al., 2012, Project Energize [43]135223N/ATeachers, supported by exercise and nutrition specialistsRCTEN, ED, P, and PIEnvironmental intervention: specialists promoted active transport, active lunch, and peer leadership of PA outside of school; modifications to the canteen were made to provide healthier snacks; healthy fundraising options were also provided to teachers. Educational intervention: children received classroom lessons on HE during the same 3 weeks their parents attended nutrition sessions. Physical intervention: specialists supported teachers by modelling fundamental movement skills, ball games, fitness activities, and sport games and emphasized keeping all children moving throughout the sessions; teachers were also supported on how to manage children during activity sessions. Parental involvement: 3 information sessions were delivered to parents which included a practical nutrition session19

Norway, southeastGrydeland et al., 2013, Grydeland et al., 2014, and Bergh et al., 2012, HEIA [2830]152820Social Ecological TheoryTeachersRCTEN, ED, P, and PIEnvironmental intervention: active commute to school campaign, new sporting equipment. Educational intervention: classroom lessons about PA and dietary behaviours once a month; classroom posters; and computer programme for 7th graders regarding healthy behaviours. Physical intervention: weekly classroom PA breaks for 10 minutes, training of teachers for PE. Parental involvement: parent information sheet23

Portugal Rosário et al., 2012 [41]2946Health Promotion Model; Social Cognitive TheoryTeachersRCTEDEducational intervention: nutrition intervention with a PA education component; teachers trained by researchers (36 hours) on intervention delivery and delivery to students (36 hours). 12 lessons included topics such as HE for children, drinking water, fruit and vegetables, foods with low nutritional quality, PA, screen time, and cooking healthy meals21

Spain, Reus, Cambrils, Salou, and Vila-secaTarro et al., 2014, Education in Alimentation (EdAl) [31]193936N/AUndergraduate medical studentsRCTED, PIEducational intervention: 8 healthy lifestyle topics—advancing healthy lifestyles, drinking healthy drinks and avoiding SSBs, improving vegetable and legume intake, eating more fruits and nuts and decreasing high sugar/high fat snacks, promoting healthy habits (PA, home meals), and increasing fruit, dairy, and fish consumption; lessons were delivered in four 1-hour education and activity sessions each year over the course of 3 years for a total of 12 sessions and were not a part of the curriculum; corresponding booklets were used by teachers throughout the year. Parental involvement: similar activities children participated in that were included in the educational booklet children participated in were intended for parents also21

Spain, GranollersLlargues et al., 2011, Avall [33]50924Investigation, Vision, Action, and Change (IVAC) methodologyTeachersRCTEN, ED, and PIEnvironmental intervention: sport/games equipment provided to school. Parental involvement: healthy recipes were given to families on a monthly basis as well as literature about local facilities and paths for physical activity19

United States, LouisianaWilliamson et al., 2012, LA Health Project [34]206028N/ATeachers + internet programmeRCTEN, EDEnvironmental intervention: modifications were made to cafeteria food and vending machines to increase fruit and vegetables and decrease fat; the PA environmental component included changes to PE curriculum with aims of increasing MVPA to at least 60 minutes/day and decreasing screen time to <2 hours each day. Educational intervention: the environment + education group received an internet based education programme and classroom instruction during class time21

United States, South Dakota Story et al., 2012, Bright Start [56]45424N/AOnly environmentalRCTEN, P, and PIEnvironmental intervention: modifications were made to cafeteria offerings of low-fat foods, low-fat nonflavoured milk, serve recommended portion sizes, increase fruit and vegetable availability and only gave 2nd helpings of fruit and vegetables; teachers limited snacks in the classroom to low-fat and low-sugar foods, and children were encouraged to drink water instead of SSBs. Physical intervention: each child received 60 minutes of PA each day during school hours (walks outside, modifications to PE, active classroom breaks, and active recess). Parental involvement: home environment, family nights, newsletters, and motivational telephone calls22

RCT = randomised controlled trial.
NRCT = nonrandomised controlled trial.
EN = environmental.
ED = educational.
P = physical.
PA = physical activity.
HE = healthy eating.
PI = parental involvement.
= three different studies using the same dataset.