Review Article

Chronic Effects of Resistance Training in Breast Cancer Survivors

Table 3

Characteristics of resistance training protocols in the analysed studies.

StudyExercisesTraining loadWeekly frequencyVolume (sets × repetitions)Rest intervalSession durationSupervision ratioTraining progression

Ahmed et al. [52]9 exercises involving arms, back, chest, buttocks, and legs.Upper body exercises load starting at 0.5 lb, and 8–10 RM for lower body exercises2x3 × 8–10~60 minFirst 3 months at 1 : 4; then there was no supervision or it was 1 : 2.

Brown et al. [40]Seated row, chest press, lateral or front raise, bicep curl, triceps pushdown, leg press, back extension, leg extension, and leg curl.2x2-3 × 1090 minFirst 3 months supervised, followed by 9 months with no supervision.Exercise load was slowly increased if there were no lymphedema symptoms.

Hagstrom et al. [53]Programme 1:
leg extension, leg curl or Romanian deadlift, lat. pull down, machine bench press, seated row, back extension, prone hold, or sit ups.
Programme 2:
barbell squat, deadlift, free weight barbell bench press, leg press, bent over barbell row, and assisted chin up
8 RM3x3 × 8–1060 min1 : 1 or 1 : 2–5.Load was increased when subjects performed 10 RM.

Hagstrom et al. [41]Programme 1: leg extension, leg curl or Romanian deadlift, lat. pull down, machine bench press, seated row, back extension, prone hold, or sit-ups. Programme 2: barbell squat, deadlift, free weight barbell bench press, leg press, barbell bent over row, and assisted chin up.8 RM3x3 × 8–1060 min1 : 1 or 1 : 2–5.Exercise load was increased when subjects performed 10 RM.

Ohira et al. [54]9 exercises involving chest, back, shoulders, arms, buttocks, hips, and thighs.According to Schmitz 2005According to Schmitz 2005According to Schmitz 2005According to Schmitz 2005According to Schmitz 2005First 3 months at 1 : 4; then there was no supervision or it was 1 : 2.According to Schmitz 2005

Schmitz et al. [42]Seated row, supine dumbbell press, lateral or front raises, biceps curl, and triceps pushdown, leg press, back extension, leg extension, and leg curl.2x3 × 1090 min13 weeks in small groups, followed by no supervision.Exercise load was slowly increased when subjects completed 2 training sessions with no change in arm symptoms.

Schmitz et al. [43]9 exercises involving chest, back, shoulders, arms, buttocks, hips, and thighs.Upper body exercises load starting with no weight or at 0.5 lb and 8–10 RM for lower body exercises2x3 × 8–10~60 min13 weeks at small groups, followed by no supervision.Upper body load: progressed as symptoms allowed. Lower body: weight was increased if subjects could perform 10 repetitions at each two sessions for the first 3 months. For the remaining months, participants increased the weight after four sessions during which they lifted the same weight for 10, 10, and 12 repetitions in each set.

Schmitz et al. [55]Seated row, supine dumbbell press, lateral or front raises, biceps curl, and triceps pushdown, leg press, back extension, leg extension, and leg curl.2x3 × 1090 min13 weeks at 1 : 2–6, followed by no supervision.Exercise load was slowly increased when subjects completed 2 training sessions with no change in arm symptom.

Speck et al. [56]Seated row, supine dumbbell press, lateral or front raises, bicep curls, and triceps pushdowns, leg press, back extension, leg extension, and leg curl.2x3 × 1090 min13 weeks at 1 : 2–6, followed by no supervision.Exercise load was slowly increased when subjects completed 2 training sessions with no change in arm symptom.

Waltman, et al. [57]Biceps curl, overhead triceps or press and upward row, back and knee extension, side hip raise, and hip flexion and extension.2x2 × 8–12Strength training took place in subject homes using free weights the first 9 months of the study, and at fitness centres the last 15 months.Potential goals for progressive training were increases in weights of 20% the first 3 months of exercises, 10% at 6 and 9 months, 5% at 12, 15, and 18 months, and 3% at 21 and 24 months.

RM, repetition maximum.