A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on the Treatment of Cerebral Hemorrhage with NaoXueShu Oral Liquid

Table 1

Characteristics of included studies.

Study	Sample size (treatment/control)	Diagnosis	Intervention		Treatment course	Clinical standards	Outcome measure
			Treatment	Control
Y. Yuan and D. Yuan 2012 [23]	60	CH	NaoXueShu + routine	Naoxuekang + Conventional treatment	30 days	The standard of TCM and Western medicine	Curative effect; hematoma absorption rate; integral value of neurological deficit; clinical symptom integral value of TCM
Wang et al. 2014 [24]	122	HICH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	4 weeks	CH + standards	GCS score; BI score; hematoma volume
Xie et al. 2007 [25]	440	HS	NaoXueShu	Naoxuekang	30 days	TCM diagnostic code (96)	stroke score; hematoma uptake; therapeutic effect
Miao and Yan 2014 [26]	69 (35 : 34)	HICH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	4 weeks	CH standards (95) + CT	NIHSS score and curative effect
Lu et al. 2004 [27]	140	HICH	NaoXueShu	Naoxuekang	1 month	Cranial CT	Changes in TCM syndrome score; NIH integral changes; intracranial hemorrhage
Wang and Zhao 2015 [16]	30	ACH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	1 month	WHO diagnostics; CT; diagnostic criteria of stroke in Chinese Medicine	Hematoma uptake; stroke diagnosis score, NIHSS; 3-month mRS
Gu and Ma 2010 [28]	62	CH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	1 month	CH standards	Neurological deficit score; clinical efficacy
Chen et al. 2016 [17]	67	HICH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	90 days	CT	Curative effect; hematoma volume change
Wang and Ding 2014 (2) [29]	86	CH	NaoXueShu + routine	Naoxuekang + Conventional treatment	1 month	Relevant standards of the Ministry of Health and criteria for diagnosis and treatment of stroke	Curative effect; hematoma volume change
Wang et al. 2016 [30]	96	HICH	NaoXueShu + acupuncture + routine	Acupuncture + routine	1 month	Guidelines for prevention and treatment of cerebrovascular diseases in China (2005)	NIHSS score; BI score
Wang et al. 2015 (2) [18]	102	Mixed stroke	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	4 weeks	CT and/or MRI	WAB score; mRS score; NIHSS score; hemorheological indicators; (blood viscosity, fibrin, red blood cell index)
Zhou et al. 2015 [20]	170	CH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	90 days	CT	ESS; Neurological deficit score; BI score
Li et al. 2014 [31]	76	HICH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	2 weeks	CT	GCS score; Neurological deficit score
Yang and Xue 2015 [21]	86	HICH	NaoXueShu + routine	Conventional treatment	4 weeks	CH standards (95)	NIHSS score; curative effect; hematoma