A Unified Level Set Framework Combining Hybrid Algorithms for Liver and Liver Tumor Segmentation in CT Images

Table 6

Comparison of the proposed method with state-of-the-art methods on the 3Dircadb dataset.

Method	Mode	Time	VOE	RVD	ASD	RMSD	MSD
Moghbel et al. [14]	Auto	30s/slice	22.812.2	8.618.8	N/A	N/A	N/A
Sun et al. [17]	Auto	1s/slice	15.64.3	5.83.5	2.00.9	2.91.5	7.16.2
Wu et al. [24]	Semi	45s	29.08.2	-2.215.9	0.70.3	1.10.5	4.33.0
Li et al. [30]	Semi	N/A	14.45.3	8.12.1	2.40.8	2.90.7	7.23.1
Foruzan et al. [46]	Semi	154s	30.610.4	16.012.0	4.29.6	5.110.7	12.617.1
Li et al. [47]	Auto	30s-200s	11.74.3	-0.00.1	0.60.5	1.92.3	N/A
Proposed	Semi	162s	28.211.9	-8.518.5	1.81.3	2.41.7	5.84.6