Medium-Long-Term Radiographic and Clinical Outcomes after Surgical Treatment of Intra-Articular Tibial Pilon Fractures by Three Different Techniques
Table 2
Patient and fracture characteristics of our cohort.
N°
Gender
Age
FW-UP (months)
AO
Technique
Ovadia
AOFAS
SF36 (PSC)
SF36 (MCS)
Gustilo
TISS.DAMAGE
(1)
M
49
69
C2
ORIF
Fair
47
22.8
35.6
Yes
(2)
M
70
54
B3
ORIF
Fair
78
45.2
44.3
(3)
F
46
47
B1
MIPO
Good
95
55.3
46.8
I
Yes
(4)
F
49
39
C2
MIPO
Good
100
55.5
57.2
(5)
F
20
65
B1
ORIF
Good
78
47.1
44.1
(6)
M
28
49
C1
ORIF
Good
90
55.37
50.8
(7)
F
22
34
C2
ORIF
Good
94
38.5
42.3
Yes
(8)
M
51
45
C3
EF
Fair
53
20.5
55.1
(9)
M
20
67
C2
ORIF
Good
89
45.6
30.1
Yes
(10)
M
61
46
C3
ORIF
Good
96
55.5
60.2
Yes
(11)
F
20
42
C1
ORIF
Good
100
54.4
60.0
(12)
M
79
72
C1
ORIF
Fair
41
21.6
31.2
Yes
(13)
F
70
60
C1
ORIF
Good
77
44.3
46.3
(14)
M
41
58
C3
ORIF
Fair
58
32.9
50.8
I
Yes
(15)
M
20
46
B1
ORIF
Good
96
51.3
45.8
(16)
M
59
54
B3
ORIF
Good
93
57.0
54.3
(17)
M
49
39
B3
ORIF
Good
95
50.8
55.37
(18)
M
69
43
B2
ORIF
Good
98
51.0
44.5
(19)
M
43
50
C2
MIPO
Good
97
50.1
53.6
(20)
M
60
47
C2
ORIF
Good
98
55.5
60.0
(21)
F
64
79
C3
ORIF
Fair
89
46.8
57.1
Yes
(22)
M
27
48
C1
ORIF
Good
100
55.6
60.9
(23)
F
65
42
C1
ORIF
Good
88
46.2
55.9
(24)
M
64
66
C3
EF
Poor
20
20.6
17.7
III
Yes
(25)
M
37
38
C2
MIPO
Good
71
35.2
37.1
(26)
F
52
74
C2
ORIF
Fair
61
43.9
44.1
Yes
(27)
F
33
37
C2
ORIF
Good
100
57.0
55.5
(28)
M
85
100
B2
MIPO
Fair
52
33.3
35.5
(29)
F
19
44
B2
MIPO
Good
90
44.7
46.8
(30)
F
22
67
C2
ORIF
Poor
44
21.7
22.5
Yes
(31)
M
82
63
C3
MIPO
Good
78
56.0
53.4
Yes
(32)
F
52
56
C3
ORIF
Fair
50
25.7
47.2
I
Yes
(33)
M
29
39
B2
ORIF
Good
90
49.8
33.2
Yes
(34)
M
43
57
C1
EF
Poor
60
38.0
28.0
II
Yes
(35)
M
83
97
C3
EF
Poor
29
17.7
27.6
III
Yes
(36)
M
56
44
C1
ORIF
Good
98
59.9
58.0
(37)
M
78
76
B3
ORIF
Poor
39
30.2
19.2
I
Yes
(38)
F
88
34
C3
ORIF
Fair
45
24.5
46.1
(39)
M
64
46
C2
MIPO
Good
88
48.9
51.6
(40)
M
23
76
C3
ORIF
Good
96
57.8
58.9
Yes
(41)
M
63
35
C1
ORIF
Good
82
43.0
51.8
(42)
F
41
39
B1
MIPO
Good
100
62
60.9
(43)
M
45
39
C2
ORIF
Good
86
48.1
42.5
Yes
(44)
F
74
37
C1
MIPO
Good
90
58.2
53.0
(45)
M
42
70
B2
EF
Fair
68
46.7
36.1
Yes
(46)
M
34
61
B2
ORIF
Good
96
53.2
56.2
(47)
M
68
37
B3
ORIF
Fair
65
37.9
35.4
(48)
M
81
45
C2
ORIF
Fair
59
23.8
32.2
Yes
(49)
F
60
69
B3
ORIF
Good
78
42.8
42.3
Yes
(50)
F
36
88
B2
MIPO
Good
58
42.1
44.8
(51)
F
52
41
C2
ORIF
Good
96
57.9
44.5
(52)
M
87
67
B3
ORIF
Fair
78
43.6
49.2
(53)
M
24
33
B3
ORIF
Fair
48
35.9
21.1
I
Yes
(54)
M
67
67
C1
ORIF
Good
68
23.3
42.5
Yes
(55)
M
19
37
B3
ORIF
Good
82
55.9
35.1
(56)
M
72
35
B3
ORIF
Good
89
56.9
56.33
(57)
M
39
85
C3
ORIF
Fair
70
47.8
58.2
Yes
(58)
M
23
42
C2
MIPO
Good
90
57.3
58.9
(59)
M
88
70
C2
EF
Poor
38
19.5
25.7
II
Yes
(60)
M
84
83
C2
EF
Fair
70
44.5
49.5
I
Yes
(61)
F
60
67
C1
ORIF
Good
88
44.9
51.7
(62)
F
46
40
B3
ORIF
Fair
65
45.8
43.0
Yes
(63)
M
83
71
C3
EF
Fair
47
36.4
45.2
Yes
(64)
M
21
51
B3
ORIF
Good
100
57.0
60.1
(65)
M
47
61
C3
MIPO
Good
94
56.2
59.1
Yes
(66)
M
61
68
C2
ORIF
Good
83
43.6
44.5
(67)
M
82
52
C1
ORIF
Good
62
43.9
46.9
Yes
(68)
M
52
93
B3
MIPO
Fair
60
39.8
41.2
(69)
F
29
36
C2
EF
Good
90
57.4
57.2
(70)
M
32
59
C2
ORIF
Good
92
44.9
42.1
(71)
M
72
38
C1
MIPO
Fair
75
40.5
39.4
(72)
F
35
48
C2
MIPO
Good
76
42.1
44.6
(73)
M
76
35
C1
ORIF
Good
98
37.0
44.0
(74)
M
75
40
B1
MIPO
Good
87
56.2
55.8
(75)
F
38
60
B2
ORIF
Good
100
57.6
51.9
(76)
F
90
101
B3
ORIF
Fair
54
38.5
23.2
Yes
(77)
M
30
45
B3
ORIF
Good
90
60.1
56.5
(78)
M
40
49
C2
ORIF
Good
98
57.6
39.8
(79)
M
75
62
C2
ORIF
Good
87
46.9
55.9
(80)
F
83
49
C3
EF
Fair
32
30.1
39.9
II
Yes
(81)
M
77
97
C2
EF
Poor
43
22.4
30.0
II
Yes
(82)
F
77
82
C1
ORIF
Good
53
22.6
39.8
Yes
(83)
F
21
73
C2
ORIF
Good
100
60.1
49.5
(84)
M
31
74
B3
ORIF
Good
85
46.2
53.2
(85)
F
79
68
C1
ORIF
Good
68
47.1
44.6
Yes
(86)
M
48
66
B3
EF
Fair
42
21.3
42.5
II
Yes
(87)
M
64
36
C2
EF
Good
78
56.1
56.9
Yes
(88)
M
23
41
B3
ORIF
Good
81
52.0
41.3
(89)
M
58
61
B3
EF
Fair
38
19.3
44.8
II
Yes
(90)
M
60
65
C3
ORIF
Good
94
56.4
57.8
Yes
(91)
M
34
59
B2
ORIF
Good
100
54.1
43.4
(92)
M
45
54
B2
ORIF
Fair
80
37.3
32.1
I
Yes
(93)
M
30
63
C1
ORIF
Good
91
52.3
46.2
(94)
M
65
43
C1
ORIF
Good
96
56.33
56.9
Distribution of the type of fracture according to Ovadia and Beals criteria in the analyzed patient series. FW-UP: follow-up, TISS.DAMAGE: tissue damage.