Efficacy and Safety of Qingpeng Ointment for Subacute and Chronic Eczema: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Table 2
Characteristics of all included studies.
First author
Sample size (T/C)
Age (years)
Interventions
Duration treatment (weeks)
Outcomes
T
C
T
C
Li 2019
60 (30/30)
26-72
20-74
QP
Sham ointment
2
①②③④
Tang 2011
228 (154/74)
18-70
18-70
QP
Sham ointment
3
①②④
Wang 2018
120 (60/60)
2-11
2-12
QP
Vaseline ointment
2
①②④
Zhang 2017
67 (34/33)
2-12
3-12
QP
Vaseline ointment
2
①④
She 2016
65 (33/32)
2-12
2-12
QP
Vaseline ointment
2
①②④
Zeng 2013
69 (38/31)
20-63
20-63
QP
Vaseline ointment
4
①②④
Chen 2010
83 (43/40)
29-68
31-69
QP
Vaseline ointment
4
①④
Tang 2017
112 (56/56)
22-64
21-63
QP
Triamcinolone acetonide cream
2
④
Song 2017
87 (44/43)
4-12
4-12
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
4
③④
Zhang 2016
64 (33/31)
18-60
18-60
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
4
①④
Yang 2016
215 (108/107)
18-64
17-58
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
2
①②④
Guo 2015
78 (38/40)
15-70
16-68
QP
Halometasone cream
4
①④
Huang 2014
77 (38/39)
18-65
18-65
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
3
①④
Hou 2014
71 (34/37)
18-72
18-72
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
3
①④
Zeng 2013
73 (38/35)
20-63
20-63
QP
Mometasone furoate cream
4
①②④
Li 2012
61 (29/32)
18-69
18-75
QP
Fluticasone propionate cream
4
①④
Zheng 2012
80 (39/41)
25-70
21-65
QP
Mometasone furoate cream
3
①②③
Zhao 2011
65 (33/32)
15-86
15-86
QP
Hydrocortisone cream
4
①②④
Wang 2011
244 (126/118)
18-65
16-60
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
2
①②④
Zeng 2011
44 (22/20)
18-75
18-75
QP
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
4
④
Yang 2018
74 (37/37)
4-10
4-9
QP + desonide ointment
Desonide ointment
4
②③④
Jiang 2017
100 (50/50)
19-78
20-81
QP + mometasone furoate cream
Mometasone furoate cream
2
①③④
Wang 2015
97 (54/43)
35.69
34.54
QP + hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
Hydrocortisone butyrate ointment
2
②
Liu 2014
82 (40/42)
21-70
19-72
QP + halometasone cream
Halometasone cream
2
①
Li 2012
62 (30/32)
21-72
18-75
QP + fluticasone propionate cream
Fluticasone propionate cream
2
①
Zheng 2012
85 (44/41)
18-72
21-65
QP + mometasone furoate cream
Mometasone furoate cream
1
①②③
Zhou 2011
126 (63/63)
15-70
15-70
QP + halometasone cream
Halometasone cream
2
①②④
Zhai 2011
64 (32/32)
16-64
16-64
QP + fluticasone propionate cream
Fluticasone propionate cream
2
①②④
Peng 2011
85 (44/41)
19-63
18-64
QP + triamcinolone acetonide cream
Triamcinolone acetonide cream
4
①②④
T: test group; C: control group; QP: Qingpeng ointment; ①: total efficacy rate; ②: total symptom score; ③: visual analogue scale for pruritus; ④: adverse events. A three-arm study.
