Review Article

Tear Levels of Inflammatory Cytokines in Keratoconus: A Meta-Analysis of Case-Control and Cross-Sectional Studies

Table 5

Results of metaregression analyses.

CytokineHeterogeneity factorsCoefficientSE95% CI (LCI, UCI)

IL-1βDetection method-2.780.471-5.91<0.001(-3.702, -1.857)
Unit of measurement-1.4062.377-0.590.554(-6.066, 3.253)
Quality score-2.780.471-5.91<0.001(-3.702, -1.857)
Region-0.0131.587-0.010.993(-3.123, 3.096)

IL-4Detection method3.5733.9390.910.363(-4.128, 11.274)
Unit of measurement5.2761.3553.89<0.001(2.62, 7.932)
Quality score3.5733.9390.910.363(-4.128, 11.274)
Region2.6380.6783.89<0.001(1.31, 3.966)

IL-6Detection method-0.7840.509-1.540.123(-1.781, 0.214)
Unit of measurement0.2120.8740.240.808(-1.5, 1.925)
Quality score0.1770.6810.260.795(-1.158, 1.512)
Region0.5060.2591.950.051(-0.003, 1.104)
Age-1.7330.28-6.19<0.001(-2.282, -1.184)

IL-10Detection method2.4881.7961.380.166(-1.033, 6.008)
Unit of measurement3.9761.7182.310.021(0.609, 7.343)
Quality score3.1181.4412.160.031(0.292, 5.943)
Region0.7971.0120.790.431(-1.187, 2.78)
Age-0.9242.759-0.330.738(-6.331, 4.483)

TNF-αDetection method1.5341.5351.000.318(-1.475, 4.543)
Unit of measurement3.6610.8984.08<0.001(1.901, 5.422)
Quality score1.5341.5351.000.318(-1.475, 4.543)
Region1.8310.4494.08<0.001(0.95, 2.711)

SE: standard error; LCI: lower confidence interval; UCI: upper confidence interval.