Review Article

Diagnostic Performance of Transient Elastography Versus Two-Dimensional Shear Wave Elastography for Liver Fibrosis in Chronic Viral Hepatitis: Direct Comparison and a Meta-Analysis

Table 2

Technical characteristics of the included studies.

IdTE2D-SWE
No. of readerExperience of operatorProbeTechnical failure rateNo. of readerExperience of operatorProbeDiameter of ROITechnical failure rate

Leung [17]1More than 5 yearsNA10.4% (47/454)1NASC6-13-4 cm1.1% (5/454)
Yao [22]1At least 100 TE proceduresM01NASC6-12 cm0
Zeng [18]2At least 100 TE proceduresM3.1% (8/257)2More than 6 monthsSC6-12 cm0.8% (2/257)
Ferraioli [21]1At least 50 TE proceduresNA2.5% (3/121)2NASC6-12 cm1.7% (2/121)
Deffieux [11]1More than 7 yearsNA5.3% (6/114)2NASC6-13 cm1.7% (2/120)
Xia 2019 [19]NANAM or LNA2NAL5-1NANA
Paul [23]NANAM or XL2.1% (5/240)NANASC6-11-1.5 cm1.3% (3/240)
Osman [24]1NANA14.0% (30/210)1NANANA5.7% (12/210)

2D-SWE: two-dimensional shear wave elastography; NA: not available; ROI: region of interest; QUADAS: quality assessment of studies of diagnostic accuracy studies; TE: transient elastography.