| | Interventions | Silver needle+massage | Electroacupuncture+massage | Needle knife+massage | Warm needling+massage | Massage |
| | Silver needle+massage | 0 | | | | | | Electroacupuncture+massage | 2.63 (-3.23, 8.50) | 0 | | | | | Needle knife+massage | 7.09 (1.48, 12.71)1) | 4.46 (2.77, 6.15)1) | 0 | | | | Warm needling+massage | 13.10 (7.74, 18.45)1) | 10.46 (7.89, 13.03)1) | 6.00 (4.07, 7.94)1) | 0 | | | Massage | 18.81 (13.51, 24.11)1) | 16.18 (13.67, 18.69)1) | 11.72 (9.86, 13.58)1) | 5.71 (4.96, 6.47)1) | 0 | | Electroacupuncture | 19.63 (13.95, 25.32)1) | 17.00 (15.57, 18.43)1) | 12.54 (11.65, 13.43)1) | 6.54 (4.41, 8.67)1) | 0.82 (-1.24, 2.88) | | Warm needle | 21.63 (15.45, 27.80)1) | 18.99 (14.98, 23.01)1) | 14.53 (10.89, 18.18)1) | 8.53 (5.44, 11.62)1) | 2.82 (-0.36, 5.99) | | Common acupuncture+massage | 25.90 (20.24, 31.55)1) | 23.26 (20.50, 26.03)1) | 18.80 (16.62, 20.99)1) | 12.80 (10.89, 14.71)1) | 7.09 (5.11, 9.06)1) | | Common acupuncture | 44.11 (37.04, 51.17)1) | 41.47 (36.42, 46.52)1) | 37.01 (32.25, 41.77)1) | 31.01 (26.37, 35.65)1) | 25.30 (20.63, 29.96)1) |
|
|
| | Interventions | Electroacupuncture | Warm needle | Common acupuncture+massage | Common acupuncture |
| | Silver needle+massage | | | | | | Electroacupuncture+massage | | | | | | Needle knife+massage | | | | | | Warm needling+massage | | | | | | Massage | | | | | | Electroacupuncture | 0 | | | | | Warm needle | 1.99 (-1.76, 5.74) | 0 | | | | Common acupuncture+massage | 6.26 (3.90, 8.62)1) | 4.27 (0.64, 7.90)1) | 0 | | | Common acupuncture | 24.47 (19.63, 29.32)1) | 22.48 (16.91, 28.05)1) | 18.21 (13.98, 22.44)1) | 0 |
|
|
