|
| Author, year | Fluid compared | N | Operation | Conclusion |
|
| Primary outcome: hemodynamic parameters (dynamic parameter, static parameter, and colloid oncotic pressure) |
| Vogt [51], 1999 | 6% HES 200/0.5
5% human albumin | 48 | Major urological surgery | No significant difference in static hemodynamic parameters
HES has lower colloid oncotic pressure |
| Ragaller [41], 2000 | 6% HES 200/0.5 + 7.2%NaCl
6% HES 200/0.5 + 0.9%NaCl | 29 | Abdominal aortic aneurysm repair | Hypertonic NaCl-HES needed lower volume and restored PCWP faster than HES in NSS after aortic clamp off |
| Ickx [24], 2003 | 6% HES130/0.4 (Voluven)
6% HES200/0.5 | 40 | Major abdominal surgery | No significant difference in dynamic hemodynamic parameter
No significant difference in colloid oncotic pressure |
| Sander [48], 2003 | 6% HES130/0.4 (Voluven)
6% HES200/0.5 | 56 | Major gynecological | No significant difference in static hemodynamic parameter
No significant difference in volume needed to maintain hemodynamics |
| Feldheiser [15], 2013 | Jonosteril
6% HES130/0.4 (Volulyte) | 48 | Cytoreductive surgery | HES reduced need for FFP and IV fluid to maintain hemodynamics. No significant difference in need for inotrope. |
| Szturz [50], 2014 | LRS
HES 130/0.4 (Voluven) | 115 | Major urological surgery | HES reduced need for FFP and IV fluid to maintain hemodynamics |
|
| Primary outcome was another objective but also had these outcomes |
| Rittoo [47], 2005 | HES 200/0.62 (Elohes)
4% gelatin (Gelofusine) | 40 | Abdominal aortic aneurysm repair | Lower HES intake to maintain hemodynamics compared to gelatin |
| Senagore [49], 2009 | Standard-LRS
GD-LRS
GD-hetastarch balance | 64 | Laparoscopic colonic surgery | Lower HES intake to achieved target stroke volume |
| Zhang [56], 2012 | Restricted-LRS
GD-LRS
GD-HES 130/0.4
Crystalloid : colloid ratio = 1.67 : 1 | 60 | GI surgery | HES reduced need of IV fluid to maintain hemodynamics |
| Hung [23], 2014 | LRS
6% HES 130/0.4 (Voluven) | 80 | Major abdominal surgery | HES reduced need of IV fluid to maintain hemodynamics |
| Lavu [30], 2014 | LRS
3% NaCl | 259 | Pancreaticoduodenectomy | 3% NaCl reduced need of IV fluid to static maintain hemodynamics |
| Yates [16], 2014 | Hartmann’s solution
6% HES 130/0.4 (Volulyte)
Crystalloid : colloid ratio = 1.6 : 1 | 202 | Colorectal surgery | HES reduced IV fluid to maintain hemodynamics |
| Kancir [27], 2015 | NSS
6% HES 130/0.4 (Voluven) | 36 | Radical prostatectomy | No significant difference in fluid need to maintain hemodynamics |
| Deng [21], 2017 | LRS
4% gelatin (Gelofusine)
4.5% NaCl in 7.6% HES 40 | 36 | Laparoscopic colonic surgery | HS-HES can prolong effect of volume expansion and decreased systemic vascular resistance index |
| Joosten [17], 2018 | Plasmalyte
6% HES130/0.4 (Volulyte) | 160 | Major abdominal surgery | HES reduced need of IV fluid to maintain hemodynamics by dynamic monitoring |
|
