Solving the Manufacturing Cell Design Problem through Binary Cat Swarm Optimization with Dynamic Mixture Ratios

Table 11

Comparison between classic BCSO.

ID	M		C	Mmax	Optimum values	EVOA				MBFA				CSOA
						Best	Worst	Mean	RPD (%)	Best	Worst	Mean	RPD (%)	Best	Worst	Mean	RPD (%)
CF01	5	7	2	3	0	0	0	0	0.00	0	0	0	0.00	0	0	0	0.00
CF02	5	7	2	4	3	3	3	3	0.00	3	3	3	0.00	3	3	3	0.00
CF03	5	18	2	3	5	5	5	5	0.00	5	5	5	0.00	5	5	5	0.00
CF04	6	8	2	3	2	2	2	2	0.00	2	2	2	0.00	2	2	2	0.00
CF05	7	11	5	2	8	8	8	8	0.00	9	9	9	12.50	8	8	8	0.00
CF06	7	11	4	2	4	4	4	4	0.00	4	4	4	0.00	4	4	4	0.00
CF07	8	12	4	3	7	7	7	7	0.00	8	8	8	14.29	7	7	7	0.00
CF08	8	20	3	4	7	7	7	7	0.00	7	7	7	0.00	7	7	7	0.00
CF09	8	20	2	5	25	25	25	25	0.00	27	27	27	8.00	25	25	25	0.00
CF10	10	10	5	4	0	0	2	1.2	0.00	3	3	3	0.00	0	0	0	0.00
CF11	10	15	3	4	0	0	4	0.8	0.00	0	0	0	0.00	0	0	0	0.00
CF12	14	24	7	3	7	11	16	13.3	57.14	9	11	10.1	28.57	7	7	7	0.00
CF13	14	24	7	3	8	12	17	14.3	50.00	8	9	8.4	0.00	8	8	8	0.00
CF14	16	24	8	5	Unknown	30	35	32.9	—	36	41	39.6	—	24	24	24	—
CF15	16	30	6	6	Unknown	31	39	35.7	—	18	25	21.1	—	17	17	17	—
CF16	16	43	8	4	Unknown	42	47	44.6	—	39	46	43.8	—	29	30	29.05	—
CF17	18	24	9	4	Unknown	32	36	34.2	—	32	35	33.2	—	26	27	26.53	—
CF18	20	20	6	7	Unknown	46	53	49.9	—	52	59	56.2	—	41	42	41.18	—
CF19	20	23	7	6	Unknown	51	56	53.4	—	49	55	51.6	—	38	38	38	—
CF20	20	35	5	5	Unknown	28	42	36	—	7	16	12.3	—	2	2	2	—
CF21	20	35	5	5	Unknown	57	65	60.3	—	43	45	43.5	—	35		35	—
CF22	24	40	7	5	Unknown	30	43	37.5	—	0	23	15.5	—	0	5	4.9	—
CF23	24	40	7	5	Unknown	39	48	44.2	—	13	19	15	—	10	15	13.53	—
CF24	24	40	7	5	Unknown	44	53	49.7	—	25	30	27.6	—	18	22	20.98	—
CF25	24	40	11	5	Unknown	60	64	61.6	—	49	57	56.1	—	40	44	43.6	—
CF26	24	40	12	3	Unknown	68	71	70	—	64	67	65.6	—	59	63	62.15	—
CF27	24	40	12	3	Unknown	69	72	70.6	—	67	72	68.8	—	61	66	64.05	—
CF28	27	27	6	11	Unknown	84	100	94.1	—	76	97	92.1	—	54	54	54	—
CF29	28	46	10	4	Unknown	102	119	112.8	—	106	112	109.1	—	91	98	96.1	—
CF30	30	41	14	4	Unknown	57	63	59.7	—	43	65	58.3	—	37	43	42.6	—
CF31	30	50	13	3	Unknown	70	79	75.3	—	54	63	60.4	—	52	59	57.9	—
CF32	30	50	14	4	Unknown	86	90	87.6	—	76	81	77.6	—	66	75	72.15	—
CF33	36	90	17	6	Unknown	136	153	144.8	—	116	125	122.6	—	93	95	94.93	—
CF34	37	53	3	15	Unknown	352	383	369.2	—	325	335	329.5	—	256	256	256	—
CF35	40	100	10	6	Unknown	181	207	195.6	—	114	130	119.2	—	83	121	110.58	—