Solving the Manufacturing Cell Design Problem through Binary Cat Swarm Optimization with Dynamic Mixture Ratios

Table 12

Experimental results for new instances.

		Results with 35 new instances
	O	Classic BCSO					Autonomous Search BCSO
		BCSO	A	RPD	I	Ms	BCSO	A	RPD	I	Ms
1	0	0	0	0	1	3583.2	0	0	0	1	3433.4
2	3	3	3	0	1	3619.7	3	3	0	1	3558.5
3	5	5	5	0	1	6273	5	5	0	1	6155.3
4	2	2	2	0	1	4157.7	2	2	0	1	3807.2
5	8	8	8	0	1	7897.8	8	8	0	1	7575.8
6	4	4	4	0	2	6919	4	4	0	2	6389.2
7	7	7	7	0	4	8158.6	7	7	0	5	7529.3
8	7	7	7	0	4	10048.4	7	7	0	4	9240.1
9	25	25	25	0	2	9373.3	25	25	0	2	8705.8
10	0	0	0	0	8	8982.7	0	0	0	10	8254.2
11	0	0	0	0	4	8893.5	0	0	0	4	8164.4
12	7	7	7	0	128	21747.6	7	7	0	194	19928.8
13	8	8	8	0	67	21835	8	8	0	87	20146.5
14	Unknown	24	24		103	27558	24	24		147	25383.5
15	Unknown	17	17		260	27283.5	17	17		296	25025.1
16	Unknown	29	29.05		922	40535.1	29	29.08		1268	37265.8
17	Unknown	26	26.53		717	31776.2	26	26.73		876	30591.1
18	Unknown	41	41.18		1241	26712.9	41	41.5		1174	27322.4
19	Unknown	38	38		577	31345.7	38	38.3		590	32086.5
20	Unknown	2	2		300	31251.8	2	2		358	29678.2
21	Unknown	35	35		318	34413.4	35	35.08		443	33892.7
22	Unknown	0	4.9		1909	42425.3	0	2.48		2017	103160.1
23	Unknown	10	13.53		1649	45014.9	10	12.43		1988	42954.3
24	Unknown	18	20.98		1958	45974.2	18	20.03		2080	43359.1
25	Unknown	40	43.6		2186	62062.9	40	44.08		2096	56834.7
26	Unknown	59	62.15		815	66630.4	57	60.73		2352	61659.3
27	Unknown	61	64.05		1204	66655.3	61	63.55		2202	62349.9
28	Unknown	54	54		466	43228.5	54	54.05		477	41759.4
29	Unknown	91	96.1		1434	76860.5	90	95.2		2578	67203.9
30	Unknown	37	42.6		1270	84810.9	34	40.9		2520	75800.3
31	Unknown	52	57.9		641	93391.4	49	54.3		2453	81183.7
32	Unknown	66	72.15		1670	99440.7	67	71.8		2431	87624.9
33	Unknown	93	94.93		2423	165907.8	93	95.48		1999	143833
34	Unknown	256	256		1345	70985.4	256	256		1005	70893.8
35	Unknown	83	110.58		964	153404.2	55	82.2		3579	150723
	5.85	34.51	36.63	0	703	42547.4	33.49	35.51	0	1007	41242.1