A Systematic and Meta-Analysis Survey of Whale Optimization Algorithm

Table 9

Comparison result of WOA-BAT and WOA.

Function	WOA		WOA-BAT
	avg	std	avg	std
1	1.2E − 74	5.89E − 74	1.34E − 06	4.07E − 07
2	2.37E − 51	8.82E − 51	0.0074	0.0013
3	50945	13527.44	0.000216	0.001126
4	52.426	24.97794	0.001	7.1E − 05
5	28.02927	0.452718	11.1554	13.89905
6	0.4356	0.212037	1.58E − 06	7.15E − 07
7	0.0026	0.002513	0.0037	0.0076
8	−10424	1668.107	−12214	1084.168
9	1.89E − 15	1.04E − 14	2.9852	9.107663
10	4.8E − 15	2.35E − 15	0.1201	0.652436
11	0.011	0.042629	7.2E − 08	3.4E − 08
12	0.02	0.010083	1.27E − 08	5.89E − 09
13	0.5672	0.296041	2.1E − 07	1.07E − 07
14	3.258	3.214906	0.998	4.52E − 16
15	0.000566	0.000369	0.000384	0.000354
16	−1.0316	6.78E − 16	−1.0316	6.78E − 16
17	0.3979	9.73E − 06	0.39789	1.69E − 16
18	3	6.15E − 05	7.5	10.23432
19	−3.856	0.009536	−3.8623	0.002004
20	−3.225	0.101675	−3.2822	0.057156
21	−8.746	2.324189	−8.4675	2.42464
22	−7.6138	2.858764	−9.697	1.830619
23	−6.7571	3.587922	−9.9988	1.640539