Review Article

A Review of EEG and fMRI Measuring Aesthetic Processing in Visual User Experience Research

Table 1

EEG contributions to UX and UI aesthetic designs.

Wave nameFrequency (Hz)Typical amplitude (uV)MeaningAesthetics on UXAesthetics on UI

Delta0.1–4100–200The deepest stages of sleep and support in describing the depth of sleepBetter UX evokes stronger relative power of delta (frontal region) [12].Delta reflects feelings of drowsiness, which can be used to evaluate the visual novelty of the UI [61, 62].
Frontal delta is related to the visual working memory, which can be used to evaluate the complexity of UI design [63].
Theta4–8Higher than 30Interesting emotions, distraction, trance, hypnosis, and intense dreams and emotionsBetter UX affects weaker relative power on the theta rhythms (frontal and parieto-occipital regions) [12].
Theta is correlated with UX on navigation and location recall, which can be considered in the virtual environment [64].
Preferred humanoid robot appearances showed higher theta rhythm power than nonpreferred ones [65].
Alpha8–1330–50 or higherRelaxed but aware stateBetter UX evokes stronger relative power of alpha (frontocentral, parietal, and parieto-occipital regions) [12].
EEG asymmetry of the alpha frequency band is strongly associated with affective or emotional processes [66].
The alpha power varies the function in tasks related to creativity and interventions [18].
Alpha brain waves are active when people feel stable and pleasant [51].
Alpha increased when users were in a relaxed state or showed pleasing images [12].
Posterior alpha is in charge of visual working memory, which can test the complexity of UI [63].
Beta13–302–20 or higherExcited state, physical activityThe beta frequency band is associated with emotions in the immersive or virtual environments [67].Studies reported that women showed higher beta in the anterior cingulate cortex on modelling design [68].
Gamma30–603–5 or higherHigh consciousness level, integration of different sensory modalities, awakened stateBetter UX evokes stronger relative power of gamma (C3) [69].It is in charge of working memory of graphic UI design [70].

UX, user experience; EEG, electroencephalograph; UI, user interface.