Review Article
Tuna Swarm Optimization: A Novel Swarm-Based Metaheuristic Algorithm for Global Optimization
Table 15
Wilcoxon rank-sum test on F1–F13 with Dim = 1000.
| | TSO vs | HHO | EO | TSA | GWO | SSA | PSO | WOA | | Function | p | Win | p | Win | p | Win | p | Win | p | Win | p | Win | p | Win |
| | F1 | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | | F2 | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | | F3 | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | | F4 | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | | F5 | 5.87E−04 | − | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | | F6 | 3.50E−09 | − | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | | F7 | 1.86E−03 | − | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.37E−05 | + | | F8 | 2.23E−01 | = | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.69E−11 | + | | F9 | NaN | = | NaN | = | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 0.333711 | = | | F10 | NaN | = | 2.90E−13 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 7.21E−07 | + | | F11 | NaN | = | 8.99E−11 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 1.21E−12 | + | 0.333711 | = | | F12 | 2.00E−05 | − | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | | F13 | 1.25E−05 | − | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + | 3.02E−11 | + |
|
|
