Tuna Swarm Optimization: A Novel Swarm-Based Metaheuristic Algorithm for Global Optimization

Table 16

Wilcoxon rank-sum test on F14–F23.

TSO vs

HHO

EO

TSA

GWO

SSA

PSO

WOA

Function

p

Win

p

Win

p

Win

p

Win

p

Win

p

Win

p

Win

F14

7.27E−11

+

2.81E−04

−

1.99E−11

+

1.99E−11

+

5.43E−02

=

1.80E−05

−

1.99E−11

+

F15

8.30E−08

+

4.84E−08

+

8.43E−09

+

3.94E−08

+

1.10E−08

+

4.27E−08

+

5.06E−08

+

F16

1.07E−09

+

1.49E−04

−

1.41E−11

+

1.41E−11

+

1.39E−11

+

1.43E−06

−

1.40E−11

+

F17

1.21E−12

+

NaN

=

1.21E−12

+

1.21E−12

+

5.07E−06

+

NaN

=

1.21E−12

+

F18

1.46E−10

+

1.85E−02

−

2.09E−11

+

2.09E−11

+

2.09E−11

+

2.88E−03

−

2.09E−11

+

F19

1.75E−11

+

5.29E−05

+

1.75E−11

+

1.75E−11

+

2.35E−11

+

1.10E−05

−

1.75E−11

+

F20

1.09E−08

+

3.07E−01

=

3.07E−08

+

8.39E−08

+

7.12E−10

+

4.65E−01

=

1.09E−08

+

F21

1.07E−11

+

3.81E−01

=

1.07E−11

+

1.07E−11

+

1.07E−11

+

1.84E−01

=

1.07E−11

+

F22

6.43E−12

+

0.019605

−

6.43E−12

+

6.43E−12

+

6.43E−12

+

2.70E−01

=

6.43E−12

+

F23

2.14E−11

+

2.20E−02

−

2.14E−11

+

2.14E−11

+

2.14E−11

+

2.31E−01

=

2.14E−11

+