Application of Improved Manta Ray Foraging Optimization Algorithm in Coverage Optimization of Wireless Sensor Networks

Table 4

Comparison of some CEC2017 test suite Functions.

Function	Algorithm	Best	Worst	Average	Std. Deviation
CF2	BOA	61865.0516	94673.9128	83610.9	7252.6901
	WOA	181153.9155	432212.7775	276488.167	55312.8565
	SCA	47819.1154	168455.467	86410.2938	22263.7286
	SSA	62613.8174	88822.6913	76844.6378	5701.0961
	MRFO	9829.1363	31305.175	19475.5722	5541.5783
	LGMRFO	3696.8277	25977.9711	12196.0016	5512.4282
CF4	BOA	877.3537	967.557	910.4024	22.3843
	WOA	729.3879	1020.0647	864.4385	73.0595
	SCA	786.6671	876.3863	835.3316	26.4226
	SSA	670.135	847.6568	777.11	42.704
	MRFO	598.501	749.7332	657.6086	38.2902
	LGMRFO	596.5108	742.7687	656.0086	32.1436
CF7	BOA	1105.4266	1162.1825	1132.1944	15.1434
	WOA	1009.6932	1229.7966	1074.2146	51.6852
	SCA	1065.2217	1126.971	1096.4516	17.2106
	SSA	891.4775	1049.7886	992.9483	34.9974
	MRFO	873.6269	1002.9701	952.1615	34.1025
	LGMRFO	881.5865	982.2495	934.2627	22.9263
CF8	BOA	8895.1653	12920.2913	11075.1726	1016.128
	WOA	6526.484	24593.4414	11953.6288	4545.5098
	SCA	5801.305	12951.4022	9435.4069	2185.7205
	SSA	5377.5911	6872.3515	5815.5711	314.8259
	MRFO	2164.7351	7093.8441	4205.0785	1036.6014
	LGMRFO	2152.914	5618.2209	3717.7776	748.5012
CF10	BOA	6547.2791	13835.6547	9002.8469	2183.7801
	WOA	3775.3694	17919.2339	10044.4225	3734.4153
	SCA	2566.8743	5716.6906	3883.7186	870.4679
	SSA	1492.0962	4381.4378	2434.9342	820.455
	MRFO	1165.9774	1315.8124	1240.9612	47.1172
	LGMRFO	1164.0194	1259.8653	1201.5794	37.8005
CF15	BOA	4532.5588	12202.6872	7530.0974	1860.0716
	WOA	3091.6252	6343.4343	4183.5431	668.3028
	SCA	3391.0211	4496.9845	4182.2468	265.6575
	SSA	2430.5504	4058.9642	3139.6938	393.3999
	MRFO	2095.1895	3166.5832	2712.2462	317.7892
	LGMRFO	2229.9637	3421.9934	2809.234	277.3386
CF17	BOA	4956069.9615	195429416.0647	58482274.1537	48599692.6692
	WOA	466476.5171	41365723.3653	9301704.5173	10116889.255
	SCA	2977781.3915	38837593.3164	15400703.9766	9893645.6625
	SSA	81791.5292	12803104.8522	2438302.354	2728490.4502
	MRFO	41716.4756	962707.3555	254339.6966	203873.0355
	LGMRFO	28304.0738	430158.1843	122081.5603	102567.4144
CF20	BOA	2612.4543	2931.4312	2729.5077	205.2435
	WOA	2412.3452	2734.6753	2582.6538	66.6743
	SCA	2400.7732	2714.5564	2609.7752	76.453
	SSA	2423.4533	2612.1334	2543.1367	23.8764
	MRFO	2201.1145	2511.1134	2422.0052	16.0254
	LGMRFO	2301.7768	2501.657	2404.667	13.1909
CF24	BOA	4867.6438	7550.4929	6012.4665	605.8525
	WOA	3111.795	3356.4394	3222.9168	72.9402
	SCA	3305.9347	4349.4399	3601.44	268.54
	SSA	2937.7087	3081.5462	3001.3027	38.5158
	MRFO	2885.7049	2942.7045	2900.6972	17.214
	LGMRFO	2891.818	2979.9971	2932.3753	24.3826