Review Article

The Risk Factors of Acquiring Severe Hand, Foot, and Mouth Disease: A Meta-Analysis

Table 3

Egger’s test of all risk factors.

Risk factorsNumber of studiesEgger’s testPublication bias (yes or no)Model
value value

Female4−0.120.916NoF
Scatter-lived children41.180.361NoR
Floating population40.580.620NoR
Fever8−0.740.492NoR
Fever for more than 3 days3−0.040.976NoF
Vomiting61.680.168NoR
Limb trembling41.360.306NoR
Dyspnea43.510.072NoR
Contact with HFMD children4−0.720.548NoR
Rash on the hands3−1.000.499NoR
Rash on the foot31.920.306NoF
Rashes on the hips3−84.520.008YesF
Level of the clinic visited first (below the country level)3−1.100.470NoR
Breast feeding3−9.690.065NoR
Pathologic reflexes31.180.448NoF
Lethargy53.090.054NoR
Convulsions50.400.718NoR
EV71 infection71.830.126NoR

R, random effect model; F, fixed effect model.