Automatic Approach for Lung Segmentation with Juxta-Pleural Nodules from Thoracic CT Based on Contour Tracing and Correction

Table 4

Experimental result of lung segmentation on 45 testing scans. AVG indicates average result, and SD is short for standard deviation.

ID	VD	VOE	RVD	ASD	RMSD	MSD
	(cm^3)	(%)	(%)	(mm)	(mm)	(mm)	(cm^3)	(cm^3)
1	−47.31	3.0242	−1.31	1.099	1.7593	18.9573	3671.56	3624.25
2	38.30	2.7479	1.09	0.7605	1.5615	18.122	3485.20	3523.50
3	71.74	3.6033	2.14	1.0078	1.7504	21.177	3275.97	3347.71
4	41.67	1.6723	1.14	0.6651	2.3539	19.6505	3615.24	3656.91
5	−54.48	3.2045	−1.47	1.123	2.0554	28.2471	3769.77	3715.29
6	31.33	3.6496	1.08	0.8762	1.7107	13.6632	2873.39	2904.72
7	−50.56	4.6419	−1.46	0.8933	1.4647	20.7681	3505.04	3454.47
8	−38.36	2.2887	−1.16	0.5502	1.5762	13.2609	3332.93	3294.57
9	75.49	5.2518	1.52	1.0722	1.5287	17.7907	4881.78	4957.27
10	−62.66	3.1748	−1.68	0.9567	1.8444	15.0682	3796.92	3734.26
11	35.49	2.5787	1.22	1.0584	1.6721	13.6448	2881.47	2916.96
12	43.62	1.6744	1.61	1.0107	1.806	19.3329	2658.32	2701.95
13	−49.49	3.1636	−1.45	1.0369	1.5537	10.0705	3459.81	3410.32
14	59.68	5.4911	1.99	0.7718	1.7302	19.3278	2945.88	3005.56
15	45.51	2.748	1.13	1.005	1.6431	19.9296	3967.29	4012.79
16	29.85	3.3606	0.77	0.9802	0.9411	11.3013	3825.41	3855.26
17	64.09	2.4039	1.83	0.4677	0.7013	10.2471	3439.35	3503.43
18	−57.97	4.3397	−1.91	1.1241	1.3929	22.9175	3099.42	3041.45
19	7.98	5.5238	0.23	1.1006	1.9721	15.0682	3531.61	3539.59
20	30.77	3.6862	0.78	1.0243	1.7763	20.1077	3938.13	3968.90
21	82.82	1.7774	2.20	0.3712	0.7476	18.913	3685.22	3768.04
22	78.42	6.1284	2.09	0.5164	0.9187	37.7341	3681.38	3759.81
23	39.89	5.0326	1.13	0.6109	1.8158	30.304	3491.12	3531.01
24	75.16	1.7624	2.24	0.4399	1.1044	17.6525	3283.02	3358.19
25	−50.81	4.5438	−1.31	0.6719	2.3576	32.5025	3918.14	3867.33
26	92.24	5.9488	2.38	1.0348	3.4893	38.3925	3776.06	3868.30
27	15.43	2.3037	0.53	0.3511	0.9273	16.7561	2879.30	2894.73
28	−46.44	2.5115	−1.34	0.5523	1.5216	16.6689	3508.69	3462.25
29	119.99	4.2139	2.69	0.6718	2.0628	29.6165	4342.92	4462.90
30	−29.24	2.8285	−0.60	0.8594	1.8682	24.9089	4887.26	4858.02
31	21.64	1.7654	0.57	0.5437	1.1489	16.5399	3799.97	3821.61
32	148.21	5.2781	4.87	1.0058	2.9211	25.7359	2892.25	3040.47
33	87.09	6.0183	3.16	1.0896	2.5128	21.8625	2668.69	2755.78
34	−168.48	4.5721	−3.91	1.0939	2.3051	21.9811	4472.12	4303.64
35	51.99	1.8947	1.73	0.3234	1.1074	26.6914	2950.36	3002.35
36	−97.87	5.4153	−2.53	1.1019	2.7363	33.2542	3970.86	3872.99
37	122.95	3.7016	2.48	0.8564	1.8731	22.6337	4835.66	4958.61
38	−137.55	5.2533	−4.15	1.1919	3.0683	47.3566	3449.08	3311.53
39	−83.38	2.6188	−2.75	0.6592	1.4036	17.7262	3110.78	3027.40
40	31.08	1.6871	0.87	0.4472	0.9098	13.2845	3543.87	3574.96
41	26.11	2.4515	0.66	0.2712	0.7285	26.0694	3945.08	3971.20
42	−71.33	2.7375	−1.97	0.7256	1.4599	17.6144	3692.75	3621.42
43	22.82	3.3868	0.62	0.4087	0.9147	10.2961	3681.11	3703.93
44	33.29	1.3839	0.94	0.3318	0.7743	12.3896	3505.11	3538.40
45	−77.18	4.3108	−2.40	0.9147	2.8345	34.8965	3290.29	3213.11
AVG	11.15	3.5057	0.3176	0.7917	1.6957	21.3430	3582.57	3593.71
SD	69.63	1.3719	1.9445	0.2741	0.6568	8.1743	529.47	528.37