Boosted Sine Cosine Algorithm with Application to Medical Diagnosis

Table 4

The value of ESCA_PSO compared with other algorithms.

(a)

	ESCA_PSO	SCADE		SCA		SCA_PSO		CGSCA		GWO
F1	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	2.80-01		1.73-06	+	2.88-06	+
F2	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F3	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.92-06	—	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F4	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	8.77-01		1.73-06	+	1.92-06	+
F5	N/A	1.78-01		1.25-02	—	6.27-02		1.48-02	—	1.59-01
F6	N/A	3.52-06	+	1.02-05	+	4.53-01		1.24-05	+	1.73-06	—
F7	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F8	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.92-06	+	1.53-01		1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—
F9	N/A	1.73-06	+	2.35-06	+	5.30-01		1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—
F10	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	9.84-03	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—
F11	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	6.88-01		1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—
F12	N/A	2.37-05	+	2.58-03	+	8.94-01		4.53-04	+	3.18-01
F13	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	4.99-03	—	1.73E-06	+	2.43-02	—
F14	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	2.70-02	—	1.73-06	+	5.22-06	+
F15	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	5.44-01		1.73-06	+	4.86-05	+
F16	N/A	3.88-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.96-03	+	1.92-06	+	2.88-06	—
F17	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.48-04	—	1.73-06	+	7.71-04	+
F18	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	2.35-06	—	1.73-06	+	2.07-02	+
F19	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	7.97-01		1.73-06	+	1.74-04	+
F20	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.92-06	—	1.73-06	+	2.88-06	+
F21	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	7.19-02		1.73-06	+	1.15-04	+
F22	N/A	6.42-03	+	3.18-01		4.11-03	+	1.36-01		7.69-06	—
F23	N/A	1.00+00		1.73-06	+	1.00+00		1.00+00		1.73-06	+
F24	N/A	1.56-02	+	1.73-06	+	1.00+00		2.44-04	+	1.73-06	+
F25	N/A	1.00+00		1.73-06	+	1.00+00		1.00+00		3.79-06	+
F26	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.64-05	+	1.73-06	+	4.68-03	+
F27	N/A	5.96-05	+	1.73-06	+	1.00+00		1.00+00		1.73-06	+
F28	N/A	1.23-05	+	1.73-06	+	1.00+00		1.00+00		1.73-06	+
F29	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	5.11-03	+	5.61-06	—	1.73-06	+
F30	N/A	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	6.75-05	+	1.32-04	—	1.73-06	+
+/-/=	/	27/0/3		28/1/1		6/8/10		22/3/5		20/8/2
Avg	2	10		9		3		7		5

(b)

	MFO		BA		PSO		LSHADE
F1	3.18-06	+	1.73-06	—	2.99-01		1.73-06	—
F2	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—
F3	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—	1.73-06	—	1.73-06	—
F4	1.73-06	+	1.57-02	—	9.75-01		1.73-06	—
F5	1.73-06	—	8.45-01		1.53-01		1.73-06	—
F6	1.15-04	—	3.06-04	+	7.69-06	—	1.73-06	—
F7	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	—	1.73E-06	+	1.73-06	—
F8	1.64-05	—	2.83-04	+	5.45-02		1.73-06	—
F9	2.21-01		7.51-05	+	2.80-01		1.73-06	—
F10	4.53-01		4.68-03	+	1.85-01		1.73-06	—
F11	1.92-01		1.11-01		9.26-01		1.73-06	—
F12	1.73-06	—	1.73-06	—	4.20-04	+	1.73-06	—
F13	1.73-06	+	6.56-02		7.16-04	—	1.80-05	—
F14	1.73-06	+	1.64-05	+	1.48-02	+	8.19-05	+
F15	1.73-06	+	1.92-06	+	5.32-03	—	1.73-06	—
F16	4.29-06	+	1.73-06	+	5.30-01		1.73-06	—
F17	2.41-03	+	2.88-06	—	2.41-03	—	2.13-06	—
F18	3.59-04	+	1.73-06	—	1.85-01		1.73-06	—
F19	2.05-04	+	6.87-02		5.45-02		1.73-06	—
F20	1.73-06	+	1.92-06	—	1.92-06	—	3.59-04	—
F21	1.36-04	+	2.84-05	—	7.19-01		1.73-06	—
F22	4.72-02	+	1.15-04	+	2.21-01		1.73-06	—
F23	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	4.32-08	+
F24	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F25	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F26	1.73-06	+	7.52-02		1.24-05	+	1.02-01
F27	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F28	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+
F29	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	8.73-03	+	1.73-06	+
F30	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	1.73-06	+	4.29-06	+
+/-/=	23/4/3		15/10/5		12/6/12		8/21/1
Avg	8		6		4		1