[Retracted] Meta-Analysis on the Application Value of Collaborative Nursing in Postcolostomy Nursing of Patients with Colorectal Cancer

Table 1

The basic characteristics of inclusion in the literature.

Study	Year	Sample time (year.month)	Cases	Age (years)		Sex ratio (male/female)		Study design	Outcome measures
			Con/Treat	Treat	Con	Treat	Con
Wang and Huang[21]	2020	2018.1-2019.6	44/44			25/19	26/18	RCT	②③④⑤
Huang and Room [20]	2015	2012.1-2014.6	48/48	18-75	18-75	32/16	33/15	RCT	③⑤⑦⑧⑨
Wang and Lou [22]	2019	2017.2-2018.10	33/33			18/15	17/16	RCT	①③⑤⑦
Chen et al. [36]	2020	2017.10-2018.10	34/34			21/13	20/14	RCT	①③⑤⑦
Wang [23]	2019	2017.07-2018.08	38/38			23/15	21/17	RCT	①②③④⑤⑥⑦
He [24]	2019	2016.04-2018.05	37/37			22/15	20/17	RCT	①②③④⑤⑥⑦
Xiao [32]	2016	2014.02-2015.02	30/30			10/20	12/18	RCT	①②③④⑤⑥⑦⑧⑨
Hu [27]	2017	2015.03-2017.01	40/40			22/18	23/17	RCT	①③⑤⑦
Li and Pang [28]	2020	2018.01-2019.08	30/30			12/18	14/16	RCT	①②③④⑤⑥⑦
Hu [25]	2017	2016.01-2017.11	15/15			8/7	10/5	RCT	①③⑤⑦
Si et al. [31]	2019	2017.12~2018.12	40/40			19/21	21/19	RCT	①③⑤
Yuan et al. [35]	2018	2016.01-2017.12	45/45	54-73	54-73	24/21	24/21	RCT	③⑤⑦
Hu et al. [26]	2020	2018.10-2019.10	55/55			34/21	33/22	RCT	①②③④⑤⑥⑦⑧⑨
Shi [30]	2020	2018.03-2019.03	35/35			21/14	20/15	RCT	①⑧⑨
Xie and Ran [33]	2019	2017.01-2019.01	43/43			23/20	26/17	RCT	⑧⑨
Li [29]	2020	2016.01-2018.12	24/24	43-86	43-86	6/18	6/18	RCT	①②③④⑤⑥⑦
Yang et al. [34]	2019	2018.06-2019.06	36/36			23/13	11/25	RCT	①⑧⑨

Note: Treat: treatment; Con: control; RCT: randomized controlled trial; NR: not reported; ①: adverse effect rate; ②: scores in self-care concept before nursing; ③: scores in self-care concept after nursing; ④: scores in self-care skills before nursing; ⑤: scores in self-care skills after nursing; ⑥: scores in self-care responsibility before nursing; ⑦: scores in self-care responsibility after nursing; ⑧: ESCA score before nursing; ⑨: ESCA score after nursing.