Review Article

Recent Fuzzy Generalisations of Rough Sets Theory: A Systematic Review and Methodological Critique of the Literature

Table 6

Distribution papers based on fuzzy set theories.

Author and referenceApplication fieldType of studyStudy categoryStudy contribution

 Gong and Zhang [105]Fuzzy systemProposedRough setsSuggested a novel extension of the rough set theory by integrating precision rough set theory variables and intuitionistic fuzzy-rough set theory
 Huang et al. [106]Intuitionistic fuzzyProposedRough sets and intuitionistic fuzzy setsProposed dominance intuitionistic fuzzy decision tables (DIFDT) based on a fuzzy-rough set approach
 Pawlak [3]Type 2 fuzzyProposedInterval type 2 fuzzy and rough setsIntegrated the interval type 2 fuzzy sets with rough set theory by using the axiomatic and constructive approaches
 Yang and Hinde [107]Fuzzy setProposedFuzzy set and R-fuzzy setsSuggested a new extension of fuzzy sets which was called -fuzzy sets as an element of rough sets
 Cheng et al. [108]Interval-valued fuzzyDevelopedInterval-valued fuzzy-rough setsProposed two new algorithms based on converse and positive approximations which were named MRBPA and MRBCA
 Zhang [109]Intuitionistic
fuzzy
ProposedFuzzy-rough sets and intuitionistic fuzzy setsProposed intuitionistic fuzzy-rough sets based on intuitionistic fuzzy coverings using intuitionistic fuzzy triangular norms and intuitionistic fuzzy implication operators
 Xue et al. [110]Fuzzy-rough C-means clusteringProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed a new fuzzy-rough semisupervised outlier detection (FRSSOD) method for helping some fuzzy-rough C-means clustering and labelled samples
 Zhang et al. [111]Intuitionistic
fuzzy
DevelopedIntuitionistic fuzzy-rough setsExamined the intuitionistic fuzzy-rough sets based on two universes, general binary relations, and an intuitionistic fuzzy implicator I and a pair of the intuitionistic fuzzy -norm
 Wei et al. [112]Fuzzy entropyDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsAnalyzed and evaluated the roughness of a rough set based on fuzzy entropy measures
 Wang and Hu [40]-fuzzy-rough setsProposedFuzzy-rough setsIntroduced the generalised -fuzzy-rough set for more generalisation of the notion of -fuzzy-rough set
 Huang et al. [113]Intuitionistic fuzzyDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsDeveloped a novel a new multigranulation rough set which was named the intuitionistic fuzzy multi-granulation rough set (IFMGRS)
 Wang [114]Type 2 fuzzy setsDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsExamined type 2 fuzzy-rough sets based on extended -norms and type 2 fuzzy relations in the convex normal fuzzy truth values
 Yang and Hu [115]Fuzzy -coveringDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsExamined the new fuzzy covering-based rough approach by defining the notion of a fuzzy -minimal description
 Lu et al. [116]Type 2 fuzzyDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsDefined type 2 fuzzy-rough sets based on a wavy-slice representation of type 2 fuzzy sets
 Chen et al. [117]Fuzzy similarity relationProposedFuzzy-rough setsIntroduced the geometrical interpretation and application of this type of membership functions
 D'eer et al. [118]Fuzzy relationsReviewedFuzzy-rough setsAssessed the most important fuzzy-rough approaches based on the literature
 Wang and Hu [38]Fuzzy granulesProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed the variable precision -fuzzy-rough set to remedy the defects of preexisting fuzzy-rough set approaches
 Ma [119]Fuzzy -coveringDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsPresented two novel kinds of fuzzy covering rough set approaches for bridges linking covering rough sets and fuzzy-rough theory
 Wang [29]Fuzzy topologyDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsInvestigated the topological characterizations of generalised fuzzy-rough sets regarding basic rough equalities
 He et al. [120]Fuzzy decision systemProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed the inconsistent fuzzy decision system and reductions and improved discernibility matrix-based algorithms to discover reducts
 Yang et al. [121]Bipolar fuzzy setsDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsGeneralized the fuzzy-rough approach based on two different universes introduced by Sun and Ma
 Zhang [122]Interval type 2ProposedFuzzy-rough setsSuggested a new model for interval type 2 rough fuzzy sets by employing constructive and axiomatic methods
 Bai et al. [123]Fuzzy decision rulesProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed an approach based on rough fuzzy sets for the extraction of spatial fuzzy decision rules from spatial data that simultaneously were two kinds of fuzziness, roughness, and uncertainties
 Zhao and Hu [124]Interval-valued fuzzy probabilisticDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsExamined the fuzzy and interval-valued fuzzy probabilistic rough sets within frameworks of fuzzy and interval-valued fuzzy probabilistic approximation spaces
 Huang et al. [125]Intuitionistic fuzzy-rough setsProposedFuzzy-rough setsIntroduced the intuitionistic fuzzy (IF) graded approximation space based on the IF graded neighborhood and discussed information entropy and rough entropy measures
 Khuman et al. [126]Type 2 fuzzy setDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsInvestigated the type 2 fuzzy sets and rough fuzzy sets to provide a practical means to express complex uncertainty without the associated difficulty of a type 2 fuzzy set
 Liu and Lin [127]Intuitionistic fuzzy-roughProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed a new intuitionistic fuzzy-rough approach based on the conflict distance
 Sun et al. [128]Interval-valued rough intuitionistic fuzzyProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed a new framework based on intuitionistic fuzzy-rough sets with the constructive approach
 Zhang et al. [129]Hesitant fuzzyProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed the common model based on rough set theory and dual hesitant fuzzy sets named dual hesitant fuzzy-rough sets by consideration of constructive and axiomatic models
 Hu [130]Interval-valued fuzzyDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsGeneralized to an integrative model based on considering interval-valued fuzzy sets and variable precision sets named generalized interval-valued fuzzy variable precision rough sets
 Zhao and Xiao [131]General type 2 fuzzy setsProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed a novel model by integrating general type 2 fuzzy sets, rough sets, and the α-plane representation method
 Yang et al. [132]Hesitant fuzzy setProposedFuzzy-rough setsInvestigated a novel fuzzy-rough model based on constructive and axiomatic approaches to introduce the hesitant fuzzy-rough set model
 Zhang et al. [133]Interval-valued hesitant fuzzy setProposedFuzzy-rough setsIntegrated interval-valued hesitant fuzzy sets with rough sets to introduce a novel model named the interval-valued hesitant fuzzy-rough set
 Wang and Hu [134]Fuzzy-valued operationsDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsExamined the fuzzy-valued operations and the lattice structures of the algebra of fuzzy values
 Zhao and Hu [36]IVF probabilityDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsExamined the decision-theoretic rough set (DTRS) method based on fuzzy and interval-valued fuzzy (IVF) probabilistic approximation spaces
 Mitra et al. [135]Fuzzy clusteringDevelopedFuzzy-rough setsDeveloped shadowed sets by combining fuzzy and rough clustering
 Chen et al. [136]Fuzzy rule interpolationProposedFuzzy-rough setsProposed a new rough fuzzy approach for handling, representation and utilisation of diverse levels of uncertainty in knowledge